Turn in your lineup card for MLB all-time team

[STAX]

1. CF Rickey Henderson
2. DH Ted Williams
3. LF Willie Mays
4. RF Babe Ruth
5. 1B Albert Pujols
6. 3B Harmon Killebrew
7. 2B Roberto Alomar
8. C Ivan Rodriguez
9. SS Omar Vizquel
P Greg Maddux
Manager Terry Francona

[smitch124]

1. CF Willie Mays
2. LF Barry Bonds
3. RF Roberto Clemente
4. DH Ted Williams
5. 1B Lou Gerhig
6. 3B Mike Schmidt
7. 2B Rogers Hornsby
8. C Johnny Bench
9. SS Ozzie Smith

[STAX]

1. CF Willie Mays
2. LF Barry Bonds
3. RF Roberto Clemente
4. DH Ted Williams
5. 1B Lou Gerhig
6. 3B Mike Schmidt
7. 2B Rogers Hornsby
8. C Johnny Bench
9. SS Ozzie Smith

I considered Schmidt and Ozzie, and bench came to mind. I actually might like Hornsby over Alomar now that I think about it... but dude cmon... no Babe Ruth? Who is your pitcher?

[smitch124]

I considered Schmidt and Ozzie, and bench came to mind. I actually might like Hornsby over Alomar now that I think about it... but dude cmon... no Babe Ruth? Who is your pitcher?

Pitcher is so tough, I don't know if I can pick one. Probably Koufax or Gibson. Regular season Maddux was incredible, but his post season performances were awful.

[Big Bear]

1. Brady Anderson CF
2. JT Snow 1B
3. Barry Bonds LF
4. Miguel Cabrerra RF
5. Tony Gwynn DH
6. Ivan Rodriguez C
7. Ken Cammaniti 3B
8. Brandon Phillips 2B
9. Ozzie Smith SS

[Big Bear]

Pitching- Chris Carpenter

[face]

lf barry bonds
cf ty cobb
rf babe ruth
dh ted williams
1b pete rose
2b jackie robinson
3b mike schmidt
c johny bench
ss chone figgins

[STAX]

Pitcher is so tough, I don't know if I can pick one. Probably Koufax or Gibson. Regular season Maddux was incredible, but his post season performances were awful.

Yeah, if this is picking a pitcher for just one game, I'd probably go Koufax, then Gibson, then Nolan Ryan, and special mention to Jack Morris (dude pitched a 10 inning complete game shutout in game 7 of 1991 world series, Twins won 1-0). If its just an all time team, I think Maddux deserves serious consideration... he is Peyton Manning of MLB pitchers... but if there's a sport where I can forgive post season mediocrity its baseball. Not so in football or basketball

[STAX]

Jack Morris was a terrific big game pitcher his entire career

[Footballtime]

Pedro in his prime over any pitcher.........

[STAX]

Pedro in his prime over any pitcher.........

RHP I agree, but Koufax in his prime. I forget about Pedro when it comes to these all time lists. I forget how dominant he was

[smitch124]

RHP I agree, but Koufax in his prime. I forget about Pedro when it comes to these all time lists. I forget how dominant he was

yes in his prime he was amazing, 1.00+ ERA in an offensive era. Pedro that is.

[STAX]

pedro wasnt great in the post season either though... 6-4 3.46 ERA

[jjgold]

I'm not gonna going to computer for 14 days and come up with this

Stax call me late tonight

[Big Bear]

I'm not gonna going to computer for 14 days and come up with this

Stax call me late tonight

JJ call me late night too

[k13]

So you don't have the best player ever on your team???

[Andy117]

LF - Ty Cobb
CF - Willie Mays
RF - Babe Ruth
1B - Jimmie Foxx
2B - Rogers Hornsby
3B - Mike Schmidt
SS - Alex Rodriguez
C - Mike Piazza
DH - Ted Williams

RHP - Tom Seaver
LHP - Randy Johnson

[TheGoldenGoose]

Yeah, if this is picking a pitcher for just one game, I'd probably go Koufax, then Gibson, then Nolan Ryan, and special mention to Jack Morris (dude pitched a 10 inning complete game shutout in game 7 of 1991 world series, Twins won 1-0). If its just an all time team, I think Maddux deserves serious consideration... he is Peyton Manning of MLB pitchers... but if there's a sport where I can forgive post season mediocrity its baseball. Not so in football or basketball

I had a dime riding that game on the Twins. The manager Tom Kelly tried to approach Morris in the dugout during the bottom of the ninth inning. Morris told him to "Get the fukk away from me. This is MY GAME and I'm going to finish it"

[pavyracer]

Baby Ruth would strike out every at bat if Randy Johnson was pitching to him. These lists make me laugh all the time.