Seaweed's Question of the Day: Who Has Had the Better Career To Date, Kobe or Duncan?

[Seaweed]

http://forum.cloud.static-files.com/vb4/images/smilies/20090121/popcorn.gif

[Smoke]

Black mamba

[The Giant]

Kobe has five rings, Duncan has four.
Advantage: Kobe.

Kobe top 10 all-time player, Duncan top 15 all-time.
Advantage: Kobe.

Kobe made way more money in endorsements, Duncan doesn't even talk.
Advantage: Kobe.

Kobe cheated, while Duncan got cheated on.
Advantage: Kobe.

The answer is obvious.

[Russian Rocket]

The answer is obvious.

not for Seaweed

[The Giant]

Rocket throwing haymakers at Seaweed.

[Russian Rocket]

Rocket throwing haymakers at Seaweed.

just some friendly jabs for now...the heymakers will come if he loses the tournament

[Seaweed]

Giant seems to have ended this discussion early, however, if San Antonio wins this year will it change your mind? I'm sure there are some Duncan fanatics here.

[ramones951]

Duncan has more MVP awards

Duncan has more Finals MVP's despite three fewer appearances

Duncan undefeated in the finals

If you want to go to the ring count, Kobe was the #2 option to Shaq for three of his rings; Duncan WAS the 'Shaq' of his championship squads.

[Seaweed]

ramones sharp as usual

[Smoke]

Black mamba

[Seaweed]

smoke stay focused on winning

[Smoke]

Kobe

[BadLuckSanta]

Duncan is due to come out of the closet. One of the weirdest celebs/athletes I've met. Guy had a tongue ring, very strange.

Kobe's career as a whole definitely more successful. Rape case made it impossible for him to win more regular season MVPs.

[Seaweed]

Why does Duncan have a tongue ring?

[BigDeem5]

Duncan has a longer schlong

[h3da]

Who is the rapist, ball hog?

[easyliving]

Different positions different type of players so can't really compare them. let me put it this way. Duncan is the greatest PF of all time. Where does Kobe rank in terms of his position?

[InTheDrink]

this thread never had any steam

[Catchn_Picks]

Kobe no question...but Duncan is a supremely classy player...the perfect definition of a team player and a star.

[TheMoneyShot]

Duncan Divorce = 1
Kobe Divorce = 0

Duncan did beat Kobe at one thing.

[GUNSHY]

Duncan Divorce = 1
Kobe Divorce = 0

Duncan did beat Kobe at one thing.

I see what you did there, lol!!!!!

[hotelis]

Kobe's career has drawn quite many controversies so I'm taking Duncan.

[t-wizzle]

Kobe Bryant.

[sheepz]

after thinking about it, i'd have to go with ducan slightly

I think most people are going with Kobe because he's in a big market team was always in the media whereas timmy d was the complete oppisite

[Seaweed]

Giant has some defending to do.....

[oldscho0led]

Kobe. End thread

[ThaTopMoron]

Duncan more consistent... players both great

[Tomasaurus]

Kobe: 2 Olympic golds

Duncan: 1 Olympic Bronze

Ouch

[Menses]

Duncan has more MVP awards

Duncan has more Finals MVP's despite three fewer appearances

Duncan undefeated in the finals

If you want to go to the ring count, Kobe was the #2 option to Shaq for three of his rings; Duncan WAS the 'Shaq' of his championship squads.

finally, a sensible answer to this growing topic....Kobe's first three rings must be ignored. The only one he earned was the Orlando Series in 09...now granted Kobe may have 3 more years left...but Timmy gets the nod thus far...

[Tomasaurus]

finally, a sensible answer to this growing topic....Kobe's first three rings must be ignored. The only one he earned was the Orlando Series in 09...now granted Kobe may have 3 more years left...but Timmy gets the nod thus far...

Lol at ignoring his first 3 rings, I seem to remember him ave'ing 30,7,6 in an nba finals in 2001

[William Walters]

finally, a sensible answer to this growing topic....Kobe's first three rings must be ignored. The only one he earned was the Orlando Series in 09...now granted Kobe may have 3 more years left...but Timmy gets the nod thus far...

Lol at ignoring his first 3 rings, I seem to remember him ave'ing 30,7,6 in an nba finals in 2001

Ignore Menses............kid is a fruitloop.

Kobe all day. But, there is no denying Duncan is/was one of the greats.

[RavensFan2k3]

Kobe has five rings, Duncan has four.
Advantage: Kobe.

Kobe top 10 all-time player, Duncan top 15 all-time.
Advantage: Kobe.

Kobe made way more money in endorsements, Duncan doesn't even talk.
Advantage: Kobe.

Kobe cheated, while Duncan got cheated on.
Advantage: Kobe.

The answer is obvious.

I lol'd

[pouyasophy]

i hate when people copy my threads...I was makin' the Kobe vs Duncan comparison when you were shittin pampers.

Duncan helped his team win rings.

Lakers won rings despite Kobe.

Duncan easily.

[pouyasophy]

Kobe: 2 Olympic golds

Duncan: 1 Olympic Bronze

Ouch

1 played with Americans.
1 played with the Virgin Islands.

[pouyasophy]

finally, a sensible answer to this growing topic....Kobe's first three rings must be ignored. The only one he earned was the Orlando Series in 09...now granted Kobe may have 3 more years left...but Timmy gets the nod thus far...

Kobe has quit in the finals vs the Pistons AND Celtics, vs the Suns, vs the Spurs, and DEFINITELY didn't deserve one of his MVPs over (Chris Paul). Tim Duncan helped his team win championships.

Also, Greg Popovich probably never hated Duncan as much as every teammate/coach Kobe has ever had has hated Kobe at one time or another.