Who is Better Ben Rapelisthberger or Eli Manning?

[Chi_archie]

just read this quote from Steve Serby's blog posted in Goblue1975's thread http://forum.sbrforum.com/players-ta...under-bus.html

"There aren’t many Giants fans who would trade Elite Eli for Big Ben Roethlisberger ... except for yesterday."

do Giant's fans here feel this way?

interesting discussion as both have the two rings and have had some ups and downs....

if you are an NFL GM or Coach, who would you have rather had the last decade?

who would you want going forward?

[rjt721]

Ben and it's not close

[ridims]

Ben. He can take multiple shots. Rape a chic and still play.

[Smoke]

I dont think ben raped anyone

I think the girl just wanted his cokk and money

To answer your question.... big ben > eli

[ridims]

I dont think ben raped anymore

I think the girl just wanted his cokk and money

To answer your question.... big ben > eli

Ben raped that whole Giant team yesterday.

[vigster]

Eli for sure

[Frisco]

Def Ben. His ability to improvise and extend plays separates him

[ridims]

Compare the arsenal at each QB's disposal. And O line.

[PAULYPOKER]

It is a toss up at this point in both of their respected careers.............

[White_Rodman]

Ben.

[ronzer]

[WvGambler]

Eli. They're equal on the field. Eli is a positive off the field. Ben is a cancer off the field....and that was even before the rapes.

Ben is hated in Pittsburgh by every restaurant and service worker.

[darkhat]

fuk the giants

eli manning is a joke

Guy basically won the fuckin lotto winning those superbowls

Has down syndrome, fuk him

[2daBank]

if im building a team not so sure there a qb i take before big ben...

[theAkathist]

if both teams plugged in kyle orton for an entire season the NYG would still do ok, and Pitt would go like 7-9

big ben

[borednaz]

fuk the giants

eli manning is a joke

Guy basically won the fuckin lotto winning those superbowls

Has down syndrome, fuk him

You know I've always thought that about both Manning's. Their facial expressions are always vacant and their foreheads are huge. They both look to be the direct result of to much inbreeding. IDK I always thought it was just me who saw that.

I would without question take Big Rape. I hate the Steelers , ABSOLUTELY FUKKIN HATE THEM! (Went BTJ On The Post). But you can literally transplant the Rapist to any team and he would still perform at the same if not better level.

[PAULYPOKER]

Nice to see all the love for Ben,since I am a homer.............

The QB draft class of 2004 Ben/Eli/Rivers is the best of all time,because of Superbowl Victories (4) this class surpasses the class of 83 Elway/Marino/Kelly who have (2) Superbowl victories..........

[k13]

Nice to see all the love for Ben,since I am a homer.............

The QB draft class of 2004 Ben/Eli/Rivers is the best of all time,because of Superbowl Victories (4) this class surpasses the class of 83 Elway/Marino/Kelly who have (2) Superbowl victories..........

1979 draft has 6 Super Bowl Victories. Montana/Simms

[Monitor-Tan]

too early to tell..

2004 class is still playing who knows if they will beat the 6, tie the 6, or fall short..

Plenty of potential in the 04 class for more rings.. They are still fairly young..

[edawg]

Ben by a c*nt hair