Tony Romo Or Michael Vick: Who Is The Most Overrated QB In The NFL?

DudleyDawson · 10-15-12, 01:36 PM

Vick imo. Vick is one of the just straight-up dumbest NFL players I've ever seen. Not joking. Vick and Vince Dumb in a place all their own. I think Romo has some talent just a shit O line...Romo will always be compared to the great Cowboy teams of the 90's.....them teams had the best O lines ever in NFL history.

BigDeem5 · 10-15-12, 01:37 PM

romo

vaas187 · 10-15-12, 01:41 PM

Vick for sure.

A lot of people think romo sucks, don't believe he is considered close to elite. A lot of people stroke Vicks shaft for no reason.

Shafted69 · 10-15-12, 01:43 PM

Vick has lead 1 of his teams to the NFC Championship game. Romo has not.

Romo is more over-rated.

k13 · 10-15-12, 01:45 PM

Tom Brady.

jjgold · 10-15-12, 01:51 PM

Romo

Vick has not been hailed as a great QB in his as 2nd stint

He actually is underrated

Nobody comparing him to Tom Brady types

Vick always has a shot to win games

2 years ago was passing in end zone vs packers in playoffs to win at end of game

He does make stupid choices which hurts him

Deuce · 10-15-12, 01:56 PM

Peyton Manning

Tired of watching the old prick on primetime tv.

ermzzy · 10-15-12, 01:58 PM

Both of them, Americans are no good.

paco · 10-15-12, 01:59 PM

Vick will get the last laugh this year

DudleyDawson · 10-15-12, 02:00 PM

Originally posted by paco

Vick will get the last laugh this year

lol

TexansFan · 10-15-12, 02:02 PM

Easily Vick.

darrell74 · 10-15-12, 02:05 PM

Vick is more overrated
Romo still overrated

Vick makes more stupid mistakes
bad fundamentals
accuracy issues

I live in New Mexico
dumb football fans here love Romo
so it looks easy to down Romo because just dumb fans like the Cowboys and Romo
All the smart Cowboy fans know Romo should have been gone a long time ago

Don't know about the smarter Eagle fans
do they still want him there?

jjgold · 10-15-12, 02:12 PM

Vick is underrated as a passer

Careless though

stefan084 · 10-15-12, 02:19 PM

vick has trouble knowing where blitzes are coming from,then holds the ball out as if he wants it to get stripped. oh yeah throwing late across the middle,taking unnecessary hits which keeps his fragile ass sitting on the bench for weeks...smart as a brick

AL1322 · 10-15-12, 02:24 PM

between these 2 guys i say romo..vick has been misused so badly with phili that they r ruining his career...vick was rg3 when rg3 was in gradeschool..even though i think hes a total pos for what he has done in his personal life..vick was a bad man when he was on the run for 1000 yards and defenses prepared for him differently..now he just stays in pocket and gets blasted.i blame the eagles for that not vick..romo is a bum always has been...to me the most overrated is jay cutler with phillip rivers a close 2nd

Mike Huntertz · 10-15-12, 04:11 PM

Vick the Dick

altieriflyers · 10-15-12, 05:26 PM

Originally posted by darrell74

Vick is more overrated
Romo still overrated

Vick makes more stupid mistakes
bad fundamentals
accuracy issues

I live in New Mexico
dumb football fans here love Romo
so it looks easy to down Romo because just dumb fans like the Cowboys and Romo
All the smart Cowboy fans know Romo should have been gone a long time ago

Don't know about the smarter Eagle fans
do they still want him there?

Romo by far.

I want Reid, Morhninweg and Vick out, ASAP. No superbowl with them at the helm.

gomiamigo · 10-15-12, 05:28 PM

Romo far and away #1.

Then Flacco.

Then Ryan who has never even won a playoff game.

Then Cutler.

Then Vick.

PAULYPOKER · 10-15-12, 05:31 PM

Vick:

KKoz9 · 10-15-12, 06:48 PM

I could name you a half dozen more overrated than either of those.

Romo gets bashed every time the wind blows so I don't see hoe he could possibly be overrated.

Vick has just always sucked.

DDT · 10-15-12, 06:54 PM

Vick

Louisvillekid1 · 10-15-12, 07:11 PM

Phillip Rivers is the most OVERRATED PLAYER IN THE NFL AND ITS NOT EVEN CLOSE!

Anybody who follows the game know what Vick and Romo are, so they shouldn't be overrated at this point...

People still think Rivers is a top tier qb, and I just have no clue why... Been saying it for years....

SportsPedagogy · 10-15-12, 07:26 PM

Haha the day in the life of a Romo hater:

Romo has a great game: regular season, doesn't matter, will choke when it counts.
Romo has a decent game: horrible game.
Romo has a bad game: worst QB ever, every game is just like this!

Romo leads a comeback : should not have been down in the first place!
Mannig leads a comeback: Amazing performance! ELI-te

Everybody forgets that Romo lead multiple comebacks last season (ask the redskins... Twice)
Everybody forgets Romo had three times as many touchdowns as picks last year. He threw the third least amount of picks per any starting QB last year... 4th most touchdown passes.

The only thing people can blame Romo for is team accomplishments. Lets be honest, no team is going to win with Jerry Jones as Owner/GM and Jason Garrett as Head Coach/OC.

stealthyburrito · 10-15-12, 07:30 PM

At this juncture in his career no one overrates romo. He is what he is: a mediocre qb.

Easily vick.

LT Profits · 10-15-12, 07:30 PM

Vick in a landslide, he is the most overrated player in the NFL at ANY position.

GunShard · 10-15-12, 09:32 PM

Vick is the worst QB in his division.

Pocket passers win Super Bowls, mobile quarterbacks do not.
Romo is a pocket passer, Vick is a mobile quarterback.

jjgold · 10-15-12, 09:38 PM

Can see how most have no clue about NFL

VICK was never rated as a great QB other than his 1st 5 years or so before prison

Hard to say someone overrated when he was never highly rated

Squares tonight out

Monte · 10-15-12, 09:39 PM

Is there actually anyone who thinks Romo is great?
So, how can he be overrated?

Chi_archie · 10-15-12, 09:40 PM

Romo is a bit behind Stafford in the over-rated for 2012 edition

slambam · 10-15-12, 09:45 PM

Originally posted by Shafted69

Vick has lead 1 of his teams to the NFC Championship game. Romo has not.

Romo is more over-rated.

Yea, 9 years and a prison term ago. He's brutal now, Eagles didn't get the same player that he used to be.

SportsPedagogy · 10-15-12, 09:49 PM

Originally posted by jjgold

Can see how most have no clue about NFL

VICK was never rated as a great QB other than his 1st 5 years or so before prison

Hard to say someone overrated when he was never highly rated

Squares tonight out

Vicks best year was when he took over as Eagles starting QB ....

stealthyburrito · 10-15-12, 09:49 PM

Originally posted by jjgold

Can see how most have no clue about NFL

VICK was never rated as a great QB other than his 1st 5 years or so before prison

Hard to say someone overrated when he was never highly rated

Squares tonight out

Fairly certain he was regarded as one of the worst pocket passing qbs in the league before his prison stint.

He had one good season in 2010 and now the "experts" have picked him to lead the eagles to division crowns last year and this.

SteelRain · 10-15-12, 09:50 PM

yep it's vick

just too dumb for the game

guy needs too realize when there is pressure throw ball away

tblues2005 · 10-15-12, 09:59 PM

That's a tough call here. Both of these guys have been horrible. One is completely washed up and Romo hasn't been any good this year either.