Aaron Rodgers Best QB in NFL : Nominated Post

[lakerboy]

Originally posted on 08/15/2011:

F off fantasy douchers. Way to ruin a bad thread with even worse conversation.
Thanks!
Fantasy football is horrible. It ruins the game. You lose what matters in the NFL (team fandom) with stupid f'n stats that mean ZERO in the end - start your own thread and piss off.

Until Rodgers goes 16-0 or wins a dickload of superbowls, he's nowhere near Brady. Brady cleared Montana years ago as the best QB in the NFL of ALL TIME. He didn't win a superbowl in 1 year with the best receiver corps he had - but he went the bowl and got beat by the best pass rush we've all ever seen and STILL almost won the ball game.

It's stupid to call out Rodgers on the level of Brady. Manning, IMO, can barely break the top 5 of all time. He's 4th or 5th best ever in the last 30 years.

To be the 'best', you gotta win a LOT in the post-season, and Manning has soooo few important HUGE games he's won in his career in the post season. Name Brady's running backs (if you name Faulk, you're a dumbass) and top receivers (1 and 2) when he won a Superbowl against the 'greatest show on turf'. When you can't think of 'that guy' off the top of your head, f off. Rodgers has a top receiver corps in the NFL, but D was why they won - just like Brady in his early years. Neither the Pats norst the Pack could run the ball with their victories. D made the Super Bowls happen, that's all I'm saying. It was some great QB play, also, but to put ANYONE ahead of Brady is just f'n dumb. Potential does NOT equal rings. Brady has 3.

nah. montana won 4 superbowls. brady has 3. montana was the best qb of the modern era. brady isnt in the same class. you didnt watch montana play or you wouldnt say this.