Matt Barkley >>> Andrew Luck

[racistrapist]

Someone do me a favor and bump this thread in a year or two when Matt Barkley turns out to be a better pro.

Andrew Luck will be good. Matt Barkley will be better.

Luck will be like Leinart

Barkley will be like Brees.

Have a nice day

[mikea33]

barkley throws seeds. luck has pocket awareness. both may be studs

[ExposingLines247]

im a barkley guy myself hes got that "it" factor

[Rous]

Whatever you guys are taking I want, because you guys sound silly. Barkley wont sniff the career Luck has as a pro. This thread is just dumb.

[racistrapist]

im a barkley guy myself hes got that "it" factor

Totally agree...he has a HUGE F***ing chip on his shoulder...

I was totally a believer in Luck last year but this year he didn't seem too special...Barkley has the urgency and desire that I can just see....and I was totally a skeptic until this year...I don't think I've ever seen someone improve so much like Barkley did this yr.

[racistrapist]

Whatever you guys are taking I want, because you guys sound silly. Barkley wont sniff the career Luck has as a pro. This thread is just dumb.

Wait 5 years and then you're gonna feel really stupid...watch

[onlooker]

Barkley = Leinart.

[Mr Handicapable]

I'm from Indy....if Peyton is healthy enough they should trade down a few picks and get Justin Blackmon (another TO without the circus act) then draft Kirk Cousins in the 2nd round. If Peyton can't go then trade down for RG3. Luck doesn't have the arm strength imo to be great....I agree with Phil Simms. I also would offer the Rams a trade for Bradford and some picks, etc. I still think that kid can be special.

[Rous]

Suck for Luck!!!!!!!!

[tatddy]

I started to take this seriously until you compared Luck to Leinart. Leinart lacks discipline, mental acuity and many other leadership abilities a top QB needs. Luck is a born leader, a relentless worker, and has no off the field aspirations.

[onlooker]

[adila1401]

[Holtgetsback]

I'm from Indy....if Peyton is healthy enough they should trade down a few picks and get Justin Blackmon (another TO without the circus act) then draft Kirk Cousins in the 2nd round. If Peyton can't go then trade down for RG3. Luck doesn't have the arm strength imo to be great....I agree with Phil Simms. I also would offer the Rams a trade for Bradford and some picks, etc. I still think that kid can be special.

Glad u aren't the GM pal

no offense

[detroitlionsfan]

i dont see whats so special about barkley

then again i didnt with luck either and he looks to be better than rg3 id say

[TheAwesome116]

This honestly might be one of the most asinine threads I have read on this board. How anyone (besides a USC homer who knows very little about football) could argue that Matt Barkley is better than Andrew Luck is beyond me.

[Enkhbat]

lol USC just keeps losing