Brady, Manning, Roethlisberger

[Scorpion]

Completion%: Brady - 62.5%, Manning - 64.4%, Roethlisberger - 63.1%

Yards/attempt: Brady - 7.1, Manning - 7.4, Roethlisberger - 8.0

Yards/completion: Brady - 11.5, Manning - 11.5, Roethlisberger - 12.7

TD%: Brady - 4.8%, Manning - 5.3%, Roethlisberger - 5.1%

INT%: Brady - 2.5%, Manning - 2.9%, Roethlisberger - 3.1%

PLAYOFFS:

QB Rating: Brady - 85.7, Manning - 88.4, Roethlisberger - 88.7

YPA: Brady - 6.46, Manning - 7.51, Roethlisberger - 7.95

TD%: Brady - 4.40%, Manning - 4.04%, Roethlisberger - 5.48%

Record: Brady - 14-5, Manning - 9-10, Roethlisberger - 9-2

[Sildenafil]

Please tell me you don't think Rapistberger is a better QB than Brady and Manning...??

[t-wizzle]

I'd go...

1) Brady
2) Roethlisberger
3) Manning

[Bobby Baroo]

I am becoming one of those that is believing that Big Ben is better qb than Brady or Manning. I've always thought Manning was the best but Ben has as many playoff victories as him and more superbowl rings and qb's are always evaluated on wins. Ben's playoff winning % is higher than Brady's. And if you had Brady and Ben switch teams would both be as good? There is no way Brady would survive. Absolutley no way! Ben's style of play enables him to play and succeed on any team. Brady needs protection. He cannot scramble and lets be honest; if you get in his face he simply throws it away or falls to the ground. Hence the nickname Tom Baby. Manning is the smartest qb around but why do all the super bow wins elude him? Ben isn't mentioned in the top five usually and at most the top three, but when it's time to produce he is always there. Defense or no defense on his side, no defense wants the ball in his hands because of his scrambling ability. It's the X factor that none of the others have. I think with some rings, Rodgers can enter the mix but that will take a few yrs. At least two anyhow. No one can argue Manning but I'll argue Brady forever. He is blessed with the right coach and right offense.

[Dave ATS]

Awesome stats bro, confirms what I suspected. Big Ben is underrated.

[samdapatriotsfan]

I am glad Tom brought some SB's to the Patriots but I would not disagree that Big Ben is better than Brady. His escapability alone make him so dangerous.

His ability to extend plays breaks down even the best defenses. And talk about clutch, how many times has Big Ben driven the length of the field with his team down and scored to give them the win.

Just something to think about.

[kcDdegenerate]

Not a fair comparison because Manning never had the caliber of defense,running game or the head coaches Big Ben has

[Scorpion]

Brady and Manning rattle when they get hit.
TOM BRADY IS A FRAUD!
Brady has been choking in the playoffs since 2005

05- With the game in hand, Brady throws a horrible interception to Champ Bailey which is returned deep into Pats territory before fumbling. Brady plays a terrible game as they are embarrassed 27-13 by Jake Plummer.

06-After owning the Colts in the 1st half and taking an early 21-3, the Patriots managed to put together one of the biggest chokejobs in nfl history. After the Colts took the lead late in the 4th, Brady threw an ill-advised interception to seal the Colts victory.

07-All I have to say is that they went 18-1.... and lost to the Giants

08- Didn't make playoffs...Brady's a sissy and couldn't stay healthy

09- Blown out at home in 1st playoff game- Brady played terrible, throwing several interceptions.

10- Dominated at home in 1st playoff game by an amateur quarterback


Do you really think this pretty c_cksucker would have those 2 superbowls by just a FG if they had not CHEATED!???

[Grits n' Gravy]

Brady and Manning rattle when they get hit.
TOM BRADY IS A FRAUD!
Brady has been choking in the playoffs since 2005

05- With the game in hand, Brady throws a horrible interception to Champ Bailey which is returned deep into Pats territory before fumbling. Brady plays a terrible game as they are embarrassed 27-13 by Jake Plummer.

06-After owning the Colts in the 1st half and taking an early 21-3, the Patriots managed to put together one of the biggest chokejobs in nfl history. After the Colts took the lead late in the 4th, Brady threw an ill-advised interception to seal the Colts victory.

07-All I have to say is that they went 18-1.... and lost to the Giants

08- Didn't make playoffs...Brady's a sissy and couldn't stay healthy

09- Blown out at home in 1st playoff game- Brady played terrible, throwing several interceptions.

10- Dominated at home in 1st playoff game by an amateur quarterback


Do you really think this pretty c_cksucker would have those 2 superbowls by just a FG if they had not CHEATED!???

Actually he has 3 rings all won by 3 points. He was major factor in all 3 wins. Steelers beat Seattle despite Ben and with assists from refs. Ben is a very good qb, but not as good as either Brady or Manning. Ben is helped from playing in a run first offense. Indy and Pats rely on their qbs to win the game.

Lose the Brady envy and be objective.

[Scorpion]

actually he has 3 rings all won by 3 points. He was major factor in all 3 wins. Steelers beat seattle despite ben and with assists from refs. Ben is a very good qb, but not as good as either brady or manning. Ben is helped from playing in a run first offense. Indy and pats rely on their qbs to win the game.

Lose the brady envy and be objective.

no rings after spygate

brady has been choking in the playoffs since 2005

brady is a fraud

[Grits n' Gravy]

no rings after spygate

brady has been choking in the playoffs since 2005

brady is a fraud

A fraud wouldn't set single season TD pass record. A fraud wouldn't go 300+ passes without a pick. Get over your Brady envy. Maybe if you ask him nicely enough, he'll bang your mom if you ever leave your parents' house.

[Scorpion]

**** Brady, you don't have to suck his cock just because the entire NE team has been f****** your mommy in the ass boy!

[kcDdegenerate]

its funny how none of the pros that get paid to analyze football dont share your view of Brady...I guess you are the only one that knows football and the qb position Scorpion...you should apply for a job at espn

[Scorpion]

They never talk about spygate either

Brady is a fraud

[ebbearsfb1]

all cause the espn experts no everything... those fools just get paid to yap none of them know whats going on there....

bottom line is you could take any of those 3 and be happy at the end of the day... me personally i'd take ben or a rodgers first as they both have some mobility and thats to my liking, but everyone can have different options


and to say well if brady had this or manning had that ... well same could be said for just about ne body

[Grits n' Gravy]

**** Brady, you don't have to suck his cock just because the entire NE team has been f****** your mommy in the ass boy!

such anger. just come out of the closet. you'll probably be a far less bitter boy.

[Scorpion]

such anger. Just come out of the closet. You'll probably be a far less bitter boy.

lol
hes mad

[rsnnh12]

For those saying Brady is terrible under pressure, needs lots of time to throw, etc-

In 2010-
Against 5 rushers- 101.3 QB rating, 8.2 YPA in 100 attempts
Against 6 or more rushers- 153.8 QB rating, 13.2 YPA in 25 attempts

That's right, 153.8. He SUCKS when he gets blitzed

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703791904576076211648454424.html

[Sildenafil]

08- Didn't make playoffs...Brady's a sissy and couldn't stay healthy

You can say what you want against the guy but did you see the tackle that took him out?? Quite unfair to say he couldn't stay healthy that year when his knee got blown out by a cheap shot...

[Conan]

Completion%: Brady - 62.5%, Manning - 64.4%, Roethlisberger - 63.1%

Yards/attempt: Brady - 7.1, Manning - 7.4, Roethlisberger - 8.0

Yards/completion: Brady - 11.5, Manning - 11.5, Roethlisberger - 12.7

TD%: Brady - 4.8%, Manning - 5.3%, Roethlisberger - 5.1%

INT%: Brady - 2.5%, Manning - 2.9%, Roethlisberger - 3.1%

PLAYOFFS:

QB Rating: Brady - 85.7, Manning - 88.4, Roethlisberger - 88.7

YPA: Brady - 6.46, Manning - 7.51, Roethlisberger - 7.95

TD%: Brady - 4.40%, Manning - 4.04%, Roethlisberger - 5.48%

Record: Brady - 14-5, Manning - 9-10, Roethlisberger - 9-2

Where did you get these stats because there off acording to NFL.com?