McNabb = early season MVP

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • goldengoat
    SBR MVP
    • 11-25-05
    • 3239

    #1
    McNabb = early season MVP
    I feel asleep so i didn't hear if they talked about McNabb being a MVP candidate in the early season on MNF but in my eyes he is #1 right now

    he is carrying that offense

    i know westbrook does more than his share too but McNabb is way more valuable than westbrook

    probably gonna be down to him and Manning
  • McBa1n
    SBR MVP
    • 01-02-06
    • 2642

    #2
    LOL - it might be, but I have to agree with Irvin in the pre-game naming "Steve Smith" (hahaha - Irvin is VERY right, though, he understands the value of elite playmakers).
    Carolina, my pre-season pick (that was before everyone on espn picked them..grrrrr), is 2-0 with him and almost unbeatable now.

    If Caro beats the Bears, then I KNOW Stevey-boy is the MVP.

    However, if I had to pick a REAL MVP right now, it's Steve McNair, hands down - no arguments.
    4-0 with that team says a LOT.
    That's not even CLOSE to the best D they've fielded in the last 5-6 years by 3-4 players.
    Comment
    • turtlenthehouse
      SBR Rookie
      • 09-25-06
      • 4

      #3
      Michael Vick would be my choice. His rushing total is in the top 10. Surprising for a QB.
      Comment
      • begolf25
        SBR Sharp
        • 11-09-05
        • 315

        #4
        Originally posted by turtlenthehouse
        Michael Vick would be my choice. His rushing total is in the top 10. Surprising for a QB.
        I don't think just because he is in the top 10 in rushing makes this guy MVP. He is a below average passer. Every once in awhile he will have a great game then tell the media to get off his back. Then go back and have a 10 for 22, 150 yard day. Atlanta could still be 3-1 without Vick.

        As far as McNair goes he definately belongs in the conversation. The Ravens are probably 2-2 at best with Boller still running the show. He has had some slow starts this year but with the game on the line has made some huge throws.
        Comment
        • Razz
          SBR Hall of Famer
          • 08-22-05
          • 5632

          #5
          I like McNabb, and he is playing well, but the Eagles have beaten the Texans, 49ers, and Packers - three of the worst defensive teams in the NFL (the Giants are pretty bad too). A little early for this kind of talk really, but let's see if he can step up against the Cowboys and other premier teams.
          I still say it's LT until someone really steps it up.
          Comment
          • John Galt1
            SBR Hustler
            • 08-23-06
            • 55

            #6
            not sold on mcnabb yet, I want to see him against dallas D
            Comment
            • psycho44
              SBR High Roller
              • 07-08-06
              • 240

              #7
              T.O. for MVP. Can't remember the last time a Wide Receiver was MVP but T.O nevertheless.
              Comment
              • bigboydan
                SBR Aristocracy
                • 08-10-05
                • 55420

                #8
                Originally posted by John Galt
                not sold on mcnabb yet, I want to see him against dallas D
                I don't think the Dallas D would really be a good judge either. I just don't think he has the talent around him to make that serious push for this award. Mcnabb would just have to carry this team on his shoulders and generate like 80% of there offense, and I still wouldn't be convinced.
                Comment
                • John Galt1
                  SBR Hustler
                  • 08-23-06
                  • 55

                  #9
                  winning w/o westbrook was a nice start, but I dont think theres a clear MVP candidate quite yet, Kurt Warner maybe
                  Comment
                  • begolf25
                    SBR Sharp
                    • 11-09-05
                    • 315

                    #10
                    Originally posted by John Galt
                    Kurt Warner maybe
                    LOL...he gets my vote.

                    As everyone has said it is early but it is very hard to argue what Clinton Portis has meant to the Redskins after having him back at full strength the last two weeks. Totally different team with him in the line up.
                    Comment
                    • MPMEYER1982
                      SBR Hustler
                      • 08-27-06
                      • 98

                      #11
                      Originally posted by goldengoat
                      I feel asleep so i didn't hear if they talked about McNabb being a MVP candidate in the early season on MNF but in my eyes he is #1 right now

                      he is carrying that offense

                      i know westbrook does more than his share too but McNabb is way more valuable than westbrook

                      probably gonna be down to him and Manning
                      Let's see, Texans, Giants, 49ers and Packers were the stout defenses he has gone against. Nope, not convinced at all.
                      Comment
                      • Zikaris
                        SBR High Roller
                        • 08-27-06
                        • 139

                        #12
                        Originally posted by MPMEYER1982
                        Let's see, Texans, Giants, 49ers and Packers were the stout defenses he has gone against. Nope, not convinced at all.
                        Yeah he needs to be tested against some real defense.
                        Comment
                        SBR Contests
                        Collapse
                        Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                        Collapse
                        Working...