Originally Posted by
terrortwylight
I'm not offended at all. I'm probably the last person on this forum you'd be able to successfully offend, especially talking race in America. My issue is an intellectual one. Everything there is not true.
First, the IQ test itself is standardized. There's this idea that if an individual is born here in the US and he speaks English, then he develops and lives in the same culture as everyone else. This is a very simplified way of looking at a very complex thing. Cognitive performance is never independent of culture. In recent years, we've learned definitively that linguistic structure controls the way people think and learn.
With any standardized test, there are going to be issues anyway. I know plenty of bright dudes who bombed on their ACT or SAT, did just one retake, and then got accepted at Michigan State. There is no exception with the IQ test. There is considerable evidence that there exists a cultural bias within the test itself. The notorious 15 point standard deviation between whites and blacks that was once roundly cited (and explained as independent of culture) has been substantially shrinking since the 70's.
In other words, my issue is with the assertion itself that whites are more intelligent than blacks.
The idea that an IQ test is comprehensive or accurate is laughable. Intelligence is defined as a "mental capacity that involves the ability to reason, plan, solve problems, think abstractly, comprehend ideas, and learn from experience." You can't go down to Best Buy or a hardware store and buy software that measures your ability to do any of those things. How do you even quantify those traits? Intelligence is not an object, it's a concept.
I would personally argue that the only meaningful way to measure intelligence is operational. Throw me actual statistics that say black head coaches are losing at a higher rate than white head coaches (some of you have already provided great trends for this and it's very interesting to look at). I'll happily accept those figures because you can't argue performance. However, my only counterpoint to that would be it's not like every white head coach is Bear Fukking Bryant.
Hopefully this helps some of you understand why the racist garbage means so little to me. It's not going to help me or aid me (or any of us) in any way whatsoever. I believe statistics will.