🏒 NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Predictions Today: Best Bets to Score for Monday, May 11

Nathan MacKinnon, looking for his fifth straight game with a goal, leads our NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today.
Colorado Avalanche center Nathan MacKinnon (29) reacts after scoring a goal as we provide our NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today.
Pictured: Colorado Avalanche center Nathan MacKinnon (29) reacts after scoring a goal as we provide our NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today. Photo by Ron Chenoy via Imagn Images.
Enjoying SBR content? Add us as a preferred source on your Google account Add as a preferred source on Google

Though we only have a single game on Monday's NHL playoff slate, every star-studded Avalanche vs. Wild matchup is a treat for hockey fans.

My NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today include targeting superstars Nathan MacKinnon and Kirill Kaprizov, alongside a gold-medal winner due for a goal in this series.


🏒 NHL anytime goal scorer predictions today: May 11

See all of our experts' NHL picks based on the latest NHL odds.; picks rated on a 1-to-5 star confidence scale based on betting value.

💰 Anytime Goal Scorer ⚖️ Bet size 🧠 Why I'm making this bet
Nathan MacKinnon, Avalanche (+105 via FanDuel) 0.2u -> 0.39u On a four-game playoff goal-scoring streak.
Kirill Kaprizov, Wild (+130 via FanDuel) 0.2u -> 0.43u Scored in two straight games while averaging four SOGs.
Brock Nelson, Avalanche (+300 via FanDuel) 0.2u -> 0.66u Due for a goal with -1.9 goals scored below expected this playoffs.

Total wagered: 0.60 units | Max profit: 1.48 units

📃 Affiliate disclosure

Sportsbook Review may receive a commission if you sign up through our links. Not intended for use in MA. Bonuses not applicable in Ontario. 21+ only. (Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER)


🥅 Best anytime goal scorer pick today

Nathan MacKinnon (+105) at Wild

Nathan MacKinnon continues to own this matchup against the Wild. When you include the regular season, MacKinnon has scored at least once in six out of seven games versus the Wild this campaign. And he carries a four-game playoff goal-scoring streak heading into Monday night.

Even when the Avalanche are largely stymied offensively, as they were in Game 3, MacKinnon lit the lamp with Colorado's lone goal. At this point, I'm comfortable backing MacKinnon in any game at plus-money odds. FanDuel offers the top value among the best sports betting sites at +105.


🔥 More NHL goal scorer picks

Kirill Kaprizov (+130) vs. Avalanche

We called the Kirill Kaprizov goal-scoring breakout this time last week, and the Wild superstar has since scored in two straight games while tallying four shots on goal in each.

As elite as Kaprizov's passing has become, his most valuable asset is his lethal shot. When the chips are down, as they will be in tonight's crucial Game 4, he won't shy away from seeking a snipe of his own. I'm backing Kaprizov to make it three straight games with a goal at FanDuel's +130 odds.

Our Gary Pearson targets Kaprizov to tally an assist instead as part of his top NHL player props today.

Brock Nelson (+300) at Wild

Brock Nelson has been the most snake-bitten shooter on the Avalanche this postseason, leading the team with minus-1.9 goals scored below expected, according to MoneyPuck.

That's because he's only scored once this playoff run despite being among Colorado's leaders in high-danger shots and medium-danger shots, demonstrating his lack of scoring has nothing to do with an ability to generate solid scoring chances.

I know Nelson - who scored 33 in the regular season - has a better scoring touch than this recent stretch indicates, and I'm backing him to convert one of his many chances tonight in Game 4 at FanDuel's +300 odds.


🚀 Best NHL goal scorer parlay

Combining all three of my goal scorer picks for Monday gives us +1786 odds at FanDuel, the best price among the best sports betting apps. The long odds demonstrate how difficult this will be to nail, so I'm only wagering 0.1 units on it.

💵 NHL goal scorer parlay picks

  • Nathan MacKinnon (+105)
  • Kirill Kaprizov (+130)
  • Brock Nelson (+300)

Best odds: +1786 via FanDuel (0.1u -> 1.8u)


💵 My betting record for NHL picks

All NHL picks, including SGPs, have been tracked since April 16.

Bet type Record Net profit ROI
Overall 22-16-2 +4.48 units ✅ 21.18% ✅
Player props 8-6 -0.05 units ❌ -0.7% ❌
Goal scorer picks 7-17 -1.57 units ❌ -30.78% ❌
Parlays 4-5-1 +1.06 units ✅ 44.17% ✅

💡 How I'm betting NHL goal scorer picks today

Follow all of our NHL analysis and expert predictions this season.

It's not often that I'm comfortable making three goal scorer predictions from the same game, but there's too much offensive talent in this matchup for me to shy away from doing so. With all three games in this series featuring at least six goals, there should be plenty of scorers tonight.

Goal scorer picks can be difficult, as represented by thee plus-money odds. It's important not to get carried away with your bet sizes. That's why I'm wagering my standard 0.2 units on each. Nailing two of three predictions would result in a profitable night, while winning all three would bring home nearly 1.5 units in profit. Bankroll management is crucial in sports betting, so be smart with yours.

We also dive further into this game as part of our Avalanche vs. Wild prediction.