Manning vs Brady, Cast your vote!

[PAULYPOKER]

Manning would never fit on a Belichick coached team........

Belichick would never give any QB the reins.......

Manning is a "soft coach" playah........

Dungy
Caldwell
Fox

[jgallagher80]

brady if your talking about a winner

[GenosPicks]

I love both QB's n this game but i think in the end LUCK can't do anything to help his terrible Colt's D stop the Pats.. the joke in this week's vid was they should call the Colt's D the Colt's E because just like E they let everyone score no matter how ugly...

here's the thread

http://forum.sbrforum.com/nominated-posts/2767938-genos-picks-divisional-playoffs-going-sea-8-ne-7-car-1-sd-9-a.html

[packerd_00]

I want to see what Manning can do this year in the playoffs,if he sh!ts the bed again,my vote goes to Brady.

[Rangers901]

Brady = Over rated.

He'll do his typical beat up on the worst teams in the league during the regular seaosn, then get outplayed by mediocre QB's in the playoffs.

Post tuck rule, spygate, constantly fielding a top 3 defense, Brady hasn't done a single thing in the playoffs.

During this span, he's been outplayed by Jake Plummer, Eli Manning, Joe Flacco, Mark Sanchez, etc.

His completions on passes over 20 yards is downright pathetic, one of the worst all time in the playoffs.

The last time the Patriots were even somewhat relevant in the playoffs, Brady went 0-12 with 2 INT's on balls thrown further than 20 yards.

Check down Tom can run that up tempo, short pass offense against the horrible teams, but it doesn't seem to work all that well once they get to the playoffs and have to play teams that aren't horrible.

Brady lovers will bash me, but the truth is the truth.

Brady is the most over rated QB of all time. Sure, I'd put him on a top 20 list of all time, but without Hoody, this guy would be nothing.

All the haters and bashers will realize what people mean when Brady retires, another scrub enters the starting QB position, and the Pats pick up right where they left off.

Remember people, shitty Matt Cassell stepped in and took the Pats to the playoffs with an 11-5 record, all this without making a single start since high school.

What happened to Cassell since? I think we all know that answer.

Brady goes down, Pats go 11-5.
Manning goes down, Colts go 2-14.

People are not only unintelligent, but illogical, STOP counting Rings as a way to judge a qb. Football teams consist of a 52 man roster. Everyone quickly forgets in the years Brady won, he was nothing but a game manager with a top 3 defense.

People who think Brady is better than Manning are simply ignorant. It's no mystery that when polls are done by past greats and current players, Manning is always #1 over Brady. Yet, scrubs on SBR think that they're more knowledgeable than the people who not only played at that level, but against both QB's.

[Kyle_Fitta]

Brady = Over rated.

He'll do his typical beat up on the worst teams in the league during the regular seaosn, then get outplayed by mediocre QB's in the playoffs.

Post tuck rule, spygate, constantly fielding a top 3 defense, Brady hasn't done a single thing in the playoffs.

During this span, he's been outplayed by Jake Plummer, Eli Manning, Joe Flacco, Mark Sanchez, etc.

His completions on passes over 20 yards is downright pathetic, one of the worst all time in the playoffs.

The last time the Patriots were even somewhat relevant in the playoffs, Brady went 0-12 with 2 INT's on balls thrown further than 20 yards.

Check down Tom can run that up tempo, short pass offense against the horrible teams, but it doesn't seem to work all that well once they get to the playoffs and have to play teams that aren't horrible.

Brady lovers will bash me, but the truth is the truth.

Brady is the most over rated QB of all time. Sure, I'd put him on a top 20 list of all time, but without Hoody, this guy would be nothing.

All the haters and bashers will realize what people mean when Brady retires, another scrub enters the starting QB position, and the Pats pick up right where they left off.

Remember people, shitty Matt Cassell stepped in and took the Pats to the playoffs with an 11-5 record, all this without making a single start since high school.

What happened to Cassell since? I think we all know that answer.

Brady goes down, Pats go 11-5.
Manning goes down, Colts go 2-14.

People are not only unintelligent, but illogical, STOP counting Rings as a way to judge a qb. Football teams consist of a 52 man roster. Everyone quickly forgets in the years Brady won, he was nothing but a game manager with a top 3 defense.

People who think Brady is better than Manning are simply ignorant. It's no mystery that when polls are done by past greats and current players, Manning is always #1 over Brady. Yet, scrubs on SBR think that they're more knowledgeable than the people who not only played at that level, but against both QB's.

First of all, I think it's a fully understood that Joe Namath will go down as the most overrated QB of all time. Calling Brady the most overrated QB of all time is one of the most illogical things I've ever heard. Sure, Tom Brady had defenses that helped him win SBs. Not going to deny that. However, Tom Brady has played with only a small amount of HOF caliber offensive weapons. And all of them, a la Corey Dillon, Randy Moss, were at the end of their careers. Before Moss came to New England, he had his worst year ever. Brady has thrown to small, systematic WRS throughout his career.

By the way, Matt Cassel has proven that he isn't that bad of a QB. He took the Chiefs to the playoffs.

Every elite QB has also had an elite WR. Montana had Moss, Manning had Harrison and Wayne, etc. etc.

And the reason Brady was "outplayed" by those QBS you mentioned was because they had top-tier defenses. The Patriots have had less-than-stellar, near the bottom ranked statistically defenses.

[Husker36]

Manning manning manning

[ThaTopMoron]

how about Peyton with this 2006 playoff defense vs Brady with is 2007 record offense

what happens? SB win vs SB loss

all that needs to be said

no defense, nobody wins jack shit in the NFL

fukkn idiots dime a dozen

didn't even compare head coaches and that stubborn fool Dungy vs Belichick

[ThaTopMoron]

Brady = Over rated.

He'll do his typical beat up on the worst teams in the league during the regular seaosn, then get outplayed by mediocre QB's in the playoffs.

Post tuck rule, spygate, constantly fielding a top 3 defense, Brady hasn't done a single thing in the playoffs.

During this span, he's been outplayed by Jake Plummer, Eli Manning, Joe Flacco, Mark Sanchez, etc.

His completions on passes over 20 yards is downright pathetic, one of the worst all time in the playoffs.

The last time the Patriots were even somewhat relevant in the playoffs, Brady went 0-12 with 2 INT's on balls thrown further than 20 yards.

Check down Tom can run that up tempo, short pass offense against the horrible teams, but it doesn't seem to work all that well once they get to the playoffs and have to play teams that aren't horrible.

Brady lovers will bash me, but the truth is the truth.

Brady is the most over rated QB of all time. Sure, I'd put him on a top 20 list of all time, but without Hoody, this guy would be nothing.

All the haters and bashers will realize what people mean when Brady retires, another scrub enters the starting QB position, and the Pats pick up right where they left off.

Remember people, shitty Matt Cassell stepped in and took the Pats to the playoffs with an 11-5 record, all this without making a single start since high school.

What happened to Cassell since? I think we all know that answer.

Brady goes down, Pats go 11-5.
Manning goes down, Colts go 2-14.

People are not only unintelligent, but illogical, STOP counting Rings as a way to judge a qb. Football teams consist of a 52 man roster. Everyone quickly forgets in the years Brady won, he was nothing but a game manager with a top 3 defense.

People who think Brady is better than Manning are simply ignorant. It's no mystery that when polls are done by past greats and current players, Manning is always #1 over Brady. Yet, scrubs on SBR think that they're more knowledgeable than the people who not only played at that level, but against both QB's.

I didn't get to read this until just now because of holding up my end on my losing bet.

It's like this guy is me posting on another account... isn't that called something along the lines of a "ghost" account by people around here?

Feels good to know that others on this planet have seen enough football to see the light and realize the truth about Tom Brady.

[ThaTopMoron]

Tom Brady 4-0 in playoffs when he has ZERO passing touchdowns.

Nuff said. Teams win games with a full team effort.

[will2survive]

If Manning wins the Super Bowl this season....then a draw. If not, Brady.

[cmendo2005]

Definitly manning

[kaalhode]

Brady

[Rangers901]

If you're choosing Brady, you're sports fan, not a sports fanatic. That, or you lack any type of significant knowledge.

Brady lovers are mainly people who don't possess the mental capacity to look beyond the surface.

By the end of his career, he'll be the leader of the YAC category, and no one will be close.

Manning has almost 15,000 more Air Yards than Brady, yes, that's right, 15,000. For an average QB, that's about 5 seasons worth of yards.

It's easy to throw 3-7 yard slants 90% of the time, it's like a college system.

It was always, Brady wasn't surrounded by greatness, he made players great. Really? So tell me, this season, when he finally has a lower tiered talent group, why he's not able to perform at any level higher than mediocre?

[MoneyzForSportz]

Manning

[Balco10]

Brady

[tomFF]

Manning

[GunShard]

[Fred The Hammer]

Rodney Harrison said the Pats win 3 SBs w/PFM too but how can he compare to the football genius of people like lakerboy!!

[Fred The Hammer]

I will say if Brady outplays Manning this Sunday then its a no-brainer. If PM wins the SB and becomes the first QB to win the SB w/2 diff teams and 5 time MVP. Its his!!

[slacker00]

I will say if Brady outplays Manning this Sunday then its a no-brainer. If PM wins the SB and becomes the first QB to win the SB w/2 diff teams and 5 time MVP. Its his!!

If Brady gets 6 TDs from his RBs again, he won't even need 200 yards passing. Fantasy football season is over.

[CashItIn]

I'll take "Eli Manning" over Brady all day, ty.

[NYCWinner]

" Brady's wife has a face of a man" ?? lol Jealous much? I hate the Pats with a passion but you must respect them and what they have done. Even if Den beats NE this week Brady is still better. He hasn't cause me any money betting on him either. Brady is also way better looking, better dresser,has a hot and rich wife, he basically lives in a castle, doesn't whore himself out on Papa John ads , and I bet Brady's dog does tricks around Peyton's too!!

[packerd_00]

" Brady's wife has a face of a man" ?? lol Jealous much? I hate the Pats with a passion but you must respect them and what they have done. Even if Den beats NE this week Brady is still better. He hasn't cause me any money betting on him either. Brady is also way better looking, better dresser,has a hot and rich wife, he basically lives in a castle, doesn't whore himself out on Papa John ads , and I bet Brady's dog does tricks around Peyton's too!!

What do you think Manning lives in,an outhouse.

[Fred The Hammer]

" Brady's wife has a face of a man" ?? lol Jealous much? I hate the Pats with a passion but you must respect them and what they have done. Even if Den beats NE this week Brady is still better. He hasn't cause me any money betting on him either. Brady is also way better looking, better dresser,has a hot and rich wife, he basically lives in a castle, doesn't whore himself out on Papa John ads , and I bet Brady's dog does tricks around Peyton's too!!

Manning opened up a childrens hospital here in Indy prob about the same time Brady dumped his pregnant baby mama for butterface. Yeah Brady is great!

[Fred The Hammer]

If Brady gets 6 TDs from his RBs again, he won't even need 200 yards passing. Fantasy football season is over.

I don't see NEs running game taking over here...I'd be shocked if Brady isn't needed in a big way on Sunday. Indy was a pretender anyway...they got absolutely crushed by St. Louis and Arizona this year.

[Blax0r]

Manning gets my vote.

That said, Brady's easily #2.

[slacker00]

I don't see NEs running game taking over here...I'd be shocked if Brady isn't needed in a big way on Sunday. Indy was a pretender anyway...they got absolutely crushed by St. Louis and Arizona this year.

And they beat Peyton in the house that he built. Indy was no joke this year, but NE made them look like one.

[localdallasbook]

Manning is the man.

[Walulu]

Brady has the rings. If Manning can get a second and make a run at a third there would be some good discussion.

[Celtics08]

Peyton Man ning

[slacker00]

Brady has the rings. If Manning can get a second and make a run at a third there would be some good discussion.

Two should be enough, just to prove the first one wasn't a fluke. So many 1 ring wonders littering NFL history.

[GWags]

Manning ... this year.

[Rangers901]

Two should be enough, just to prove the first one wasn't a fluke. So many 1 ring wonders littering NFL history.

And what has Brady proved? That he can't be the main component of a championship team?

Ding, Ding, Ding, we have a winner.

Brady has done nothing since spygate, tuck rule, and fielding a top 3 defensive unit.

Manning, on the other hand, was easily the main component to Indy winning it all.

But, don't take my word for it, how about the players/owners poll that was done again this season that was just released on ESPN.

They were polled based on two things:

Which Player Do You Respect The Most?

Manning: 26.8%
Brady: 7.5%

If You Had To Start A Team With One Player, Who Would It Be?

Manning: 19.3%
Brady: 12.8%

But, really, who cares about the players, owners, ex-greats, etc. and what they think, right? I mean a bunch of scrubs on SBR are far superior in regards to knowledge than the players, owners, ex-greats, etc. of the game, right?

There's no argument, Manning is the greatest QB of all time, and people who don't see this are simply ignorant.

When will people stop judging greatness on rings alone? NFL rosters consist of 54 men, not 1. When Brady was forced to put his team on his back in the playoffs, he choked every time. That's right, without spygate, tuck rule, and more importantly a top defensive unit, Brady has won nothing.

Brady can beat up whatever cupcakes he wants to during the season, throw as many 4th quarter TD's up 28 points as he wants, etc. etc. but he'll just never be anything close to Manning, nothing.

When the Broncos win the SB this year, clinging onto the back of Manning, Brady lovers will be heart broken. That would mean that Manning won 2 rings being the main component of his team, and Brady will have 0 rings being the main component of his team.

[bobby heenan]

And what has Brady proved? That he can't be the main component of a championship team?

Ding, Ding, Ding, we have a winner.

Brady has done nothing since spygate, tuck rule, and fielding a top 3 defensive unit.

Manning, on the other hand, was easily the main component to Indy winning it all.

But, don't take my word for it, how about the players/owners poll that was done again this season that was just released on ESPN.

They were polled based on two things:

Which Player Do You Respect The Most?

Manning: 26.8%
Brady: 7.5%

If You Had To Start A Team With One Player, Who Would It Be?

Manning: 19.3%
Brady: 12.8%

But, really, who cares about the players, owners, ex-greats, etc. and what they think, right? I mean a bunch of scrubs on SBR are far superior in regards to knowledge than the players, owners, ex-greats, etc. of the game, right?

There's no argument, Manning is the greatest QB of all time, and people who don't see this are simply ignorant.

When will people stop judging greatness on rings alone? NFL rosters consist of 54 men, not 1. When Brady was forced to put his team on his back in the playoffs, he choked every time. That's right, without spygate, tuck rule, and more importantly a top defensive unit, Brady has won nothing.

Brady can beat up whatever cupcakes he wants to during the season, throw as many 4th quarter TD's up 28 points as he wants, etc. etc. but he'll just never be anything close to Manning, nothing.

When the Broncos win the SB this year, clinging onto the back of Manning, Brady lovers will be heart broken. That would mean that Manning won 2 rings being the main component of his team, and Brady will have 0 rings being the main component of his team.

my god

*Won-Loss Record: Brady holds a 10-4 edge
*Brady on the road: holds a 3-2 edge.
*Team points per game: 30.0 for the Patriots, 24.6 for Colts/Broncos.
*Completion percentage: Brady: 67.0%, Manning: 61.8%.
*Touchdowns to interceptions: 26 TDs, 12 INTs for Brady; 29 TDs, 20 INTs for Manning.
*Regular season Passer Rating: Brady: 100.6, Manning: 93.6
*Playoff Passer Rating: Brady: 81.7, Manning: 61.0

penetrating spygate...lol...such a copout for the patriots haters...it meant nothing....they videotaped some handsignals from a prohibited area.....when kraft asked belichick straight up on a scale of 1-100 how much it helped he told him "1"......i guess the patriots stopped winning football games after that right?...oh thats right they had an unbeaten regular season.......you anti patriots guys are such whiny queers its unreal......."oh shit the patriots havent won a superbowl since 'spygate'...winning superbowls is very easy....the patriots cant win without cheating"....jfc