Manning vs Brady, Cast your vote!

[PAULYPOKER]

Good call Jo Jo,Maning will put the ! mark on it this post season then announce retirement......

Fine print:

I always was a Manning basher

[slacker00]

Manning.. BIG TIME'


why NO RINGS after SpyGate!!!????

po-LENTY of time... NO EXCUSES*

Spygate? How many rings does Peyton have since spygate? Zero. LOL

[rock1010]

Manning during regular season, Brady in playoffs

[pavyracer]

Manning.

Brady won nothing sing the scandal of videotaping other teams practices was exposed.

[slacker00]

[frostno98]

Peyon f..king Manning!

[lakerboy]

Peyon f..king Manning!

dude you need help.

[smitch124]

If I need to win an IMPORTANT game? Brady.

[sickler]

Which one is better at running the two-minute drill?

[PAULYPOKER]

which one is an offensive coordinator firstly and QB 2ndary?

[The Giant]

Everyone argues Manning had better players around him, but who had the better coaching? Brady, and it's not even close.

Therefore, I'm calling this one a...draw.

[Domestic]

Brady

[DroppinDimes]

Manning! Can't pick the guy that wears Ugg boots.

[samdapatriotsfan]

Everyone argues Manning had better players around him, but who had the better coaching? Brady, and it's not even close.

Therefore, I'm calling this one a...draw.

This is probably closest to the best answer so far.

Brady has done more with less on offense for much longer and he is continuing to do it. That said P. Manning makes some throws that should not be made let alone completed, and he is close to a genius on the field.

But at the end of the day...

Tom F- -kin Brady!!!

[Cuse0323]

Everyone says Manning chokes but Brady hasn't won shit in 10 years.

Manning.

[STAX]

If Manning wins it this year, then we have a discussion... If Brady wins it this year, not only is he the best QB of this generation, he's the best of all time.

[slacker00]

Everyone says Manning chokes but Brady hasn't won shit in 10 years.

Manning.

Brady has won 2 Super Bowls and 14 playoff games within the last 10 years.

[SharkAA]

Pirlo or Xavi

Brady or Manning

I'll pass on this meaningless question.

[Hot Jerry]

PROFESSOR BREADY by MILE !!

[t-wizzle]

Brady

[Snowball]

Brady is the better pure passer, but Manning is the better reader of defenses.
draw.

[JakeLc]

Brady its not even close

[dmncnlou]

Fuk both of them. The best is whoever is winning me money.

[kid_mikey_84]

Ask again in 3 years

[darkhat]

Easy, Brady

[face]

[PAULYPOKER]

Brady has won 2 Super Bowls and 14 playoff games within the last 10 years.

One word: Spygate.......

[PAULYPOKER]

Can't compare today's QBs to yesterday's

They are "Modern era QBs".........

[t-wizzle]

What's the tally here?

[tricity]

got believe manning to me is greater than bledsoe....mho

[slacker00]

One word: Spygate.......

Neither Peyton or Brady has won a Super Bowl since spygate. What about Brees and bountygate? Give me a break.

[Hot Jerry]

PROFESSOR BRADY by MILE !!

agree

[Ferndog68]

Todd Marinovich

[GunShard]

Brady has the better team.
Manning is the better QB.
Manning.

[Dollars2Donuts]

Brutal.....you people are almost all terrible.

If you want to know the best team of the past decade...then NE would be most people's choice

If you want to know the best coach of the last decade then Belicheck is obvious

If you want to know who the best QB is.....then imagine this (seriously, close your eyes and imagine this you fu.cktard...yes I am talking to you):

Put Tom Brady on the Colts......and then break his neck. Then, after a year off, throw him on the Broncos.....

THEN:

Put Peyton Manning on the Pats......give him Belicheck, give him their receivers and their D (they ween't always as bad as they are now)


NOW....


Who is the best QB of all time?

Manning....

And guess what??

Brady doesn't make the top 5. Peyton could have 5 or 6 Lombardi Trophies by now.


Cheers,

D2D