Is Tim McCarver The Worst Baseball Commentator On TV?

[dartmouthemcee]

homerism is amatuerish. act like you been there before clowns

[dartmouthemcee]

no one in chicago likes hawk either. not really sure why he has a job

[byronbb]

Love the san fran and seattle guys. HATE that 10000 year old muppet in LA.

[thetrinity]

mccarver the worst national guy in any sport period. local clowns are often worse though.

[RITZ]

no one in chicago likes hawk either. not really sure why he has a job

Darin Jackson and Ed Farmer radio for White Sox are THE worst! Bad banter/every ball is a strike/umps all bad plus over analysis.

[EmpireMaker]

The hawk is the most annoying announcer ever

[turtlejc]

Steve stone is the best there is

[rsnnh12]

Quotes compiled by (the former?) shutuptimmccarver.com

2004 ALCS, Game 5? Red Sox vs. Yankees. David Ortiz hit a home run into right field. Tim: “Mt.Everest erupts again!”…..too bad Mt. Everest isn’t a volcano! – Many readers

August 19, 2006 Yankees @ Red Sox. “Pitching is such a vital part of the game, as far as winning is concerned” –Sarah Page

“Roy Oswalt is a drop and drive pitcher. What is a drop and drive pitcher? He is a guy who drops and drives. Very simple.” – From many readers. (2005 WS Game 4, 10/26) Very insightful Tim!

Joe Buck: “I am stunned the Angels don’t have anyone warming up in their bullpen.” McCarver: I am your co-stunner.

Google "shut up tim mccarver" for the full list. Got it from another forum when I googled it, not sure on SBR policy on linking to sports forums

[LostBankroll]

the Os have solid broadcasters IMO

[Bob Loblaw]

no one in chicago likes hawk either. not really sure why he has a job

That's not true. The majority of White Sox fans love Hawk, myself included.

[BuddyBear]

The White Sox TV and radio guys are both terrible. Neither group has any journalistic/broadcasting norms when broadcasting games.

[InTheDrink]

That's not true. The majority of White Sox fans love Hawk, myself included.

and that folks is why teams have homer announcers

if anyone like suzyn waldman id be fukkin shocked...GOODNESS GRACIOUS! she's the fukkin worst!

Bronxer whatta ya say pal?

[nrok2118]

Im bumping this, trying to watch the Phils on fox and I cant stand this dude, I dont give a shit about the bone chips in your elbow!

[cadillac pete]

I can't stand Rick Sutcliff....He annoys me to now end.

[kcburg]

yes

[B1GER1C828]

nails it.

[mathdotcom]

They are all pretty shitty

How come I haven't noticed Piniella on YES since opening day? Was he canned or have I just been unlucky?

Piniella is the man