Is Derek Jeter top 15 of all time

[nyplayer33]

Top 20 or top 25 player of all time

[SOUP]

Yes.

[TankHankerous]

[You mad bro]

Ur a fuccckin idiot for even asking ... Top SS prob ever and def not top 15 overall player I can name 20-25 players better

[Bcatswin]

Yes if your talking SS not of all time. Question is who else would be on the list?

[Jimmy Proffett]

Top 15 shortstop? Definitely. Top 15 player of all time? lol

[Gndias]

[will2survive]

No but this year goes a long year in making him one of the all time greats if he keep's even a .330 to .340 pace up with decent power. His power and ability to make contact have been amazing this season. Great story

[face]

111 years of baseball with american and national leagues is a long time, jeter is really good but top 15 in 111 years is unlikely

[Pabinator]

Maybe top 15 most over rated of all time

[frogsrangers]

I think he is slightly over rated because he plays for the Yankees. Michael Young puts up similar numbers but gets no where near the recognition

[You mad bro]

I think he is slightly over rated because he plays for the Yankees. Michael Young puts up similar numbers but gets no where near the recognition

young doesnt have the rings that jeter has neither ... that also helps

[InTheDrink]

Define "puts up similar numbers". Young is two years younger and ONE THOUSAND HITS short of jeter.

[You mad bro]

Define "puts up similar numbers". Young is two years younger and ONE THOUSAND HITS short of jeter.

people hate on jeter cuz their favorite teams never had him

[SBR_John]

Best defensive SS? No. For starters his range is simply average and can't be compared to the great ss's.

Best hitting SS? Maybe(would have to research that).

Top 15 I would say definitely not. But his career is not over. If he can put in two years hitting like he has the past two months then maybe. Some pretty great players on the top 15 list.

[InTheDrink]

Guys please stop with best ss ever.

Do a little homework on honus Wagner. Not even close, regardless of generation.

[You mad bro]

Guys please stop with best ss ever.

Do a little homework on honus Wagner. Not even close, regardless of generation.

wagner straight beast lmao ... hes a top 15 ss but def not top 15 player of all time

[Br0nxer]

no

rivera better all time player then jeter

rivera top 15

[InTheDrink]

no

rivera better all time player then jeter

rivera top 15

Common Bronxer

Paul Oneill better than Rivera

Oneill top 15

The only current yank with a shot at that claim is arod as much as anyone hates to admit it.

[Br0nxer]

Common Bronxer

Paul Oneill better than Rivera

Oneill top 15

The only current yank with a shot at that claim is arod as much as anyone hates to admit it.

drinker are you fukkin kidding me

oneill isn't a pimple on rivera's ass

rivera top 5 greatest pitchers ever

[greenhippo]

Bonds
Rodriguez
Pujols
Kaline
Musial
Foxx
Mays
Ruth
Gehrig
Williams
Speaker
Hornsby
Wagner
Aaron
Cobb
Shoeless Joe

16 there without thinking and without listing a single pitcher. I wouldn't consider him in top 30.

[InTheDrink]

drinker are you fukkin kidding me

oneill isn't a pimple on rivera's ass

rivera top 5 greatest pitchers ever

Oneill was a joke but Rivera isn't close to top 15. Arod the douche is though.

[Br0nxer]

Oneill was a joke but Rivera isn't close to top 15. Arod the douche is though.

thought you were serious for a second

[Vesuvius]

funny gif but Jeter is top 15 ... most hits on the greatest team in the MLB? how are you not top 15?

[greenhippo]

funny gif but Jeter is top 15 ... most hits on the greatest team in the MLB? how are you not top 15?

When there are easily 25 better players.

[InTheDrink]

Bonds
Rodriguez
Pujols
Kaline
Musial
Foxx
Mays
Ruth
Gehrig
Williams
Speaker
Hornsby
Wagner
Aaron
Cobb
Shoeless Joe

16 there without thinking and without listing a single pitcher. I wouldn't consider him in top 30.

The mick says hi

Also bench....get rid of kaline

[You mad bro]

Bonds
Rodriguez
Pujols
Kaline
Musial
Foxx
Mays
Ruth
Gehrig
Williams
Speaker
Hornsby
Wagner
Aaron
Cobb
Shoeless Joe

16 there without thinking and without listing a single pitcher. I wouldn't consider him in top 30.

lol and if u wanna list pitchers .... could give you even a shit load more ... jeter will break top 50 overall probably though .. havent even thought about this

[You mad bro]

hey morons ... your forgetting about wild thing mr vaughn and willy mays hayes

[freeVICK]

jeter is #1 in my eyes. mostly due to the fact that he banged the hottest 15 chicks

[You mad bro]

jeter is #1 in my eyes. mostly due to the fact that he banged the hottest 15 chicks

[face]

Common Bronxer

Paul Oneill better than Rivera

Oneill top 15

The only current yank with a shot at that claim is arod as much as anyone hates to admit it.

no. arod around 2800 hits in 19 years, jeter with 3100 in 18 years

[InTheDrink]

thought you were serious for a second

That shit cray Bronxer

[InTheDrink]

no. arod around 2800 hits in 19 years, jeter with 3100 in 18 years

Lol do the 350 extra home runs matter?

[greenhippo]

The mick says hi

Also bench....get rid of kaline

Obviously could have gone another 5-6 names before even getting to pitchers, but I'll go on the record saying I like Kaline over Bench. Kaline should have won MVP is 55 over Berra IMHO

[face]

Lol do the 350 extra home runs matter?

yes, but 300 more hits in one less year and i give the edge to jeter. didn't realize arod more had so many hr than jeter though good point, definitely close you're right