Brady or Manning?

[robmpink]

Brady, although i still can't come to grips that he turned out as well as he has.

[Scorpion]

Brady lost when NE did not cheat

Manning over Brady any day

Its easy to win when you cheat, NE won 2 SBs by a FG, they probably would lost if they had not cheated and Brady would have been 1-3 in the big game, maybe even 0-4

Brady is overrated!

[Scorpion]

Brady could not beat Brian Griese in college

NE cheated, simple!

[AnotherLoan]

Manning is head and shoulders above Brady. If Manning had all those receivers that Brady had he would have easily won the Super Bowl. Manning understands the game better than anyone.

[robmpink]

Manning is head and shoulders above Brady. If Manning had all those receivers that Brady had he would have easily won the Super Bowl. Manning understands the game better than anyone.

Are you doing K? One year Brady has had good receivers. How many SB has Brady won?

[Sactown]

Manning Manning Manning.

but Brady is head and shoulders about everyone else.

[Brady2Moss]

What is the point of this thread? they are both great QB's and I would have both on my team anyday.

Saying all this BS about brady has a great WR blah blah blah... WTF is that all about? What do you call Reggie Wayne, Marvin Harrison, Stockley, Clark

Manning has years of chemistry with these guys, and Brady has won superbowls with way less talent.

[SBR Lou]

Brady could not beat Brian Griese in college

NE cheated, simple!

That's probably going a little far but I understand the sentiment. I'd personally take Brady over Manning any day of the week and twice on Sundays.

[JDizzel]

Lets see...Brady had spygate AND a rule made up in the middle of a game (tuck rule) so he could win

Dont matter really which Manning brother you talk about here....because right when Brady thought he wouldnt have to deal with a Manning....the younger Manning sent him home a loser to his fine ass wife

The Mannings will ALWAYS be in Bradys nightmares

Both Mannings will be in football longer than Brady

Brady is good...dont get me wrong...but he was also spoonfed by the league and surrounded by cheats

The Mannings represent hard work and coming from nothing to something

Just a shame that this upcoming year the Pats are going to get worked...and there is a special bonus for any crushing blows layed down on Brady this year

I'm with you 100% Boss ..

[max_asdf]

moss > all
brady!!!!!!!

[Jacey]

Brady.

Where's all this "if Peyton had Randy Moss....." BS come from the last year.......look at the receivers Manning has had. You going to tell me Deion Branch (who I like) or Troy Brown or David Patten are better than Marvin Harrison or Reggie Wayne?

Outside of NE no receiver that has left has done much of anything.

[swede96]

Brady.

Where's all this "if Peyton had Randy Moss....." BS come from the last year.......look at the receivers Manning has had. You going to tell me Deion Branch (who I like) or Troy Brown or David Patten are better than Marvin Harrison or Reggie Wayne?

Outside of NE no receiver that has left has done much of anything.