Brady or Manning?
With all star break here, had to fire this one up because I love these two quarterbacks but I want to see whom others prefer/think is better.
My vote is BRADY...
-
With all star break here, had to fire this one up because I love these two quarterbacks but I want to see whom others prefer/think is better.
My vote is BRADY... -
Brady is one smooth operator.Comment -
If Manning had Moss, he will be just as good, no offense to Harrison or Wayne...Comment -
Brady is the best QB in the league.Comment -
I like Peyton Manning more personally .If you're talking fantasy then MAYBE Brady has a slight edge because NE like to run up the score...Comment -
Anybody who says Brady is a dumb ass who didnt watch Superbowl.Comment -
Rotlisberger!!! hahaha
Seriously, m'boy is gonna show his stuff this year, if he's got it or not. He's got his "big target" WR now, plus a nice RB in the draft. It's put up or shut up for Ben. I'll be watching him closely this season. Now if Ben had Moss and Welker. Holy Sh!t!Comment -
Big Ben?Originally posted by slacker00
He doesn't deserve to be in the same conversation, let alone breath as these two...Comment -
Brady by far.Comment -
Brady no doubt at allComment -
peyton (minus dungy)Comment -
The one he lost or all those he wonOriginally posted by bigblue74
You continue to amaze me with your posts.Comment -
I remember Brady's first NFL start against the Colts in 2001. Indy were like 10 point favs at Foxboro and I wasn't impressed with Brady at Michigan so I dumped a ton on the Colts. Pats won 44-3.
Man, has that guy proven a lot of people wrong.Comment -
Brady because he has no choke in him and a little more accurate.Comment -
Gotta be Brady.Comment -
brady....just cause of the superbowl doesnt mean he doesnt have it anymoreComment -
Brady. Hands down.
To whomever made the dig about NE running up the score: What are they playing? Pop Warner? Youth Football? Give me a break! Is it worse to run up the score, or insult the other team by sending in your entire second string? Either way NE is going to get shit for it. You don't want them to score, stop them. It's that simple.
To whomever is basing their entire perception of Brady on this last SB: Go home, son...you will lose every penny you have if you bet with that mentality. Who wants to talk about how many playoff games Manning has lost? Or how many rings Brady has by comparison? If your team is in a clutch game, you can choose any QB in the league to finish it for you and you don't pick Brady, you are an idiot. Regardless of this last SB, there's NO QB I'd pick over him in a clutch.Comment -
Lets see...Brady had spygate AND a rule made up in the middle of a game (tuck rule) so he could win
Dont matter really which Manning brother you talk about here....because right when Brady thought he wouldnt have to deal with a Manning....the younger Manning sent him home a loser to his fine ass wife
The Mannings will ALWAYS be in Bradys nightmares
Both Mannings will be in football longer than Brady
Brady is good...dont get me wrong...but he was also spoonfed by the league and surrounded by cheats
The Mannings represent hard work and coming from nothing to something
Just a shame that this upcoming year the Pats are going to get worked...and there is a special bonus for any crushing blows layed down on Brady this year
Comment -
man ill never forget that game against Oakland....the ref was talking to someone in the booth...held the game up for a few mins
then they make the call "err tuck rule no fumble"
ironically a few years later it comes out...."spygate"
could you imagine what would happen to if Peyton had access to the other teams defensive sets like Brady had all those games??
Comment -
Great athlete, but his legacy was stained somewhat. Not as bad as a Monica Lewinsky's dress, but still. It'll resonate in peoples minds for a few seasons, unless he doesn't make choking in Super Bowls a habit.Originally posted by swede96Comment -
You gotta say brady, Manning comes from a family of QB's while brady is some late round wonderComment -
and it wasnt brady's fault the pats lost the SB, it was the defense that ****ed upComment -
and the O-lineComment -
The mannings coming from nothing??are u kidding me? I'm pretty sure they've been surrounded by the NFL their whole lives. And spygate is a joke. Any who says that the pats were the only team to do this is a pathetic bafoon. Spygate is the result of saddass jealousy and utter dominance. Manning is a cry baby and can't win in the clutch. He can't even hold bradys jockComment -
I agree with Swede here, despite the fact that I hate the Pats more than any other NFL team. This IS the NFL and there's no crying in football. The game doesn't stop until the clock is all zeros. I hope the Pats bust the friggin' scoreboard again this year, because I'm going to be betting them every week until they start making 4 TD lines again like last year. I'll be happy if the Pats go 15-1 with the loss coming to the Colts!To whomever made the dig about NE running up the score: What are they playing? Pop Warner? Youth Football? Give me a break! Is it worse to run up the score, or insult the other team by sending in your entire second string? Either way NE is going to get shit for it. You don't want them to score, stop them. It's that simple.
And I don't want to hear any crying when all of this comes true! 
Comment -
Blister says Brady. Blister knows QBS.Comment -
so every team in the league had what the Pats had??Originally posted by polishkielbasa10
lmfao
dont kid yourself....THEY WERE FILMING THE OTHER TEAMS SIGNALS
not looking at them....but recording them...big difference
cheaters
and what I mean by "coming from nothing" I mean not having the NFL league officials fixing games like the OAK/NE game inventing new rules in the middle of the game
nor did the Mannings have ANY good coaches but yet BOTH still found a way to win
Brady is 'silver spoon' fed...everything given to him..EVEN THE OTHER TEAMS DEFENSIVE SETS ON FILM THE WEEK BEFORE...AND STILL LOST AFTER BEATING UP ON TEAMS LIKE THE BILLS AND REDSKINS ALL YEAR LONG 60-3
Comment -
Guys if you ask yourself If any Coach in the league had to choose from Brady or Manning I bet 90% will say Manning!
Manning can read your D like a book and rip it apart! Brady dont have that type of talent. Manning gets on the line and hit the weakness of what the Defense is giving him! If you ask any coach who would they take the majority of them will say Manning!
Manning is what every offensive cordinator dream of (A COACH ON THE FIELD!)Comment -
ManningComment -
Stained by the loss? Yeah, I guess so...but hey, no one's perfect. For now, you have to look at it as the exception, not the rule. Brady's playoff record is pretty damn impressive. We'll see what happens this year. I think people are only looking at it as a stain because of the perfect season and high expectations, which is understandable. However, I have a feeling that had the Pats won, no one would look at the loss as a stain on Eli Manning's legacy. I guess that's the price Tommy pays for being so wicked awesome!Originally posted by crazyl
Comment -
Originally posted by Cloak & Daggerso every team in the league had what the Pats had??
lmfao
dont kid yourself....THEY WERE FILMING THE OTHER TEAMS SIGNALS
not looking at them....but recording them...big difference
cheaters
and what I mean by "coming from nothing" I mean not having the NFL league officials fixing games like the OAK/NE game inventing new rules in the middle of the game
nor did the Mannings have ANY good coaches but yet BOTH still found a way to win
Brady is 'silver spoon' fed...everything given to him..EVEN THE OTHER TEAMS DEFENSIVE SETS ON FILM THE WEEK BEFORE...AND STILL LOST AFTER BEATING UP ON TEAMS LIKE THE BILLS AND REDSKINS ALL YEAR LONG 60-3
Do you need a tissue and a hug, honey? EVERY team has had some calls go for them AND against them that affected the game. To say otherwise is just plain stupid. People need to learn how to put aside their love for "their" team and look at the facts. It's always something. No matter how good a team is, there will always be some jerk-off calling them cheaters or making excuses for why their team couldn't beat them.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't the Raiders still have a chance to score in OT after that call? They had a chance to get it back. Whether they agreed with the call or not, they should have put on their big boy pants, stopped crying, got back out there and put the fvcking ball in the end zone. Period.Comment -
Brady ... hands down
Comment -
Manning.Comment -
Whether his coach tarnished his legacy a bit or not, I still believe he's more clutch than Peyton Manning.Comment -
Brady, not even close.Comment
