Name your top 5 qb's of all time

[samgurt]

I love the Brady has more talent argument. How did givens do when he left? How did branch do when he left? How about when he came back? How was moss immediately before and after he was in NE? When did welker become one of the best wr's in th game? Hilarious argument. Meanwhile Reggie Wayne still piles up big numbers in mannings absence and will continue to do so all year.

it's not that hard for those receivers to get open when they have brady standing in the pocket for 10 secs every play.

I like em both...just because brady can put up better numbers in a game doesn't make him better

[samgurt]

can we all just agree that O-line makes a team and a QB...any good professional can make passes when they have time.

[ThaTopMoron]

Top QB thread's always turn into Manning Brady postings... both must be in the top 5 then and after that people rank 1 ahead of the other depending on who they like more or who has beaten their own favorite team less. The end.

[Cap dat 4ss]

Top 5 current QB's

Tom Brady
Peyton Manning
Drew Brees
Cam Newton
Michael Vick

Final answer

[rsnnh12]

can we all just agree that O-line makes a team and a QB...any good professional can make passes when they have time.

It certainly helps... having guys like Manning and Brady who can feel pressure and navigate the pocket effortlessly makes the Oline look good too, though

[kmarinouofm]

marino ( god i was lucky to grow up in miami ) , Montana (best ever ), Brady (one of the smartest i have ever seen, True Michigan Man) , Steve Young (only legend to follow a legend ) , Elway

[InTheDrink]

can we all just agree that O-line makes a team and a QB...any good professional can make passes when they have time.

Depends on what you call a good professional.

Not every guy can go through progressions and hit his fifth receiver in four or five seconds. Brady is the best ever at that hands down. When he's at his best the pats will have like 9 guys with receptions.

[face]

yea tom and peyton are both really smart QBs. they read tons of defenses and have oodles of plays memorized.