Name your top 5 qb's of all time

harlee71 · 09-12-11, 10:46 PM

#1 Warren Moon

harlee71 · 09-12-11, 10:47 PM

#2 Troy Aikman

jrmartin.mig · 09-12-11, 10:47 PM

How do you not put Brady above Manning? I mean Manning is a good QB and all, but its Tom Brady we are talking about, and this is coming from a Steelers fan.

wantitall4moi · 09-12-11, 10:48 PM

Montana
Elway
Marino
Moon
Flutie

Aikmen honorable mention

harlee71 · 09-12-11, 10:48 PM

#3 Jim Kelly

harlee71 · 09-12-11, 10:48 PM

#4 Dan Fouts

harlee71 · 09-12-11, 10:49 PM

#5 Dan Marino

rsnnh12 · 09-12-11, 10:49 PM

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Marino
4. Manning
5. Elway

Can't rank guys like Johnny U because I haven't seen enough, if any, to give a fair rating. These are the best I've seen a lot of.

EaglesPhan36 · 09-12-11, 10:49 PM

In no order: Manning, Montana, Marino, Brady, Elway

Unitas is on almost everyone's list, but I never saw the guy play so I cannot say. Those are the guys I would rank among the ones I have seen play. Favre right on the outside, easily the most entertaining QB I have seen play IMO is Favre.

ttwarrior1 · 09-12-11, 10:51 PM

harlee can we stick with one post

LolsMcwinsey · 09-12-11, 10:51 PM

chad pennington #1

ttwarrior1 · 09-12-11, 10:51 PM

its funny how people use superbowls or wins to put some qb at 1 yet at the same time they might say barry sanders is #1 all time at rb if asked

Sledge187 · 09-12-11, 10:53 PM

I would say
1) Montana
2) Brady
3) Elway
4) Manning
5) Aikman or Bradshaw

rsnnh12 · 09-12-11, 10:53 PM

Originally posted by rsnnh12

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Marino
4. Manning
5. Elway

Can't rank guys like Johnny U because I haven't seen enough, if any, to give a fair rating. These are the best I've seen a lot of.

Originally posted by EaglesPhan36

In no order: Manning, Montana, Marino, Brady, Elway

Unitas is on almost everyone's list, but I never saw the guy play so I cannot say. Those are the guys I would rank among the ones I have seen play. Favre right on the outside, easily the most entertaining QB I have seen play IMO is Favre.

ttwarrior1 · 09-12-11, 10:53 PM

I like to use this as an example

Lets use last year's carolina panthers. If you were to stick brady on that team, they wouldnt make the playoffs. If you put rodgers on that team, they wouldnt make the playoffs. If you stick p manning on that team, they are superbowl contenders.

Just look at the colts without manning. They might not win a game.

Only 3 qb's i can think of that could make a bad team into a contender. Manning, marino,elway. A rodgers is getting there

Sledge187 · 09-12-11, 10:56 PM

Originally posted by ttwarrior1

I like to use this as an example

Lets use last year's carolina panthers. If you were to stick brady on that team, they wouldnt make the playoffs. If you put rodgers on that team, they wouldnt make the playoffs. If you stick p manning on that team, they are superbowl contenders.

Just look at the colts without manning. They might not win a game.

Only 3 qb's i can think of that could make a bad team into a contender. Manning, marino,elway. A rodgers is getting there

As a Texans fan I agree with your Manning argument. He would make any team great.

harlee71 · 09-12-11, 10:58 PM

Tie #5 Manning

rsnnh12 · 09-12-11, 10:58 PM

Originally posted by ttwarrior1

I like to use this as an example

Lets use last year's carolina panthers. If you were to stick brady on that team, they wouldnt make the playoffs. If you put rodgers on that team, they wouldnt make the playoffs. If you stick p manning on that team, they are superbowl contenders.

Just look at the colts without manning. They might not win a game.

Only 3 qb's i can think of that could make a bad team into a contender. Manning, marino,elway. A rodgers is getting there

Yea, because Brady has never led bad teams to the playoffs, right?

Hell, Steve Smith would be the 2nd best WR Brady has ever had, and JStew/DWill in the top 3 for what Brady has ever had at RB. The Panthers have a decent amount of talent, it was the shitty coaching and lack of a QB that hurt them last year.

Jimmy0607 · 09-12-11, 11:00 PM

Matt Cassel replaced brady and went 11-5 brady still a beast thou

ehp6737 · 09-12-11, 11:00 PM

Originally posted by ttwarrior1

1. P manning
2 John elway
3 dan marino
4 joe montana
5 bret favre

sorry brady is not on my list.

He is 7 or 8 if i made a top ten

I don't like comparing era's though . A qb is only as good as his owner, system and offensive line

So you have Marino ahead of Montana and Favre ahead of Brady

Kindly put down your crackpipe, sober up, and rethink your list......

downsouth · 09-12-11, 11:01 PM

Marino
Montana
brady
Elway
Manning

SBRMAN23 · 09-12-11, 11:02 PM

Brady always has talent on both sides of the ball just how much and I agree with Peyton argument

InTheDrink · 09-12-11, 11:04 PM

Manning threw a super bowl away

The best ever doesn't do that

Sledge187 · 09-12-11, 11:04 PM

My Top 5 Texan QBs of All Time

1) Matt Schaub
2) Sage Rosenfels
3) Matt Leinart
4) Dan Orlovsky
5) David Carr

rsnnh12 · 09-12-11, 11:08 PM

Originally posted by InTheDrink

Manning threw a super bowl away

The best ever doesn't do that

Don't forget his spectacular numbers in the playoffs the year they won the Super Bowl... 3 TDs and 7 INTs

And people say Brady was carried by his D

drfunkmaster · 09-12-11, 11:14 PM

KYLE ORTON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ttwarrior1 · 09-12-11, 11:15 PM

not hard to dominate the afc east the past few years with miami, buffalo, jets. 6 guaranteed wins the last few years. Brady has the best o line. Has brady ever needed to run out of the pocket.

rsnnh12 · 09-12-11, 11:36 PM

Originally posted by ttwarrior1

not hard to dominate the afc east the past few years with miami, buffalo, jets. 6 guaranteed wins the last few years. Brady has the best o line. Has brady ever needed to run out of the pocket.

South- Jags, Texans, Titans. Yeah, Manning sure is in a much tougher division

Are you saying Manning has a bad line? And as far as running goes, has Manning ever juked Brian Urlacher? Because Brady has... just sayin'

face · 09-12-11, 11:39 PM

joe namath (bc he won jets only superbowl)
brett favre
john elway
joe montana
tom brady

samgurt · 09-12-11, 11:39 PM

peyton has more skill than brady. brady has a better team which makes him better.

both are unreal

InTheDrink · 09-12-11, 11:40 PM

I love the Brady has more talent argument.

How did givens do when he left?

How did branch do when he left? How about when he came back?

How was moss immediately before and after he was in NE?

When did welker become one of the best wr's in th game?

Hilarious argument. Meanwhile Reggie Wayne still piles up big numbers in mannings absence and will continue to do so all year.

CanuckG · 09-12-11, 11:41 PM

warren mooon

B1GER1C828 · 09-12-11, 11:41 PM

Originally posted by samgurt

peyton has more skill than brady. brady has a better team which makes him better. both are unreal

fukin idiot...

where was brady's team in 03? number 1 wr was givens? unreal.

if brady isnt number 1 on ur list then gtfo. fuckin mooks.

SportsMushroom · 09-12-11, 11:42 PM

why do people consider manning one of the best quarterbacks? he is a stat whore and a chocker