Nfl mvp: Vick or brady?

[Nivas the guru]

Can I take that bet. Brady all day.

[Nomocino]

Injury to Vick and games missed make Brady a no brainer, also think Rodgers and MJD should be in the hunt

[pavyracer]

Matt Ryan has the same number of wins as Brady. He should be in the mix. And Matt Ryan has more 4th quarter game winning drives than Brady which means he is better under pressure.

[Doc JS]

With a quarter of the season remaining, it's Brady and it's not close...

Doc

[thebestthereis]

Both are worthy but people will not vote for Vick because of his past

[thisisit]

Brady is the most likely winner here, but do not sleep on Rodgers, he has been putting up killer numbers, and gets a chance to beat brady in 2 weeks!

[FR3SH like UgHH]

right now gotta say vick...

[teddyd]

Vick has no chance...

[D3 Mighty Ducks]

Brady hands down. Its already his, Vick's got no chance.

[brahmabull117]

lets be real, as good as vick has been, philly has talent on offense who exactly is brady throwing to that scares anybody? isnt the pats defense last in yards given up? pats have the better record, brady has better stats, hes played more games where does vick have an edge over brady?

how the hell does Brady have better stats??


Vick is averaging nearly 340 total yards per game and 2.7 touchdowns per game, nobody in the league is close to that


brady is averaging about a 100 yards less per game than Vick is

[Snowball]

NFL will never reward Vick with MVP

Bad Publicity

[xxxvince]

nfl just might to get extra publicity.. guys are bored of handing down mvp to brady and manning

[jjgold]

Its close but Vick missed some games

Brady winning right now

[rm18]

Vick won't win, Eagles are not even going to the playoffs

[B1GER1C828]

brady easily wins mvp but vick is definatly in 2nd. just amazing year by brady

[Grits n' Gravy]

Matt Ryan has the same number of wins as Brady. He should be in the mix. And Matt Ryan has more 4th quarter game winning drives than Brady which means he is better under pressure.

Ryan is nice, but he is not close to Brady at this point in his career. Right now it is Brady's award to lose. Think he'd gladly trade it for a 4th SB ring.

[kydchi]

i like vick and the eagles offense but brady should win mvp soley based on his weapons on offense.

[stealthyburrito]

not even a debate at this point.

brady wins in a landslide if the season ended this week.

[bretb27]

we've already seen the eagles win without vick this year, no way the patriots win without brady

[goofyre]

Brady, hands down.

[KKoz9]

Brady, he does more with less. He doesn't even have a #1 receiver.

Vick is having a great season but Kolb could have won 7 or 8 games with the Eagles. Plus, he's only played half a season, he's got to do it for longer than that to raise his career passer rating above Steve Beuerlien and Jeff George.

[Art Vandelay]

Vick's been great but its Brady - He's doing more with less weapons.

[Philavanh]

Brady all the way

[ByeShea]

I'll go with Vick. He has to get props for coming from backup and leading his team to a playoff contender. Before Vick was the starter for Philly fans where still mumbling about the McNabb trade to division foe the Redskins. Kolb although has his qualities is not a starting QB in the NFL in my opinion. Brady is a future hall of famer and a great QB who has been there and done that. No disrespect to him but this is Vick's year. He suprised a lof of people and shut the mouths of the naysayers.

Know what else would surprise people, I mean really surprise the hell out of people? If there is a single coach in the NFL who'd opt for Vick over Brady as their QB based on their performance this year.

Brady.

Vick gets the "Surprise Props" award only because Brady as MVP isn't that surprising a scenario.

[venice2222]

No question that it should be Brady.

[rsnnh12]

Matt Ryan has the same number of wins as Brady. He should be in the mix. And Matt Ryan has more 4th quarter game winning drives than Brady which means he is better under pressure.

Didn't Matty Ice need a miracle strip by Roddy White to even have a chance, after Ryan through the game-ending pick?

No way is Ryan better under pressure than arguably the most clutch QB in NFL history. Ryan will be a great QB, but he isn't near Brady yet

[freelee]

Peyton Hillis

[jcadwell]

vickkkkkk! love him

[iQon]

You're an idiot if you think Vick gets the MVP over someone like Tom Brady.

[ByeShea]

how the hell does Brady have better stats??


Vick is averaging nearly 340 total yards per game and 2.7 touchdowns per game, nobody in the league is close to that


brady is averaging about a 100 yards less per game than Vick is

Brady is going to walk into Soldier Field and rip the Bears a new one and leave with a "W", exactly what Vick could not do.

Then what?

(And by the way there is no other QB in the league who I can make such a prediction with such confidence. At this point, we're surprised if anyone can stop Brady - and he's not doing with any Jerry Rices, either.

Vick is doing awesome, no doubt, but not better than Brady.)

[Vangel330]

definitly brady!!!! Vick awesome as well

[Capybara]

Matt Ryan has the same number of wins as Brady. He should be in the mix. And Matt Ryan has more 4th quarter game winning drives than Brady which means he is better under pressure.

No, it means the Pats have been up three touchdowns in a bunch of their games in the fourth quarter. Most have ended up looking close because the D kept giving up late TD's. I can think of four games in which this was the case.

Anyway, right now it's clearly Brady, but Vick has a definite shot if he's great in his final four games. If either of these guys doesn't win his division, it will probably go to the other guy.

[MortalLock]

Gotta be Tom Bieber Brady.

[BobHarvey]

With a quarter of the season remaining, it's Brady and it's not close...

Doc

Hands down it's Brady. His leadership skills have improved as he's gotten older. Put that together with his numbers from this year and like Doc said it's not even close.

Vick is still a bad citizen.

[PUDS]

Captain Tom Brady easily