Post your "how the hell was he ever an all star" here

[stevenash]

I'll start

Chan Ho Park

[Big Bear]

Hmmm Fat Albert..?

[Chi_archie]

cesar Izturis back about 6 years ago.

[biff]

joe girardi

got in due to someone getting hurt and all the players loved him

[easyliving]

Mehmet Okur, his the reason they lifted the mandatory center from the all star lineups. Simply a lack of big men in the league

[ThingsFallApart]

Mehmet Okur, his the reason they lifted the mandatory center from the all star lineups. Simply a lack of big men in the league

Get a grip mate.

[daneblazer]

Rolando Arrojo

[daneblazer]

Mike Bordick

[Louisvillekid1]

Mike Williams PIT....

Guey had like a 9+ ERA and then got traded here like a week after the game and was awful. Only made it because of his one good year before.

Prob was like 04...

[I/O]

Joakim Noah

[RubberKettle]

Worst all star ever....Ty Wiggington

[konck]

Jason Bay

[Chi_archie]

Mike Williams PIT....

Guey had like a 9+ ERA and then got traded here like a week after the game and was awful. Only made it because of his one good year before.

Prob was like 04...

Yeah I remember that, wAsnt only due to year before. But the stupid one player from every team rule. Plus he had of saves that year at the break.

Pirates are great at take garbage pitchers than making them closers, than trading them right as they revert to garbage.


trade Grilli NOW!

[Monitor-Tan]

Michael Jordan when he was with the wizards

[El Nino]

Matt Lawton

Cristian Guzman

[Monitor-Tan]

I take that back, he wasn't TOO terrible, it's just this keeps coming back to me and it just keeps playing back in my head every fukking damn time.. Why MJ.. WHY>>>

[Artieaa]

Milton Bradley
John Buck
Phil Hughes
Alexi Ogando
Edinson Volquez

[Itsamazing777]

Brandon Inge

[Louisvillekid1]

Milton Bradley
John Buck
Phil Hughes
Alexi Ogando
Edinson Volquez

Good list, but Milton Bradley was full of talent just a fukk up... Isn't he going away for a few years now>?

[actiondan]

Steve Nash

[PaperTrail07]

Cesar is a quality player but ALLSTAR....i agree here big time....he reminds me of a Harriston type of player....

cesar Izturis back about 6 years ago.

[Big Bear]

Paul Byrd

[MCOZONE]

Scott Cooper. TWICE.

[rm18]

Omar Infante obviously

[bobby heenan]

esteban loaiza.....guy had that one year he won 20 games with an era under 3.....the guy has a career 4.65 era never won more than 12 games in a year before or after that

[freeVICK]

Polanco

[gcd8]

without a doubt it's bryan lahair that guy didn't deserve to be on the all star team and he's not even in the majors anymore playing in japan guy is a bum

[Artieaa]

Good list, but Milton Bradley was full of talent just a fukk up... Isn't he going away for a few years now>?

yeah Bradley was very skilled but he never tried, recall him while playing in Dodgers uniform always good start in the season then bum nothing!!!

[Chi_archie]

Cesar is a quality player but ALLSTAR....i agree here big time....he reminds me of a Harriston type of player....

he was hitting .275ish with 1 HR at the time

[jjgold]

Mark Tex

Yanks

Who're shit

[PaperTrail07]

unreal

he was hitting .275ish with 1 HR at the time

[PaperTrail07]

Cant agree here....anybody who can hit bombs from both sides of the plate like he has deserved it atleast a few times.....guy holds the MLB record, I mean come on

Mark Tex

Yanks

Who're shit

[Otters27]

No one player comes to mind especially but baseball is most susceptible to this because the format of having one player from each team. Sometimes a guy batting .280 with 12 homers get on the list because there is no one else on his team that is a better choice

[You mad bro]

Anyone on steroids

[Ghenghis Kahn]

jj hardy