Which NFL QB Is More Overrated?

onlooker · 12-02-08, 10:42 PM

Brett.

element1286 · 12-02-08, 10:54 PM

If Manning is past his prime it is only by a little bit.

daggerkobe · 12-02-08, 10:59 PM

BBD needs his posting privileges taken away for the rest of the year.

pimike · 12-02-08, 11:00 PM

peyton

brett is not overratted, he was asked not to come back to Greenbay, remember

pimike · 12-02-08, 11:01 PM

Originally posted by daggerkobe

BBD needs his posting privileges taken away for the rest of the year.

nice picks tonight. At least I hit Penn under for us.

bigboydan · 12-02-08, 11:02 PM

Originally posted by daggerkobe

BBD needs his posting privileges taken away for the rest of the year.

I could use a paid vacation sir.

daggerkobe · 12-02-08, 11:07 PM

Thanks pimike.

Excellent pick on that under.

dwaechte · 12-02-08, 11:36 PM

They're both still excellent QB's. Peyton is still head and shoulders better though.

Kingctb27 · 12-02-08, 11:40 PM

Neither...?

guru-t · 12-02-08, 11:51 PM

Sage Rosenfels

For real now,Its got to be Favre

Casperwaits · 12-02-08, 11:56 PM

Favre is WAY overrated. To think the Jets are winning because of him is foolish. Manning has carried his team as of late. As a Patriots fan, I can say without bias, that this question is a no-brainer.

Bake · 12-02-08, 11:58 PM

The Colts would flat out blow without Manning at the helm. Jim Sorgi would make Matt Cassell look like Joe Montana.

yisman · 12-03-08, 01:19 AM

Kerry Collins

MJFtheGenius · 12-03-08, 01:21 AM

Now it is favre

Jets signed alot of players in the offseason that improved their team

they are not the New York Bretts

ShamsWoof10 · 12-03-08, 01:28 AM

This one is easy... I say Manning because he depends on his OLine more then Farve.. All QB's and players for that matter depend on the O/DLine but if Manning gets a little pressure he's not as creative as Farve and Romo is like a Farve where he does the samething... Romo has to because that OLine needs work with pass blocking...

Farve should kiss the Jet Organizations as* for going after OLinemen the last two years... What took these teams so long to figure out that passing on a big named skilled player in favor of a good O/DLinemen for a top pick is not such a bad thing...

jjgold · 12-03-08, 05:39 AM

Favre

Enentually kills his team with stupid mistakes

I.R.B · 12-03-08, 06:39 AM

None.. both are argubly in the top 7 QB's ever played.

seaborneq · 12-03-08, 09:20 AM

I think Brett has ONE Super Bowl ring in nearly 20 years, yet is considered an all time great. Trent Dilfer, Doug Williams, Brad Johnson, and Mark Rypian have done the same thing, and they were journeymen. Go Figure. What makes Favre so great, must be the Wrangler commercials. Brett is so overrated that we should make a uber word to fully comprehend how silly it is that he is considered an all time great. Same with Cal Ripken Jr. Both of these guys are considered all time greats because they played everyday, even though they played everyday slight above average.

ipickwinners · 12-03-08, 09:24 AM

farve for sure

SBR Lou · 12-03-08, 09:27 AM

Peyton is not 'well past' his prime. Marvin Harrison is and Reggie Wayne seems to drop more and more passes. One of the only positions that has played with much consistency over this season, aside from the shaky opening weeks where he had not played and was coming off an injury, is Peyton.

And do not look at last weeks boxscore, he played well and one of the interceptions was with 2 seconds remaining in a half and a hail mary, the other Wayne was outplayed on.

CaneDawg · 12-03-08, 10:15 AM

Phiilp Rivers is the most over rated qb in the league

firedawg · 12-03-08, 10:21 AM

pm

fiveteamer · 12-03-08, 10:29 AM

Both are great QB's. This is a stupid poll.

And btw, only one is past their prime.

cweh · 12-03-08, 02:30 PM

Farve- and I agree! P. Riviers is biggest overrated QB in NFL right now!

Kargo · 12-03-08, 03:08 PM

I agree they both had they're good times, at least that's the case with Favre. I think Favre is done and Payton has a chance to come back, but right now, they're both overrated.

Kargo · 12-03-08, 03:13 PM

Favre should retire right now before he makes a full of himself.

BTW, I.R.B. who's the chick on your avatar, that's a huge ass !!!

ShamsWoof10 · 12-03-08, 03:14 PM

Originally posted by seaborneq

I think Brett has ONE Super Bowl ring in nearly 20 years, yet is considered an all time great. Trent Dilfer, Doug Williams, Brad Johnson, and Mark Rypian have done the same thing, and they were journeymen. Go Figure. What makes Favre so great, must be the Wrangler commercials. Brett is so overrated that we should make a uber word to fully comprehend how silly it is that he is considered an all time great. Same with Cal Ripken Jr. Both of these guys are considered all time greats because they played everyday, even though they played everyday slight above average.

Dan Marino has zero.. Would you consider him over rated..?

tacomax · 12-03-08, 03:15 PM

Originally posted by CrazyL

Peyton is not 'well past' his prime. Marvin Harrison is and Reggie Wayne seems to drop more and more passes. One of the only positions that has played with much consistency over this season, aside from the shaky opening weeks where he had not played and was coming off an injury, is Peyton.

And do not look at last weeks boxscore, he played well and one of the interceptions was with 2 seconds remaining in a half and a hail mary, the other Wayne was outplayed on.

CrazyL, it took you nearly 12 hours to reply to a Peyton-bashing thread - please improve.

In the meantime, please start your weekly The Colts are the sharp pick this week because... thread.

Kargo · 12-03-08, 03:18 PM

Dan Marino is overrated too, any QB that can't take his team to a Super Bowl and win it is because he's not all time great material !

Kargo · 12-03-08, 03:19 PM

All these QB's might have been slightly above average, but that doesn't make them great !

Kargo · 12-03-08, 03:23 PM

John Elway, that's quality right there !

eidolon · 12-03-08, 03:25 PM

Originally posted by jjgold

Favre

Enentually kills his team with stupid mistakes

My thoughts exactly. I've seen him try and do too much by throws bombs to know one, only to get intercepted...and this is during times they don't need crazy hailmarys.

ShamsWoof10 · 12-03-08, 03:39 PM

Originally posted by Kargo

Dan Marino is overrated too, any QB that can't take his team to a Super Bowl and win it is because he's not all time great material !

Last I checked Football was a team sport... Jim Kelly would have one if Scott Norwood hits that 47 yarder so what is really over rated is how people use Super Bowls to rate players...

Miami has a terribe D when they went to the Super Bowl... "Ganch/Taco" can cover GUYS better then the DB's they had back then...

seaborneq · 12-03-08, 03:49 PM

Originally posted by ShamsWoof10

Dan Marino has zero.. Would you consider him over rated..?

Don't get me started on Dan Marino.