Guys It Is Time To Admit ELI By Far BEst QB In NFL

[RonPaul2008]

Just wait until Eli gos to SF next month. F*cker isn't gonna do jack shit except throw interceptions and lay on the ground.

[R.P. McMurphy]

Did'nt he beat Frisco in Jan. this past season on his way to S.B. win #2

[CanuckG]

Eli will go down as one of the most underrated QBs ever. Good for another SB ring too

[JACK MATZ]

The Ice Man! on the road. again and again!

[pulledclear]

When the DUST settles he will go down as the best of the Mannings. The kid is 8-3 in the playoffs 5-1 ON THE ROAD!!! Peyton is 9-10. Bash all you want but the proof is in the pudding while Peyton is throwing wounded ducks in Denver Eli will be heading a very good giant team into the playoffs! Read em and weep ladies...

Eli Manning now has two Super Bowl titles. That’s impressive. Not many quarterbacks have multiple Super Bowl titles. Let’s see. Bart Starr, Bob Griese, Roger Staubach, Terry Bradshaw, Jim Plunkett, Joe Montana, Troy Aikman, John Elway, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger. And now Manning.
Impressive. But this is more impressive. Eli Manning now has five road victories in the NFL playoffs. Not many NFL quarterbacks have five road playoff wins. As in none, other than Peyton’s little brother.
Manning’s NFC Championship Game win at Green Bay raised his playoff road record to 5-1. That’s not counting the neutral-field Super Bowls. That’s road games. That’s games in unfriendly environs, which are incredibly hard to win.
Johnny Unitas, Kurt Warner, Doug Williams, Bobby Layne and Jeff Hostetler all were NFL champion quarterbacks. They combined for five road playoff wins. The same as Eli Manning all by his lonesome.
Steve Young, Y.A. Tittle and Norm Van Brocklin all are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Combined, they were 0-7 in playoff road games.
Peyton Manning and Joe Montana are on virtually everyone’s list of the top five quarterbacks in NFL history. They each went 2-5 in playoff road games.
Troy Aikman, Bob Griese, Jim Kelly, Warren Moon and Dan Marino are in the Hall of Fame, too. They reached a combined 11 Super Bowls, winning five. Their combined playoff road record: 5-19.
Eli Manning’s career playoff road record: 5-1.

[GamblerSpirit]

Did'nt he beat Frisco in Jan. this past season on his way to S.B. win #2

Niners' fans still salty! " who got it better than us!!! "

[19th Hole]

without a doubt. all he lacks is the mobility. watching him run is a crime lol

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~````

Been watching old video of Johnny U. attempting
to run in those high tops.

[GunShard]

Peyton has more MVPs than Eli.

Eli's reciever, defensive line and head coach made him look good.

[Goat Milk]

When the DUST settles he will go down as the best of the Mannings. The kid is 8-3 in the playoffs 5-1 ON THE ROAD!!! Peyton is 9-10. Bash all you want but the proof is in the pudding while Peyton is throwing wounded ducks in Denver Eli will be heading a very good giant team into the playoffs! Read em and weep ladies...

Eli Manning now has two Super Bowl titles. That’s impressive. Not many quarterbacks have multiple Super Bowl titles. Let’s see. Bart Starr, Bob Griese, Roger Staubach, Terry Bradshaw, Jim Plunkett, Joe Montana, Troy Aikman, John Elway, Tom Brady, Ben Roethlisberger. And now Manning.
Impressive. But this is more impressive. Eli Manning now has five road victories in the NFL playoffs. Not many NFL quarterbacks have five road playoff wins. As in none, other than Peyton’s little brother.
Manning’s NFC Championship Game win at Green Bay raised his playoff road record to 5-1. That’s not counting the neutral-field Super Bowls. That’s road games. That’s games in unfriendly environs, which are incredibly hard to win.
Johnny Unitas, Kurt Warner, Doug Williams, Bobby Layne and Jeff Hostetler all were NFL champion quarterbacks. They combined for five road playoff wins. The same as Eli Manning all by his lonesome.
Steve Young, Y.A. Tittle and Norm Van Brocklin all are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Combined, they were 0-7 in playoff road games.
Peyton Manning and Joe Montana are on virtually everyone’s list of the top five quarterbacks in NFL history. They each went 2-5 in playoff road games.
Troy Aikman, Bob Griese, Jim Kelly, Warren Moon and Dan Marino are in the Hall of Fame, too. They reached a combined 11 Super Bowls, winning five. Their combined playoff road record: 5-19.
Eli Manning’s career playoff road record: 5-1.

good post. But I don't see you mentioning Brady there. He probably doesn't have 5 road playoff victories because the guy gets a bye ever single year....

Check who has the most playoff wins for a qb then get back to me (btw if Brady doesn't already have this record, he will shatter it by the time he retires)

[eidolon]

Did'nt he beat Frisco in Jan. this past season on his way to S.B. win #2

He didn't beat SF. The kick returner gave NY the game.

[pulledclear]

good post. But I don't see you mentioning Brady there. He probably doesn't have 5 road playoff victories because the guy gets a bye ever single year....

Check who has the most playoff wins for a qb then get back to me (btw if Brady doesn't already have this record, he will shatter it by the time he retires)

I didnt say the best of all time I said best OF THE MANNINGS.

[LT Profits]

I pretty much can't stand the Giants, but Eli is awesome........He's gotta be top 4 with Brady Brees and Rodgers. Really just personal preference of who you would choose among these guys, no one else belongs in this group

I never thought Eli would reach this level, but the last few years he has proven it

It looks like we agree on something. I rate Eli 4th right now. In order: Rodgers, Brady, Brees, Eli.

[Big Bear]

this fill in JJ is a dumbass

[Big Bear]

Top 5 NFL QB's
1. Tom Brady
2.Aaron Rodgers
3.Drew Brees
4. Matt Ryan
5. Ben Roethlisberger

[fergie's balls]

LOL at the guys with Matt Ryan above Eli. true Matt Ryan is still young, but ridiculous to say at this point. some guys just can't over that "Aw Shucks" Eli keeps on winning...relies on D-line, lucky Super Bowl tosses, because of his run game, etc, etc....go ahead keep trying to justify, i'll just keep counting rings.

[fergie's balls]

He didn't beat SF. The kick returner gave NY the game.

haha, another one, keep them coming....

[fergie's balls]

Peyton has more MVPs than Eli.

Eli's reciever, defensive line and head coach made him look good.

pile em on! Eli can't do this, Eli can't do that, Eli got lucky, let's see ELi here, let's see Eli play there...hilarious

[lakerboy]

How does Eli do if he gets traded to Cleveland?

He would make them better for sure. How would Rodgers or Brady do in cleveland?

[Sam Odom]

Ron Paul, you can't be serious

that is a correct statement

[darkhat]

[Br0nxer]

Top 5 NFL QB's
1. Tom Brady
2.Aaron Rodgers
3.Drew Brees
4. Matt Ryan
5. Ben Roethlisberger

Matt Ryan

[PhillyFlyers]

Eli is still somehow underrated by many.

Brady is 0-2 vs. Eli in the Super Bowl with 2 Super Bowl MVPs to go with it. Also set a Super Bowl record with 9 consecutive completions to start a Super Bowl.

On that alone, he is worthy of being mentioned in the top 5.

[HedBustah1]

You guys keep arguing about it and underrating Eli, he'll just go out & keep winning super bowls, let's go giants!

[isotopes]

Eli Manning is not even a top 5 QB.

A Few QB's Currently Better Then Eli Manning:

Tom Brady
Aaron Rodgers
Drew Brees
Matt Ryan
Matt Schaub
Alex Smith

This easily is the dumbest thing I have ever read on an SBR board, legit you are a moron of epic proportions and you NYG hating has made you an illigitimate sports commentator

[greenhippo]

This easily is the dumbest thing I have ever read on an SBR board, legit you are a moron of epic proportions and you NYG hating has made you an illigitimate sports commentator

Dumbest thing you've ever heard and yet don't refute a single one of those using facts to back it up.

[BigDeem5]

Eli Manning is not even a top 5 QB.

A Few QB's Currently Better Then Eli Manning:

Tom Brady
Aaron Rodgers
Drew Brees
Matt Ryan
Matt Schaub
Alex Smith

You did not put Matt Ryan, Alex Smith, and Matt Schaub inot this list?

[freakydave]

Ellie-may Manning is not the best QB in the NFL.He's in the top 5-6 because of his team.Rodgers,Brady,Brees make their teammates better-Ellie may not so much.

[isotopes]

Dumbest thing you've ever heard and yet don't refute a single one of those using facts to back it up.

Anyone who puts Alex Smith over Eli Manning literally is not worth having an intelligent sports debate with. It is a ludicrous statement that speaks for itself and it was pure stupidity, from what one can only assume is a huge NYG and Eli Manning hater.

I understand that alot of people don't like the Giants, and I also understand that Eli looks like a little boy and his face is irritating, but to say that Alex Smith is better than a two time Super Bowl MVP who wins games regardless of who his receivers are is just dumb and being said because the guy is a hater. Get over it, I hate Brady but the guy is a stud it isn't hard to admit. It's time the Eli bashers stop it because it is becoming rediculous, the guy is an animal and while you can debate all day who is the best qb or the top 3-5 there is absolutely no debate about Eli vs. Alex smith, Matt Ryan or Matt Schaub.

[Ghenghis Kahn]

all this eli love makes me sick.

[p19101]

good post. But I don't see you mentioning Brady there. He probably doesn't have 5 road playoff victories because the guy gets a bye ever single year....

Check who has the most playoff wins for a qb then get back to me (btw if Brady doesn't already have this record, he will shatter it by the time he retires)

He also cheated...

[Goat Milk]

He also cheated...

LOL he cheated? Football is played on the field. Not in the film room. You could study for 10 hours a day, have other coaches playbooks in your hand. It wouldn't matter if you throw the ball like Jay Cutler. You still have no shot to win it all.

Tom Brady made Bill Bellchick. Let's all make note of that.

[Monitor-Tan]

Eli makes his WR and his TE better.. There's a TON of list of guys who played under Eli and ended up shitting the bed after levign the team, or guys who didn't perform very well but comes plays with Eli and starts becoming much better..

We'll probably never see how Eli does if he's on another team, but we clearly see how he makes other players better..

No such thing as Would've could've or should've in sports. You argue with the facts that are present to you currently. Not what he could do in the future.

[p19101]

Dumbest thing you've ever heard and yet don't refute a single one of those using facts to back it up.

Trolls are better off ignored. Anyone who has Alex Smith 6th in the league is clearly a troll.

[Goat Milk]

VIctor Cruz one of the best talents I've seen at WR in last 5 years. Nicks a really good receiver too. When was the last time Brady had 2 weapons like that? (Welker and Moss?) He went 18-0, until Moss dissappeared like a little bitch in the superbowl.

[jjgold]

Manning makes no names receivers into stars
Cruz would be a nobody in Minn, Ariz or many other teams
Manning puts the ball right there all the time

That says it all