Will Serena Williams ever be recognized as a GOAT in female tennis?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SharkAA
    SBR MVP
    • 11-10-13
    • 2005

    #1
    Will Serena Williams ever be recognized as a GOAT in female tennis?
    19 GS and not giving up just yet. 3 more GS and she is going to tie with Steffi Graf (22 GS). Even if she'll have the same amount of GS, do you still put her in the same context as Steffi Graf?
  • Stokes36
    SBR Sharp
    • 01-17-13
    • 494

    #2
    I think she's already the GOAT imo...if she never wins another GS. lol
    Comment
    • matt1216
      SBR Posting Legend
      • 10-27-11
      • 14683

      #3
      Graf has to be more impressive, no matter what. Serena has the body of a Male athlete with the mentality and emotional side of a woman. Her pure ball bashing power exceeds any female on tour.
      Comment
      • pipita17
        SBR Sharp
        • 07-17-12
        • 393

        #4
        who cares? she surely doesnt.
        Comment
        • Snowball
          BARRELED IN @ SBR!
          • 11-15-09
          • 30047

          #5
          Grand Slam Wins

          Margaret Court - 24
          Steffi Graf - 22
          Helen Wills Moody -19
          Serena Williams - 19
          Martina Navratilova - 18
          Chris Evert - 18
          Billie Jean King - 12

          *being impossible to verify how any of these women would have fared against Serena
          in their primes, and with today's equipment, courts, and medicine, the question is
          and will always be - unanswerable.
          Comment
          • SharkAA
            SBR MVP
            • 11-10-13
            • 2005

            #6
            Originally posted by matt1216
            Graf has to be more impressive, no matter what. Serena has the body of a Male athlete with the mentality and emotional side of a woman. Her pure ball bashing power exceeds any female on tour.
            Good point. I've been wondering, since so many tennis spectators and the media, pretty much look at the GS titles first and everything else second. If I could go by the GS titles, I would say that Margaret Court is the best, but honestly, I don't believe that she's the best female tennis player of all-time. I don't buy it. Since the game of tennis has changed throughout the decades, I realize that it is hard to compare different eras. All in all, there is a widely accepted conclusion, that Steffi Graf is the G.O.A.T at the moment. Do you think, Serena Williams can some day be the best of all-time?
            Comment
            • davidg123
              SBR Sharp
              • 02-13-15
              • 261

              #7
              In my opinion, Serena already is the GOAT!!!
              Comment
              • spankmythighs
                SBR MVP
                • 01-26-10
                • 2884

                #8
                Shes grose. I might have to take Barthel over Serena if I had to choose who to take to the sack. Does Barthel have a meth problem or just bad acne?

                Click image for larger version

Name:	618a447f506953f4c66a421e4077c1ec.jpg
Views:	2
Size:	9.9 KB
ID:	29128981
                sbr
                Comment
                • pattymayo
                  SBR Posting Legend
                  • 05-19-09
                  • 10221

                  #9
                  Oh please, Serena is the best ever

                  If somehow we could pit her against Graff in each of their primes, Serena would smoke her 6-2 6-1
                  Comment
                  • jjgold
                    SBR Aristocracy
                    • 07-20-05
                    • 388189

                    #10
                    Serena and Graf tough call
                    I think Graf's ground strokes would of buried Serena and she had a great serve also

                    If they play 10 times in their prime Graf 7-3 or 6-4

                    Goat??? One of fiercest competitors of all times only diva we will ever see in women's tennis

                    Idiot poster with ZERO clue about tennis
                    Comment
                    • pattymayo
                      SBR Posting Legend
                      • 05-19-09
                      • 10221

                      #11
                      Originally posted by jjgold

                      Idiot poster with ZERO clue about tennis
                      Comment
                      • SharkAA
                        SBR MVP
                        • 11-10-13
                        • 2005

                        #12
                        Originally posted by jjgold
                        Serena and Graf tough call
                        I think Graf's ground strokes would of buried Serena and she had a great serve also

                        If they play 10 times in their prime Graf 7-3 or 6-4

                        Goat??? One of fiercest competitors of all times only diva we will ever see in women's tennis

                        Idiot poster with ZERO clue about tennis
                        Who were you referring to, jj?
                        Comment
                        • felix_felicus7
                          SBR High Roller
                          • 04-19-13
                          • 175

                          #13
                          I always loved Steffi but Seles was dominating their h2h up to the time of the incident (which was sadly why it happened). As a result & thru no fault of her own, Steffi grabbed extra GS titles. Regarding Serena tho, I miss someone like Henin truly going toe to toe with her. Only Azarenka at full fitness, or Kvitova with a brain transplant, have the talent to provide consistently competitive matches against her.
                          Comment
                          • gaebiskon
                            SBR Wise Guy
                            • 03-10-12
                            • 869

                            #14
                            as disgusting as serena is, she is the best ever
                            and i also wouldn't be surprised if she won a gs in her 40s

                            penetrating wta
                            Comment
                            • Dmoneytx
                              SBR Hall of Famer
                              • 02-09-12
                              • 6450

                              #15
                              Originally posted by jjgold
                              Serena and Graf tough call
                              I think Graf's ground strokes would of buried Serena and she had a great serve also

                              If they play 10 times in their prime Graf 7-3 or 6-4

                              Goat??? One of fiercest competitors of all times only diva we will ever see in women's tennis

                              Idiot poster with ZERO clue about tennis
                              Sorry, but this has got to be the biggest laugh I have had in quite some time. Graf's groundies would of buried "Sarena's"??? Are you fing kidding me JJ??? I know you aren't a tennis guy, but this is just laughable. Have you ever actually watched Graf play a match?? Her eastern forehand, almost continental & her only slice backhand. And you think she would of eaten up Sarena's massive topspin power game? Oh Lord, lol!!! It's funny to me how someone can make a statement like that & really have no idea what they are really talking about.
                              And you think Graf would beat Sarena 70% of the time if they met in their primes?? Wow, JJ, just so you know Patty is right. Sarena would win probably 2&2 & it would be Graf that wins probably 3 of 10 match ups. Maybe! It was a different game back then. Lots of court massaging. Slicing. Rushing the net on over half her points. Etc.. You simply can't match that to today's game & power. Graf would of been abused coming to the net so much by the pace & control of Sarena's groundies. Actually, would be a fairly boring match if Sarena was on her game. It's like comparing McEnroe rushing the net every point in his old school tennis. You think Nadal would beat John in his prime? Lol.. Same answer with Sarena vs Graf IMO..
                              Not even close. What Graf did was amazing. What happ to Seles opened that path for her. Sarena has done it facing so many greats along the way. And yes, I could see her winning a GS even around 40 with her game. And yes, I would consider her the GOAT already not only bec or her accomplishments, but her pure psychical ability as well..
                              Comment
                              • jjgold
                                SBR Aristocracy
                                • 07-20-05
                                • 388189

                                #16
                                Serena could not take the pressure of Graf

                                Serena gets tight on long rallies and is erratic

                                Graf was not..would of pinned her to the baseline all day

                                Biggest mistake players make vs Serena is going for corners and over hitting

                                Of course so hard to compare different ages
                                Comment
                                SBR Contests
                                Collapse
                                Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                Collapse
                                Working...