There is a fukking defender on the line for Christ's sake!!
SamsNCharge99
SBR Aristocracy
10-22-08
41242
#2
agree
but I'll take it being on S. Africa Win/Draw
Comment
3PtShooter
SBR MVP
04-13-08
3936
#3
sounds like the announcers have money on Mexico
Comment
tltaylor89
SBR Posting Legend
06-19-09
19610
#4
Tell me about it Pavy dying for a Mexico goal
Comment
Smogs
SBR MVP
12-31-08
4173
#5
Come on guys, you have to know the off side rule before you can judge the ref.
He got it 100% RIGHT.
The GK was ahead of Vela meaning there would have had to be 2 players for Vela to be onside. Just one and he is offside.
Trust me on this
Comment
Jaug
SBR MVP
01-11-09
3087
#6
The rule is, 1 player or less behind attacker it's offside. Goalie was ahead of line and therefore correct offside.
Comment
colout
SBR Wise Guy
11-11-09
772
#7
Smogs is right here guys :-)
Comment
Pauulzcappin
SBR Posting Legend
04-23-10
20295
#8
Smogs is right.
Comment
pavyracer
SBR Aristocracy
04-12-07
82838
#9
I have to see the slow motion replay again. Was the goalie ahead of the player receiving the ball when the header was made?
Comment
SRBI
SBR Hall of Famer
10-20-09
8393
#10
Originally posted by Smogs
Come on guys, you have to know the off side rule before you can judge the ref.
He got it 100% RIGHT.
The GK was ahead of Vela meaning there would have had to be 2 players for Vela to be onside. Just one and he is offside.
Trust me on this
Nice Smogs, you know your isht
This game will end in a draw no doubt in my mind about it.
Comment
Cappinpicks
SBR Posting Legend
03-11-10
14986
#11
I knew NBA was fixed but soccer too?
Comment
Smogs
SBR MVP
12-31-08
4173
#12
Originally posted by Cappinpicks
I knew NBA was fixed but soccer too?
For the love of christ, how can the correct call presume a fixed game??!!
Comment
blackf1re
SBR Sharp
01-31-10
487
#13
Lol, maybe learn the actual rule before starting a thread.
Comment
Marginalis
SBR MVP
12-12-09
1862
#14
Originally posted by Smogs
Come on guys, you have to know the off side rule before you can judge the ref.
He got it 100% RIGHT.
The GK was ahead of Vela meaning there would have had to be 2 players for Vela to be onside. Just one and he is offside.
Trust me on this
Comment
mihaita666
SBR Hall of Famer
09-13-09
8596
#15
no offside, it was my initial guess too, but than I saw the rgk is in front....good ref overall so far.
Soccer record (2010) : 244-160-24
2010-2011 season (soccer) : 144-95-11
NBA Record (2010-2011 season) : 17-12-1
Comment
Cappinpicks
SBR Posting Legend
03-11-10
14986
#16
SA wins now that the refs had it fixed
Comment
SRBI
SBR Hall of Famer
10-20-09
8393
#17
Originally posted by SRBI
This game will end in a draw no doubt in my mind about it.
Comment
Sforz
SBR MVP
08-07-08
2221
#18
Originally posted by Smogs
Come on guys, you have to know the off side rule before you can judge the ref. He got it 100% RIGHT. The GK was ahead of Vela meaning there would have had to be 2 players for Vela to be onside. Just one and he is offside. Trust me on this
i was lmao at the announcers ... they should know the rules
Comment
hustla
SBR MVP
10-20-09
1235
#19
it was offside
Comment
hustla
SBR MVP
10-20-09
1235
#20
A player is in an offside position if he is in his opponents' half of the field and is nearer to his opponents' goal line than both the ball and the next to last opponent.
The 2005 edition of the Laws of the Game included a new International Football Association Board decision that stated being "nearer to an opponent's goal line" meant that "any part of his head, body or feet is nearer to his opponents' goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent (the last opponent typically being the goalkeeper). The arms are not included in this definition."[1] This is taken to mean that any part of the attacking player named in this decision has to be past the part of the second-last defender closest to his goal line (excluding the arms) and past the part of the ball closest to the defenders' goal line.
It is not necessary that the goalkeeper be one of the last two opponents. It should be noted that any attacker that is even with or behind the ball is not in an offside position and may never be sanctioned for an offside offense. Regardless of position, there is no offside offense if a player receives the ball directly from a goal kick, corner kick, or throw-in.
IFAB has clarified in the 2009-2010 Laws of the Game that a player temporarily off the field of play is considered to be ON the boundary line at the point that he crossed over the boundary line.[2]