Eli Manning Most Clutch QB in NFL

[mathdotcom]

Rings are so overrated

Tons of great players stuck on shit teams

If you really want to evaluate the worth of a player look at relevant stats

Win Loss
MVPs
Superbowl rings
Playoff games won
Division titles
etc. etc.

All complete garbage

[GamblerSpirit]

Rings are so overrated

STFU.

[dlunc3]

your won GM would trade vick for ELI right now in a heartbeat

you are 100% correct... but outside of that, he'd keep the eagles roster in a heartbeat

[Sam Odom]

Racism is rearing its ugly head in this thread... If Eli was a black guy he would be Darius Rucker

[ZetaPsi808]

Rings are so overrated

Tons of great players stuck on shit teams

If you really want to evaluate the worth of a player look at relevant stats

Win Loss
MVPs
Superbowl rings
Playoff games won
Division titles
etc. etc.

All complete garbage

i think Eli wold rate highly using those metrics ^^^

great regular season WL record

no MVP's

2 rings

8 playoff games won, maybe even more

1 division title

[mathdotcom]

Stats like passer ratings are not sexy but are much more telling, just like park-adjusted ERAs in baseball

But yeah, Eli's rings are all about him and nothing to do with the team around him... you're right... I concede...

[C-Gold]

I think the Giants only missed the playoffs 1 or 2 years with Eli as a starter
2 super bowls
2 super bowl MVPs
Playoff games won... on the road.

How many playoff games has Romo won?
How many playoff games has Vick won? or even been healthy for?

Look at how receivers have stepped in, done well with the giants and moved on, and not done as well.
Jermey Shockey
Kevin Boss
Jay Ballard
Steve Smith
Victor Cruz came out of nowhere
Manningham had success
Nicks has had success
He made the guys around him better but still has haters.

[mathdotcom]

Wonder how many rings Urlacher would have if the Bears didn't have horseshit QBs year after year...

[C-Gold]

Quarterbacks have more of an impact on teams than MLBs.

You could put the best kicker in NFL history on the Oakland Raiders and what would they have won the last 10 years? Nothing.

[KingJD31]

Eli is solid he has more let down games then any other star qb but when he's on he's got deadly accuracy

[ZetaPsi808]

eli manning proves again how good he is

look at the RB's and WR's he had to work with tonight when the giants won 36-7 on the road

http://espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=320920029

andre brown at RB

martellus bennett at TE

ramses barden at WR

none of these were any good before this season

[rm18]

Giants cover the 4th quarter every single game, even with a huge lead they cover

[p19101]

k13 mad eli kicked out 49ers last year

No news here, his buttocks are still sore.

[ZetaPsi808]

Giants cover the 4th quarter every single game, even with a huge lead they cover

No news here, his buttocks are still sore.

[Goat Milk]

Giants don't make playoffs this year

[ZetaPsi808]

Eli Manning does it again with another 4th quarter comeback and throwing the winning 77 yard TD bomb

damn i miss those haters

[ZetaPsi808]

[CanuckG]

Giants don't make playoffs this year

[p19101]

I think that is what k13 says every year

[Sam Odom]

http://forum.sbrforum.com/players-talk/1965232-eli-manning.html