I like the list but I think that Crosby should be 1 and Ovechkin 2. Ovechkin shoots about 3 times as much as Crosby and doesn't get THAT many more goals as a result of it. Crosby picks his spots a lot better, seems to get others involved a little bit more.
Comment
bigboydan
SBR Aristocracy
08-10-05
55420
#3
4. Lidstrom
I think you might be a bit bias with that one Deuce.
Comment
Deuce
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
01-12-08
29843
#4
Originally posted by bigboydan
4. Lidstrom
I think you might be a bit bias with that one Deuce.
Best D in the league even at 38. Best D of all time. There is not a team out there who would have him on their top line. He is clutch.
Comment
tullamore
SBR MVP
07-17-07
3586
#5
Phaneuf should be close to top 10.
Comment
Deuce
BARRELED IN @ SBR!
01-12-08
29843
#6
Originally posted by tullamore
Phaneuf should be close to top 10.
Yes
As well as Kane, Toews.
Comment
Dashwood Clipper
SBR MVP
03-12-08
1598
#7
Originally posted by Deuce
Best D in the league even at 38. Best D of all time. There is not a team out there who would have him on their top line. He is clutch.
Bobby Orr was pretty good.
Comment
Matt Rain
SBR Hall of Famer
02-13-07
5001
#8
Lidstrom definitely deserves to be there. Top 10, maybe top 5 defenseman of all time.