Who would you take......

[LVBOUND]

A healthy Derrick Rose or Russell Westbrook.

I would take Westbrook....kid is such a beast.

LV

[Br0nxer]

westbrook

kid is top 3-5 player in league if he can get attitude in check and cut down on turnovers

more explosive than a healthy rose

[jjgold]

Westbrook by far

Rose is Allen Iverson II one dimensional but with a great attitude
Rose cannot rebound, cannot defend, not a great passer

[InTheDrink]

if rose was paired with durant and they were both healthy they'd just close down the league and hand them the larry obrien

[Smoke]

Westbrook all day son

Rose is a walking corpse

Banged up

[Brock Landers]

both a couple of studs, of course everyone says westbrook now cause rose is injured

[Bcatswin]

[SmoovCruz]

bibby

[sweethook]

you know to much brock

[darkhat]

Westbrook no question in my mind. Don't know how it's a real debate.

[onlooker]

Westbrook.

[dudekid]

no one was singing this tune last year when d. rose was the MVP singlehandedly carrying the bulls, and westbrook was fighting with durant on the sidelines and jacking up terrible shots....

if rose and westbook are both healthy on their A game its definitely a debate, how can you say otherwise?

[LVBOUND]

I wish I could hear what everyone thought last year at this time. I can't remember who I liked better last year to be honest.

[onlooker]

Westbrook wears Nikes, so he isn't going to break down like Rose.

[Speedy88]

Can I take Chris Paul instead of those two?

[darkhat]

Westbrook wears Nikes, so he isn't going to break down like Rose.

that Nike Designer ripped Rose apart.

[celtics3388]

I'll take Rose from last year over this year's Westbrook

[d2bets]

At full strength Rose is/was better. But Rose may never be full strength again, and given that Rose is out probably for a year, of course anyone would take Westbrook now.

[face]

westbrook, kid gets better every week

[5mike5]

westbrook, kid gets better every week

[BigDofBA]

Westbrook. The guy isn't as fragile and he is taking making huge strides it seems like every month.

The guy has gotten even better than he was last year.

[Sport_Fish]

Only thing Westbrook really lacks is effective decision-making, which results in turnovers. Other than that, he is an explosive point guard.

[paranoyd androyd]

westbrook is a lot stronger

[tony_come]

Fisher fo sho

Jerry west thanks man

[Punter101]

At full strength Rose is/was better. But Rose may never be full strength again, and given that Rose is out probably for a year, of course anyone would take Westbrook now.

Rose might have reached his full strength but Westbrook keep's taking strides every year. Next year's Westbrook is gonna be better than this year's and 2014 Westbrook is going to be better than 2013 Westbrook, barring any injuries.....but Nikes got his back

[lunchbawks]

D rose absolutely. Westbrook almost shot OKC out of a win tonight. D rose would have gone to the rim for atleast foul shots.

cant stand these point guards like westbrook, athletic freak and he pull up from midrange over and over again

[tullamore21]

yeah that's the reason. moron

[deeznutz]

if rose was without injuries, rose ALL DAY

[tullamore21]

Dimitris Diamantidis and Vasilis Spanoulis are better

[therealdealau]

I think Westbrook has more room for improvement compared to Rose which is scary.

[ParlayJunkie]

Only two to choose from? neither. Chris Paul over both.

[Br0nxer]

no one was singing this tune last year when d. rose was the MVP singlehandedly carrying the bulls, and westbrook was fighting with durant on the sidelines and jacking up terrible shots....

if rose and westbook are both healthy on their A game its definitely a debate, how can you say otherwise?

The reason you didnt hear this debate last year is because westbrook wasnt anywhere near the player last year that he is now. His makeup is still questionable. But i would still take westbrook over a healthy rose. And that has really nothing to do with rose being hurt. Westbrook is better than a healthy Rose

[ngates815]

Westbrook.

And I'm from Chicago.

[flyingillini]

What's up Paul Wall, how you been?

[Br0nxer]

LV what was the weather like in south florida today