Eli Manning is better than Tom Brady now.

[dinaro7]

tom brady is the best qb in football now better than rodgers and both mannings if there had been one more minute ne would have won

[paranoyd androyd]

top 5 currenty:

Eli
Rodgers
Brees
Roethlisberger
Rivers

[beerman2619]

Some of you clowns need to post some stats up besides Eli having won 2 super bowls as the best qb in the league. Look at the stats kids Eli had his best season this year and wasn't even a top 3 qb in this league. Guy got lucky vs the 49ers easily could of had 2 ints and the Giants should of been sitting at home watching the super bowl if i wasn't for a rookie kickoff/punt returner. How many times has Eli won the mvp of the league uh thats right 0. Trent Dilfer has a super bowl ring also. Rings are nice and all. But the last 2 super bowls the Giants have won over the Pats has been because of there defense. Should of gave the mvp yesterday to the Giants d line or the punter. What did Eli do oh wow he threw for one td amazing. Great catch by Manningham also saved Eli's a$$. Eli might be in the top 5 but i don't see it right now. His wideouts make him look better then he is. Some great catches by Nicks yesterday and Manningham.

top 5 currenty:

Eli
Rodgers
Brees
Roethlisberger
Rivers

[millflavor]

eli is #4 behind brady brees and rodgers

[Monitor-Tan]

I'd say Brady, Brees, Rodgers then Eli. I agree with millflavor..

Brady still is the best right now because the fact is atleast he plays in the outdoors in a tough NE weather..

Brees does amazing things but has to be #2 because of his dome

Rodgers, has been GREAT BUT, way to short in his career. He's a system QB, 2 more season for Rodgers with great # like he is doing now he can make some great cases.

Eli Manning is #4, when he has his opportunity, he knows how to deliver, that's what makes you a winner. Not the retarded fantasy stats like half of you morons live by and ask why their QB got them 30 points in fantasy, but you lost..

If Eli gets another ring and Peyton doesn't, Eli pretty much will seal that he's better then peyton

[uhuhahah]

Eli will go to top next year. Roger will be #2. Brady is heading to bottom 10.

[Monitor-Tan]

With 2 rings already, I still feel, Eli has room to improve and just as this was his best season, he's got even better season ahead of him.. you can't teach to be calm like Eli and just deliver when it needs to be done.

[paranoyd androyd]

Eli will go to top next year. Roger will be #2. Brady is heading to bottom 10.

yep, have brady #7 of current QB's and falling fast.

[Thehusker]

1. Eli
2. Rodgers
3. Brees
3. (tie) Brady
5. Rapistberger

[ThaTopMoron]

Eli 2-0 in Super Bowls and 8-3 in the playoffs.

Brady below .500 in the playoffs last 5 years and a pro at losing Super Bowls.

.....

[Scorpion]

brady is 0-2 in legitimate super bowls