Eli Manning cracked top 50 QBs of all time tonight

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Maybe puts him as high as #45.

Lets see what he does in the next few years.

[NYSportsGuy210]

I have him ranked at #12. Ahead of Jim Kelley and Warren Moon.

[jjgold]

Yeh he is top 15 and maybe higher

His age makes him have a shot for top 5 eventually

[BigBlueNYG]

Lol top 45, that's funny. Seriously, you should get an act together and try it out somewhere.

LMAO top 50 maybe 45,

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Lol top 45, that's funny. Seriously, you should get an act together and try it out somewhere.

LMAO top 50 maybe 45,

I just looked at stats of past QBs. I'll admit i'd give him about the 40 spot.

He had a good game.

[Powderguy]

WHAT just top 50, get the fuk outta here, he was unreal this year...4th quarter $$$

[beerman2619]

agree

Yeh he is top 15 and maybe higher

His age makes him have a shot for top 5 eventually

[ZetaPsi808]

he is #9 of all time. easily

[Monitor-Tan]

I'd say he's top 15 right now.

He's clutch in the 4th quarter. Most TD's in the 4th quarter in single season.

One of the best QB rating in the 4th quarter..

come from behind win twice in the superbowl against the Pats..

Definitely a candidate for top 15..

He's still young, definitely has another shot or maybe even two more superbowls...

We shall have to see if he can crack top 10..

[big joe 1212]

top 50?

WAKE THE FUKK UP !!!!!

[NYSportsGuy210]

Nobody listens....he is #12 ahead of Jim Kelley and Warren Moon.

[Kindred]

name 40 QB's with better stats..two super bowl rings..two time super bowl MVP..more game winning drives

not easy...guy looks like a dufus but he's clutch, has ice water in his veins and comes through when it counts over and over again. But he looks like a dufus so he gets no respect

[Salmon Steak]

Maybe top ten. Look at the top superbowl winning QBs. Don't see Peyton on here. He is in elite company.

Terry Bradshaw (4)
Joe Montana (4)
Tom Brady (3)
Troy Aikman (3)
John Elway (2)
Roger Staubach (2)
Bob Griese (2)
Ben Roethlisberger (2)
Bart Starr (2)
Jim Plunkett (2)
Eli Manning (2)

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Doesnt he have 7% downs Syndrome? I read tht somewhere. Not sure if it is true though. He does a lot of shoulder twitching.

[millflavor]

top 50

[DiggityDaggityDo]

A lot of good QBs out there, guys.

[frostno98]

That's pretty low for a guy guaranteed to be in Canton at some point after his retirement.

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Not taking shots at Eli here. Top 40 is pretty damn good!!!

[Extra Innings]

He is the best, PERIOD!