Who makes more of an impact on the League as a rookie....

[flyingillini]

Rashard Mendenhall or
Darren Mcfadden



Gotta go with my ILLNI guy... Mendenhall is going to be a star in the league.

[Deuce]

Mendenhall will be a flash in the pan. Nothing more. Very hard to be a solid back in the leauge.

Jake Long will have the most impact btw.

[dwaechte]

Mendenhall's going to be a very good back, I'm not sure I can say the same about McFadden.

[element1286]

I hope it is Mendenhall, he doesn't look like he knows how to run yet, but that could change. Overall, McFadden is a much more polished back, and will get more carries.