Eli Manning is most underrated player in sports, period!

FlaxMartin · 12-18-11, 02:25 PM

wow, what a mistake at 4th down, instead of 20-0 its 17-3

paco · 12-18-11, 02:43 PM

Another pick for Eli

ebbearsfb1 · 12-18-11, 02:47 PM

Lmao.. o eli

beerman2619 · 12-18-11, 03:18 PM

Eli 3 ints today

.

ram749 · 12-18-11, 03:18 PM

Love the way he hits defensive backs in stride!! Vegas loves ya!!

p19101 · 12-18-11, 03:32 PM

Zebras are against the Giants as well today...

KingJD31 · 12-18-11, 03:34 PM

Originally posted by p19101

Zebras are against the Giants as well today...

did u see that bullshit pass int. call on the skins..........yeah sure w.e u say

Dark Horse · 12-18-11, 03:35 PM

Never seen a division leader playing for a playoff spot play this bad at home. They would have lost to a college team.

p19101 · 12-18-11, 03:37 PM

Originally posted by Dark Horse

Never seen a division leader playing for a playoff spot play this bad at home. They would have lost to a college team.

Terrible for sure, the whole team.

jjgold · 12-18-11, 03:43 PM

He will never be an elite QB
Way too many INT's at the wrong time
Not good enough of a record

McBa1n · 12-19-11, 07:02 PM

Sheesh, this thread is still alive? Are Giants fans still defending Eli?
The guy is a real good QB, but give it up on the elite thing already. If you'd like, we can go over game-by-game where Eli made plays that elite QBs DON'T make. The guy is a damn good QB, I think he's a better big game winner than his brother, but sheesh... And I'm not even thinking about yesterday. Yesterday is a HUGE knock at Eli's leadership. It's bad. A QB cannot be elite without being the leader of the team. I bet if you asked people who they thought was the 'leader' on the Giants and I bet a lot of them would say 'Tuck'. Stats aren't the only part of being a QB. Throwing a pick in the end zone in a critical spot after racking up 40-50 passing yards is NOT being a good QB. It's shit QB'n and stat whoring. Good QB play is to at least get 3 points on the board for the drive, not turning it over with a stupidly thrown pass. Elite play and good QB leadership is not having your team do fuckall the rest of the way after the critical pick (read: the game vs the Saints).

Sorry, clutch and elite QBs can't do a TON of stuff that Eli does. He's a nice QB, but he's probably borderline top 10, at best. He's not top 5 or top 6. Not even close. Peyton, Brady, Brees, Big Ben, Rivers, Rodgers - tell me you want him over any of those guys or he's better - he's not and never has been.

Louisvillekid1 · 01-30-12, 10:38 PM

After his 2nd ring on sunday, maybe you fukks will understand...

And oh yeah, this is coming from an Eagles fan...

Sambooka · 01-30-12, 10:49 PM

i love it.... This was a great thread to bump at the right time

the thread died down on 12-18-11 and after that weekend, Eli has not lost a game

GO GIANTS!!!

millflavor · 01-30-12, 11:16 PM

eli finally has weapons and we see his potential... peyton had borderline hall of famers (m harrison, r wayne, d clark) his whole carreer who did eli have? trouble maker plax? imagine if eli had a tight end like rodgers, brees, brady, or peyton had? he elevates the play of all of his teammates including stiffs like k boss and ballard

DJ Dana · 01-30-12, 11:37 PM

I'm a lifelong Skins fan and I just can't deny Eli's talent (in fact I've always been puzzled by fellow Skins fans that badmouth him w/o looking at how many times he's won already). His success has taken of course longer than his brother's but I've always felt he will always be measured alongside Peyton's accomplishments (for good or bad, fair or unfair). If he wins Sunday he really cements himself as arguably a top 5 QB in this league.