Goat's 5 who s/b in NY for Heisman

ChuckyTheGoat · 12-03-11, 08:15 PM

Originally posted by ChuckyTheGoat

Richardson, Alab
Mathieu, LSU
Luck, Stan
LM James, Oreg
KMoore, Boise

If Mathieu isn't in New York, it's a joke. Most dynamic player in country. Luck's star has dipped a bit. LM James is great, but missed a few games. I would list Montee Ball (WIS), but some of his success is a function of Wilson and the Off Line.

Really, the Heisman card should play out as:
1) Richardson
2) Mathieu

neverstoppers23 · 12-03-11, 08:18 PM

i don't get how you can dis-credit balls success but not dis-credit moore's success who is the pure by-product of the boise state system. hes a system qb.
also, monte ball is splitting carries with white, so his numbers could even be much larger. i believe i heard on espn that every 1/8 times ball touches the ball its a touch down.

i would have
griffin 3
luck
ball
luck
richardson

William Walters · 12-03-11, 08:34 PM

Barkley has got to be there....great, great numbers, top 10 team, and was the leader his team needed when they had no hopes of post season play this year.