Who is the better scrambler? Tebow or Vick?

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Both love to take off running with the ball.

[jjgold]

Vick much quicker with his feet

[poochiecollins]

In the short run, I'd probably take Vick. Long run, Tebow takes punishment much better.

[rm18]

Tebow, doesn't fumble

[arsenalxiv]

Vick is super fast but is susceptible to injuries and Tebow is built like a linebacker. Tebow all day!

[titanup]

Ill take tebow, Vick always gets hurt, noway he carries the ball 20+ times a game

[zsr]

Vick turns the ball over about 5 times as much as tebow when he runs, easy answer. Not to mention the injuries.

[DiggityDaggityDo]

Tebow will get injured bad soon if they keep letting him run, right?

Rember Steve Young? Of course he was not built like tebow, but the head/brain can only take so many hits.

[D3 Mighty Ducks]

I'd take Vick any day, any week, any year. Much more experience.

Vick's having a terrible season but he'll be back to his last year numbers year next year you can bank on that.

[FindTheLock]

I'd take tebow because he can throw for 3 completions -24 yards and still win by 3.

[will2survive]

Vick. Not even close

[face]

ben roethlisberger

[k13]

Tebow will get injured bad soon if they keep letting him run, right?

Rember Steve Young? Of course he was not built like tebow, but the head/brain can only take so many hits.

Yeah and he is in the HOF and looks like he could still play right now.

[neverstoppers23]

vick by a mile, its not even close. tebow has showed me nothing, and its a mystery to me how he keeps winning. it will end soon-enough though.

[Djstucky]

I'd take Vick any day, any week, any year. Much more experience.

Vick's having a terrible season but he'll be back to his last year numbers year next year you can bank on that.

Last year was a fluke...this is the mike vick you can anticipate until he retires...his style only works short term in the NFL and that term is over...lots of people want Vick to do amazing things but he gets hurt too often and isn't getting any younger...

[DiggityDaggityDo]

I'd take tebow because he can throw for 3 completions -24 yards and still win by 3.

[zsr]

Last year was a fluke...this is the mike vick you can anticipate until he retires...his style only works short term in the NFL and that term is over...lots of people want Vick to do amazing things but he gets hurt too often and isn't getting any younger...

It wasn't even effective all of last year, idk why people forget how average he was after that amazing stretch. He only had that great stretch because he was out of the league for 2 years and people forgot how to defend him. Since then, he's either back to his old zero work ethic ways, or defenses just figured him out.

[Djstucky]

It wasn't even effective all of last year, idk why people forget how average he was after that amazing stretch. He only had that great stretch because he was out of the league for 2 years and people forgot how to defend him. Since then, he's either back to his old zero work ethic ways, or defenses just figured him out.

I totally agree here...

[poochiecollins]

Tebow will get injured bad soon if they keep letting him run, right?

Yes.



If he didn't have God on his side.

I'd take tebow because he can throw for 3 completions -24 yards and still win by 3.

Lol.

[NYSportsGuy210]

I'll take a healthy Michael Vick or Donavan McNabb of 4 years ago over Tim Tebow in scrambling ANY DAY.

[YouHave2outs]

Tebow will get injured bad soon if they keep letting him run, right?

Rember Steve Young? Of course he was not built like tebow, but the head/brain can only take so many hits.

he has God on his side

[sunshine777]

Tebow is build like a linebacker and can take hits just like one. Most running backs in the NFL are smaller than Tebow but you don't hear anyone saying anything about them getting hurt or not being able to take the hits. Tebow can take the hits and is a new breed of quarterbacks that can run and throw. Yeah he can't throw it perfect today but he is going to figure it out you can count on that.

[zsr]

Tebow is build like a linebacker and can take hits just like one. Most running backs in the NFL are smaller than Tebow but you don't hear anyone saying anything about them getting hurt or not being able to take the hits. Tebow can take the hits and is a new breed of quarterbacks that can run and throw. Yeah he can't throw it perfect today but he is going to figure it out you can count on that.

Completely agree. He actually looked much better throwing today, and the thing is, if he's playing this good in the 4th quarter when he cant throw from the pocket, wait till he can throw