If You Don't Think Tony Romo is a Top 3 NFL QB.......

[19th Hole]

This is what happens when you send guys from New Jersey
(where people really are tough)
to Dallas (where people are full of hot air and
pretend to be tough!)

[Westcoast0]

This is what happens when you send guys from New Jersey
(where people really are tough)
to Dallas (where people are full of hot air and
pretend to be tough!)

right on bro chach

[racistrapist]

right on bro chach

lol there are no tough guys on the eastcoast...just bitter dooches like in this picture who grab their bawls and say "get da fuk outta heeeya"

[opie1988]

Romo on pace for 4500 yards, 35+ touchdowns, and 10 interceptions for this season.

What an incredible year Tony is having.

[dlunc3]

Romo on pace for 4500 yards, 35+ touchdowns, and 10 interceptions for this season.

What an incredible year Tony is having.

but may not make the playoffs yet again

[PAULYPOKER]

but may will not make the playoffs yet again

[SportsPedagogy]

but may not make the playoffs yet again

Thats a team effort.
If Romo had the Steelers defense, the way Big Ben does, he would have a Superbowl.
If Big Ben had the looks and charm that Romo does, he would be able to bang hotties like Romo does, instead , he has to rape ugly underage chicks.

[tragicend]

Hell yeah!!! Go niners!!!

[freakydave]

Thats a team effort. If Romo had the Steelers defense, the way Big Ben does, he would have a Superbowl. If Big Ben had the looks and charm that Romo does, he would be able to bang hotties like Romo does, instead , he has to rape ugly underage chicks.

Assumes facts not in evidence.EPIC FAIL

[JAKEPEAVY21]

you're on crack if you think Romo is a top 3 QB, sorry opie.

[freakydave]

Romo on pace for 4500 yards, 35+ touchdowns, and 10 interceptions for this season. What an incredible year Tony is having.

It's all well & fine to look at those stats & conclude he's having a good year but those 10 int's cost his team at least 3 games & may well be a big reason why they don't make the playoffs.AS opposed to an actual elite QB Aaron Rodgers 39 tds 6 int's 4125 yds-His 6 int's cost his team nothing.

[doylfish]

top 3 eh? so behind brady and rodgers...is romo? what about manning?

[SportsPedagogy]

Assumes facts not in evidence.EPIC FAIL

Romo never threw more picks then TD passes ... Big Ben did. The steelers have always had a solid running game aswell. Big Ben is a glorified Tim Tebow.

[SportsPedagogy]

Assumes facts not in evidence.EPIC FAIL

This thread is based entirely off of assumption. We speculate what makes a QB great. If we went off of statistics, Romo would be #4 as he is one of only 4 QBs t have a passer rating over 100.

Anything that is not based off of INDIVIDUAL performance is purely speculation.

[Delirium tremens]

The difference between Romo and Tebow is Tebow shows up in the 4th quarter.

[SportsPedagogy]

The difference between Romo and Tebow is Tebow shows up in the 4th quarter.

Your right... the guy with the highest 4thq QB rating of all time doesnt show up in the 4th Q

[dlunc3]

Thats a team effort.
If Romo had the Steelers defense, the way Big Ben does, he would have a Superbowl.
If Big Ben had the looks and charm that Romo does, he would be able to bang hotties like Romo does, instead , he has to rape ugly underage chicks.

So it is just a GIANT coincidence that Rodger's, Brady's, Peyton's, Brees's, Roth's teams all make the playoffs every year? weird how that works huh?

[SportsPedagogy]

So it is just a GIANT coincidence that Rodger's, Brady's, Peyton's, Brees's, Roth's teams all make the playoffs every year? weird how that works huh?

I will give you that Rodgers, Brady and Brees are elite. I think Romo is top 5, bar none.
The Cowboys were nothing without Romo. When he got hurt last year, they got blown out the next two games then Phillips was fired.

Ben Rothilsburgers offense averages 1.2 ppg more then Tim Tebows this season. If the Steelers did not have such a good defense, Rothilsburger would be just another QB.

[dlunc3]

I will give you that Rodgers, Brady and Brees are elite. I think Romo is top 5, bar none.
The Cowboys were nothing without Romo. When he got hurt last year, they got blown out the next two games then Phillips was fired.

Ben Rothilsburgers offense averages 1.2 ppg more then Tim Tebows this season. If the Steelers did not have such a good defense, Rothilsburger would be just another QB.

part of being a qb is being clutch when it matters though, and making plays to win the game for your team... Big ben does that... its not just all stats---that is fantasy football.

Sure the cowboys got blown out the two games after romo left, most teams do when their starting qb goes down... BUT, do you remember what the cowboys record was WITH Romo starting, before he got hurt?? Heres a hint (they lost 5 games, but they only played six)... heres the answer (1-5 )

[dlunc3]

and how can you even put him ahead of Eli? let alone peyton?? Eli has better numbers this yr and has a sb under his belt.. not to mention the cowboys have a MUCH more talented team then the giants

[JosephPavs]

#50+yearoldmalefaceliftcreepsmeout #lovetoseethecowgirlslose

[SportsPedagogy]

and how can you even put him ahead of Eli? let alone peyton?? Eli has better numbers this yr and has a sb under his belt.. not to mention the cowboys have a MUCH more talented team then the giants

Peyton is not playing this year.
How does Eli have better numbers ? Im going to give you pass on that one cause your logic is alot more solid then most posters on this site.
I looked it up, Eli has thrown for more yards and thrown more interceptions.
Romo has thrown for more touchdowns and has a higher completion percentage. His biggest weapon this year was a man cut by several teams.

Dallas rushes for more yards, but they only have 4 rushing touchdowns all season. The Giants have 13.
Dallas offense is ALL Romo

[SportsPedagogy]

part of being a qb is being clutch when it matters though, and making plays to win the game for your team... Big ben does that... its not just all stats---that is fantasy football.

Sure the cowboys got blown out the two games after romo left, most teams do when their starting qb goes down... BUT, do you remember what the cowboys record was WITH Romo starting, before he got hurt?? Heres a hint (they lost 5 games, but they only played six)... heres the answer (1-5 )

Big Ben threw a bad pick vs the Browns that could have let them take the lead late but his defense bailed him out again. Romo makes plenty of clutch 4th q plays. They are all dismissed as "Not Big games" which is funny cause every game this year has been a game Dallas NEEDED to win.

Last season Romo had the highest completion percentage in the NFL and an average 11 touchdowns and 7 picks. (5 of which went off of his receivers hands, 3 for Miles austin, 2 for Jason Witten)
I am basically trying to say that he played really well before his injury.

People are just really hard on Romo for some reason. He keeps Dallas in games. I love having him as the cowboys QB. It seems people just want to find any little thing to bash him for. After they lost to the Giants, all anybody talked about was Romo chocking and missing a wide open Austin, then austin admits he lost the ball in the lights, the replay shows him looking around trying to find it and ponting to the lights after the play, yet people say that he is just covering for Romo, and it is still Romos fault. Some people just want to see Romo fail the same way they want to see Vick fail. You can not use logic against that.

[dlunc3]

Eli his averaging 35 more yards per game, while his wrs have also been beat up this yr, with his main weapon being an undrafted free agent... His best RB has also been down most of the year.. Point being though... yes, their numbers are similar, both have had great statistical years.. but, you gotta give the edge to Eli as right now they are the favorite to win the division and he has a ring on his finger. They in my mind are very close, but I think Eli has the step bc his proven ability to win big games. I still say top five are:

Top 5-
Rodgers
Brady
Peyton
Brees
Roth

6. Rivers (even though hes had a down yr)
7. 8. 9. Romo, Eli, Vick (all interchangeable depending on personal preference... i know Im a homer having Vick there, but when fully healthy, which is rare, he is def up with these guys)

[dlunc3]

I like romo and think he is a good qb... but at this point, struggle to put him top 5, esp not top 3. He is very talented, but there are other just as talented qbs that are proven big time winners

[SportsPedagogy]

The vick that played Dallas could beat any team in the league. It might be in part to Dallas having a bad secondary, but Vick was on the money with every pass.

Romo has had banged up receivers. Lets not forget Miles Austin was an undrafted Free agent (Just like Romo) and Romo beat the 49ers and Redskins with practice squad receivers.

[jsmithj88]

there really isnt that much of a difference in eli and romos stats
difference is 3 % completion, 3 ints, 1 td, 500 yards
same record, weak defenses, up and down running games, injuries

[PAULYPOKER]

Tonight's game won't do shit for his rep if he has a good game performance,

but if he loses,

this will all but prove he is Mr choke artist when it counts as he has done throughout his career........

LOL @ sport ped for still clinging to Romo's nutsack.........

[opie1988]

Tonight's game won't do shit for his rep if he has a good game performance,
but if he loses,
this will all but prove he is Mr choke artist when it counts as he has done throughout his career........
LOL @ sport ped for still clinging to Romo's nutsack.........

No reason to be a dikk, pal.

Get over yourself.

[beerman2619]

i actually agree with Dlunc and his list.

[Blissit02]

I'm from Texas, and I tell you what, the most ignorant, arrogant fan in sports is those who go for the Dallas Cowboys, that team has more TALENT then any of team in the league....that is always their argument. Yet they dont win SHIT....You give Tom Brady that defense and those recievers and Tom doesnt lose a game in 4 years....Now Brady has slipped to number to in the league. I'm a die hard patriots fan! But you are from Texas you are asking yourself. Well when my Oilers left, I had to pick a new team and I really liked this QB out of Washington....Drew Bledsoe....Been a die hard fan ever since....Tony Romo when on his game is in the top 7...No way in the top 3...

[opie1988]

I'm from Texas, and I tell you what, the most ignorant, arrogant fan in sports is those who go for the Dallas Cowboys, that team has more TALENT then any of team in the league....that is always their argument. Yet they dont win SHIT....You give Tom Brady that defense and those recievers and Tom doesnt lose a game in 4 years....Now Brady has slipped to number to in the league. I'm a die hard patriots fan! But you are from Texas you are asking yourself. Well when my Oilers left, I had to pick a new team and I really liked this QB out of Washington....Drew Bledsoe....Been a die hard fan ever since....Tony Romo when on his game is in the top 7...No way in the top 3...

"Diehard Patriots fan from Texas".

Get the fukk out, Benedict Arnold. Yes, I'm sure you were a GIANT Pats fan when they were 2-14.

Let me guess....you're a die-hard Red Sox fan too (.....but of course wayyyy before '04)

Romo 18 of 22 for 190 yards. 3 passing touchdowns, 1 rushing touchdown.........in the 1st half.

[PAULYPOKER]

Dallas will not make the play-offs.............

[hels]

and then this top 5 qb fumbles the ball for a defensive td when winning 28-0

[PAULYPOKER]

Romo Fukks up again,just can't seem to play a whole game without lookin like one of Jerry's kids even when it is handed to him.........