Who's the best NFL Quarterback

[TodaysAction]

you've ever seen in your lifetime?

[jjgold]

Elway or Brady maybe

[max_asdf]

romo

[topgame85]

ELWAY no comparison Brady and Romo blow

[Brock Landers]

Can't remember many being better than Montana, more consistently good than anyone else.

[element1286]

I'd go with Elway/Manning/Brady, all did it different ways, but all great none the less.

[Doc JS]

romo

You are either kidding or havent lived very long...

[Doc JS]

ELWAY no comparison Brady and Romo blow

TG, please explain how Brady "blows"...
He's won three SB's.
He owns the NFL single season TD record.
He had a QB rating of 117.2 last year.

You don't have to like him. But to say he "blows"...

[Red_Sux]

matt cassel

[Deuce]

Brady

/thread

[Doc JS]

matt cassel

I'm thinking we need a penalty box of sorts for posts like this...

[Sabanbama]

Brady or Montana!!!

[bigboydan]

I gotta go with Dan Marino

[Hoja Verdes]

gotta go with Peyton...the most cerebral of everyone mentioned here.

[Panic]

With rings: Montana/Elway

Without rings:Marino/Fouts/Moon

[bettilimbroke999]

matt cassel

It's a lock

[bigboydan]

With rings: Montana/Elway

Without rings:Marino/Fouts/Moon

I think Warren Moon was a product of that run and shoot style offense he ran in Houston under Pardee and Mouse Davis. Now if you take that away from him, I doubt he would even be considered to be on your list sir.

[bettilimbroke999]

Peyton, not just b/c I'm from TN either, he's just flat out the best QB I've ever seen, close 2nd would be Elway

[Richkas]

Marino

Played his whole career without a running game.

[Panic]

I think Warren Moon was a product of that run and shoot style offense he ran in Houston under Pardee and Mouse Davis. Now if you take that away from him, I doubt he would even be considered to be on your list sir.

Dont know about that BBD. That system was there before Warren Moon and after him. And know one came close to his numbers. When you talk about a system usually the quarterbacks will florish, regardless who they are. IE: Kurt Warner/Trent Green/Marc Bulger in St. Louis.

Warren was inducted into the hall of fame. Dont see another houston quarterback inducted for them.


Here's another quarterback no one mentions. He has 3 rings and had incredible accuracy and poise. That was Troy Aikman.

[Shark79]

Elway - Brady

[b.hess1]

Best I've seen in person.. Manning and McNabb (in his prime)

[frostno98]

Elways the most exciting QB to watch out of the top 5 Greats

ELWAy
JOE COOL
Brady
Manning
Marino

[smitch124]

Steve Young

[bigugly]

Tarvaris Jackson.

[gordon gekko]

Brady.

[Crayzee]

montana

[nysmoneyman]

roger staubach #12...he is the reason why i love football

i was little when i watched him playing but i knew what i was seeing was special

After his required service in the United States Navy, including a tour of duty in Vietnam, Staubach joined the Dallas Cowboys. He led the club to four Super Bowl appearances, with victories in Super Bowl VI and Super Bowl XII. Staubach was named Most Valuable Player of Super Bowl VI. He was named to the Pro Bowl six times during his eleven-year NFL career.

[daggerkobe]

Jim Plunkett. Never seen anyone throw deep balls as well as this guy. Oh and he won two SBs after he was considered washed up.

[Marigold HD]

in my time ------Brady

[hoopster42]

elway, montana, very difficult to pick, they were both so incredibly good at passing, pocket-feel/avoiding pressure, leadership, clutchness, just everything, tom brady right up there with those 2 in my book

[topcat]

ELWAY no comparison Brady and Romo blow

i agree with you on romo,but not brady.brady has never played with ha really good recievers,with the exception of moss,and please dont give branch.elway,marino[i know he never won the big one,but he truly never had a back worth a darn].terell davis was the one that pushed the first super bowl for elway. i have never seen anybody use the two minute drill like jim kelly,nick named the k gun.montano,them young,and farve[great stat.but needs to keep the interceptions down]warrem moon..its hard to say,but peyton manning is the best.him changing the plays at the line of scrimmage are brilliant.he does need to win another superbowl though.

[topcat]

roger staubach #12...he is the reason why i love football

i was little when i watched him playing but i knew what i was seeing was special

After his required service in the United States Navy, including a tour of duty in Vietnam, Staubach joined the Dallas Cowboys. He led the club to four Super Bowl appearances, with victories in Super Bowl VI and Super Bowl XII. Staubach was named Most Valuable Player of Super Bowl VI. He was named to the Pro Bowl six times during his eleven-year NFL career.

great choice,and a great man.he would have had better numbers,but he had to do his military commitment,like david robinson.