Game Tying Drive- Peyton or Eli?

DrStale · 11-10-11, 10:13 PM

You drunk? I'd take Peyton right now even a frozen neck.

rm18 · 11-10-11, 10:14 PM

Eli is the best 4th quarter QB ever whether clutch or garbage time

will2survive · 11-10-11, 10:17 PM

Joe Montana is the best 4th quarter QB ever (better than Elway)....saying that, Eli is very clutch

ttwarrior1 · 11-10-11, 10:20 PM

don't forget eli has thrown a goaline td 2 times this year and they lost both games, they are beating teams they should beat

Monitor-Tan · 11-10-11, 10:22 PM

Eli, all the way. Peyton chokes hard when in a must win situations.

The High Flier · 11-10-11, 10:23 PM

Since 2007 Eli has more regular season wins and is 4-2 in the playoffs. Peyton is 2-4 in the playoffs.

Dirty Sanchez · 11-10-11, 10:28 PM

Originally posted by will2survive

This used to be so automatic. Even though Peyton is one of the all time greats, I would choose Eli. Eli is more clutch.

Anyone agree?

Eli...because Peyton can't even grip a ball

KingJD31 · 11-10-11, 10:32 PM

ill take john beck over eli

zoo youk · 11-10-11, 10:34 PM

Originally posted by KingJD31

ill take john beck over eli

paco · 11-10-11, 10:35 PM

Peyton.

Sambooka · 11-10-11, 10:37 PM

Peytons better days are behind him

The High Flier · 11-10-11, 10:39 PM

Eli has the second highest wonderlic score for a QB behind Ryan Fitzpatrick (Harvard grad has the NFL record for score 48/50 and fastest completion at like 6 minutes). Smart QBs don't make bad throws. As Eli said, he is not a 25 int QB. At least half those ints last year were off wrs hands.

bet420 · 11-10-11, 10:43 PM

Peyton all dayyy

bet420 · 11-10-11, 10:46 PM

I got giants friends, before this little "hot" streak every other week its "Eli is a fukkin pussy loser" He's like the NFC Joe Flacco

NYSportsGuy210 · 11-10-11, 10:50 PM

Originally posted by The High Flier

Eli has the second highest wonderlic score for a QB behind Ryan Fitzpatrick (Harvard grad has the NFL record for score 48/50 and fastest completion at like 6 minutes). Smart QBs don't make bad throws. As Eli said, he is not a 25 int QB. At least half those ints last year were off wrs hands.

This.

The one thing about Eli people don't understand is that he has a tremendous football IQ and mind. He gets how to play the position and how to perform as an efficient QB in the system. He could retire tomorrow and become a top notch QB coach for any NFL team the next day.

The High Flier · 11-10-11, 10:55 PM

Originally posted by bet420

I got giants friends, before this little "hot" streak every other week its "Eli is a fukkin pussy loser" He's like the NFC Joe Flacco

New York attitude and media is exactly why Eli doesn't get the respect he deserves. The place is a pressure cooker and if you aren't the 1996-2000 Yankees then you suck.

It's fine by me. I cashed in on the +400 ML on the Giants vs the Pats.

bet420 · 11-10-11, 10:56 PM

Peyton has been refered to being a coach from the colts even before he was injured. Main reason their offense is so fukkin bad is because Peyton is the play caller, he controls the tempo, everything. Pretty smart

bet420 · 11-10-11, 10:58 PM

I like Eli not a giants fan or colts fan, but if both their carrers ended now, Peyton comes out on top

D3 Mighty Ducks · 11-11-11, 07:18 PM

Neither. I'd take Matty Ice

Wrigley · 11-11-11, 07:22 PM

Eli

thejrichshow85 · 11-11-11, 07:25 PM

peyton

ThaTopMoron · 11-11-11, 07:33 PM

the last time Peyton drove the Colts down the field, it was to take the lead vs the Jets with a bunch of backups in a playoff game leaving less than a minute on the clock.

yes, the Jets - who then went on to beat up on a 36 TD 4 INT MVP Brady... and came close to a SB berth.

dlunc3 · 11-11-11, 09:03 PM

how is this even an argument? bc eli is having his first good yr of his career? the easy part of his schedule is over...lets bring this back up in 6 weeks..

surffreak · 11-11-11, 09:17 PM

this has to be a big joke.

Peyton is the comeback king, he has 35 fourth quarter comebacks, and 46 game winning drives in his career.

You go on youtube and you can find so many vids on peytons amazing comeback drives that he has had throughout his career. Eli has one decent year when peyton is hurt. Does anyone remember how bad eli has played in the past?

Full Time Hobo · 11-11-11, 09:39 PM

Peyton because Eli has down syndrome

KingJD31 · 11-11-11, 10:49 PM

Originally posted by Full Time Hobo

Peyton because Eli has down syndrome

haahahhhaahaha

eidolon · 11-11-11, 10:56 PM

I was always a Giants fan until they picked up Eli. Haven't liked them since.He is an above average QB, but I wouldn't give him all the love some ppl give him.

LT Profits · 11-11-11, 11:02 PM

Peyton in a landslide for now, although Eli has potential.

LT Profits · 11-11-11, 11:04 PM

Originally posted by Sambooka

Peytons better days are behind him

Not true at all unless the injury is worse than people are saying, Peyton had his best season last year.

Masu485 · 11-11-11, 11:08 PM

Rivers... no question.

BarkingToad · 11-12-11, 07:56 AM

Not enough info to answer the question, are we talking meaningless regular season game against a not so good team or a playoff game?

Monitor-Tan · 11-12-11, 08:53 AM

Originally posted by surffreak

this has to be a big joke.

Peyton is the comeback king, he has 35 fourth quarter comebacks, and 46 game winning drives in his career.

You go on youtube and you can find so many vids on peytons amazing comeback drives that he has had throughout his career. Eli has one decent year when peyton is hurt. Does anyone remember how bad eli has played in the past?

Meaningless stat to say since Peyton's played about 6 and half more years of football then Eli did. You can bring up that arguement when both players retire and their stats are final. But for now that stat is meaningless. Now if we were to crunch it up and bring out a % of drives where they comeback for 4th quarter come from behind drivers on failure and sucess %, that'd be a bit more credible stat for now

k13 · 11-12-11, 09:23 AM

Will either one win another Super Bowl?

No.