Who are the top 10 NFL QB's of all time ?

[EmpireMaker]

Who are the top 10 NFL QB's of all time ?

[VegasInsider]

Brady
Montana
Manning
Favre
Elway
Unitas
Marino
S. Young
Moon
Bradshaw

[EmpireMaker]

Starr
Unitas
Namath
Griese
Staubach
Montana
who else ?

[EmpireMaker]

Starr
Unitas
Namath
Griese
Staubach
Montana
who else ?

Starr
Unitas
Namath
Griese
Staubach
Montana
Favre
Bradshaw

[onetrickpony]

1. peyton manning
2-10. u aint nothing if u aint numero uno

[rsnnh12]

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Marino
4. Manning
5. Elway
6. Young
7. Johnny U
8. Staubach
9. Tarkenton
10. Baugh/Favre

Winning list

[InTheDrink]

Bradshaw?

Montana
Elway
Brady
Manning
Unitas
Marino
Favre
Rodgers
Kelly (keep in mind he lost a few years to USFL)
Young

[Sunde91]

bradshaw and tarkenton = hang yourself

arm chair QBs so smaat

[Brock Landers]

Namath belongs nowhere on this list, had more INT's than td's

[VegasInsider]

Bradshaw?

Montana
Elway
Brady
Manning
Unitas
Marino
Favre
Rodgers
Kelly (keep in mind he lost a few years to USFL)
Young

How can you have Rodgers on the list already? What if he gets injured in the coming weeks and is done for his career...would he still be Top 10 All-Time??

The answer is no.

Rodgers will most likely become one of the all time greats....but not yet.

[Roadtrip635]

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Marino
4. Manning
5. Elway
6. Young
7. Johnny U
8. Staubach
9. Tarkenton
10. Baugh/Favre

Winning list

Pretty close to what i would have except to replace Tarkenton with Starr.

[rsnnh12]

bradshaw and tarkenton = hang yourself

arm chair QBs so smaat

Thanks for your wonderful list

[rsnnh12]

Pretty close to what i would have except to replace Tarkenton with Starr.

How the hell did I forget Starr?!?

Well, looks like I've got 4 guys fighting for the last 2 spots

[mighty maron]

in no order

Fouts
Marino
Elway
Staubach
Brady
Montana
Unitas
Blanda
Bradshaw
Manning

[str]

no order:

Baugh
Graham
Unitas
Starr
Elway
Montana
Brady
Manning
Marino
Staubach

[Goat Milk]

Starr Unitas Namath Griese Staubach Montana who else ?

just wondering how old are you if you don't mind me asking?

also fyi steve young called tom brady one of the top 2-3 of all time right now and joe montana said that when he's done he'll easily be the best of all time.

[tokio]

Rodgers will make the list in a few years.

[mh217]

montana easily the best..marino prob #2...kind of surprised no love for aikman or fouts

[EmpireMaker]

Starr
Unitas
S Young
Griese
Staubach
Montana
Favre
Brady
Manning
Baugh/Bradshaw

[tcpugh5]

Hard to compare different eras. Much more of a passing league than it was 15 years ago.

[GoBlue77]

Rodgers will make the list in a few years.

by the end of his career, i concur.

[InTheDrink]

How can you have Rodgers on the list already? What if he gets injured in the coming weeks and is done for his career...would he still be Top 10 All-Time??

The answer is no.

Rodgers will most likely become one of the all time greats....but not yet.

What can I say? I'm edgy. put him in for the same reason I'd also put Pedro in the top 5 pitchers of all time because he was the most dominant of his era by a lot even if not for a long stretch.

Has Aikman become an underrated qb over time? I didn't say he's top 10 but he's not far outside. Sme of these other lists are fukkin ridiculous. Namath? Staubach? GRIESE????

[EmpireMaker]

Jim Kelly better than Staubach ??? Really ???

[beerman2619]

1. Leaf
2. Jamarcus Russell

[EmpireMaker]

Marino put up nice stats but was never a good team player and never won the big one, so I left him off. I agree Namath doesn't belong on the list.

[d2bets]

In no order...

Montana
Brady
Manning
Graham
Unitas
Luckman
Young
Elway
Starr
Marino

[Adm. Cowpollock]

Montana
Marino
Manning
Brady
Favre
Elway
Unitas
Young
Bradshaw
Starr

[mdemps9190]

1. Montana
2. Brady
3. Marino
4. Manning
5. Elway
6. Young
7. Johnny U
8. Staubach
9. Tarkenton
10. Baugh/Favre

Winning list

Similar except I think Brady will be # 1. Peyton # 3 not Marino...I don't think Favre is # 10. Don't know much about Tarkenton (only 21 years old).

[iifold]

1.Brady
2.Rodgers
3Montana
4.Elway
5.Young

The rest are not even on these guys level...

[yD]

Guys I would want in a regular season game against the Browns.

Manning
Marino
Elway
Unitas
Brees
Moon
Fouts
Rivers
Kelly
Young

Guys I would want in the playoffs, win or go home.

Montana
Brady
Starr
Bradshaw
Aikman
Staubach
Favre
Roethlisberger
McNair
Otto Graham

[Goat Milk]

1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Marino

everything else is a toss up to me

[t-wizzle]

1. Montana
2. Unitas
3. Brady
4. Marino
5. Elway
6. Favre
7. Young

Fukk this list i don't feel like going any further. All i know is that i can't put manning in there. Maybe at #10.

[rsnnh12]

Similar except I think Brady will be # 1. Peyton # 3 not Marino...I don't think Favre is # 10. Don't know much about Tarkenton (only 21 years old).

I think Brady will be #1 as well, if he can win another ring and play 3+ years of elite football. I based my rank of him and Manning on if they retired tomorrow.

[Djstucky]

Brady is the total package. Records, MVP's, Rings, Longevity, Game winning drives, Competitiveness, etc... Lots of great quarterbacks in the league over the years but Tom ranks #1 or very high in all categories we measure great or the greatest qb's of all time. This guy wasn't a high draft pick and hasn't always had great recievers.

[EmpireMaker]

any other thoughts?