Should garrard go to the raiders?

[UntilTheNDofTimE]

I thought at the beginning of the season he was a great fit for that offense. He can air the ball out a lot more than campbell and the raiders offensive make up is very similiar to the jaguars when he was at his best.

What do you think about the raiders picking him up.

[EaglesPhan36]

Would probably make better sense than trying to trade for Carson Palmer.

[slatter]

Has he even kept himself in shape at all? Would seem like that's the biggest question surrounding him.

[bb_skoots]

an out of shape Garrard is better than Kyle Boller.

[jarvol]

There is virtually no difference between Campbell and Boller. If the Raiders were satisfied with their QB play before they should be satisfied now.

[samgurt]

Just last week Garrard said he was in top shape

[jess40]

Just last week Garrard said he was in top shape

ya but i heard few days ago he ate at a buffet...

[PhillyFlyers]

Palmer is better than both Boller or Garrard.

[Ice House]

start Terelle Pryor he might be the next Cam Newton

[VegasInsider]

It makes sense, but I want to see Pryor get some snaps!

[oiler]

seems they are doing good with what they have,why mess with a good thing

[samgurt]

seems they are doing good with what they have,why mess with a good thing

Cuz their qb broke his collarbone

[JAKEPEAVY21]

I think Garrard would be a great fit for the Raiders

[JAKEPEAVY21]

I thought at the beginning of the season he was a great fit for that offense. He can air the ball out a lot more than campbell and the raiders offensive make up is very similiar to the jaguars when he was at his best.

What do you think about the raiders picking him up.

couldn't agree more. As a Chargers fan, I'm hoping they don't sign him.

[crustyme]

no go on garrard. hes having back surgery.

looks like its palmer or bust.

[iwantcougars]

i doubt the bengals trade palmer. i doubt the raiders will ship a 1st for him

[jmdudney]

or maybe they could go get ryan NFL leaf

[testertips]

raiders shouldn't give up a 1st for palmer... 4th + the 5th makes sense. if not, go with boller, campbell isn't much better and i don't want to see the raiders pick up garrard. i would like to see the kid pryor take some snaps too.

[FishFace5]

i doubt the bengals trade palmer. i doubt the raiders will ship a 1st for him

Well a first should be out of the question.
Hopefully the worthless bengals owner will understand they already have the QB of the future for them and they need to get something for palmer.

[The Bet Master]

[spurginobili]

no go on garrard. hes having back surgery.

looks like its palmer or bust.

This. http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/71...ampbell-injury

[KKoz9]

That's potentially one heck of a tight end

[NYSportsGuy210]

A healthy Garrard would have been a decent fit for that club. Looks like Palmer or bust now.