Eli Manning is an "elite" QB . . .

[SportsPedagogy]

Did you watch the Cowboys game ? Dallas was only ahead thanks to Romo. The first INT was bad, the second was his receivers fault for not hustling. That's usually always the case when a slant is picked off. Either way, the offense was horrid in their attempts to tackle, it wasn't like the defenders ran untouched into the endzone. My point of all of this is, however, that everybody was so quick to give Romo all of the Blame he didn't deserve and now everyone is undeservedly blaming their QBs for the loses. Thought it was ironic

[slacker00]

I'll take Rivers over Eli any day, so that's a knock. But I'll take Eli over the majority of starters in the NFL.

[stevenash]

I'll take Rivers over Eli any day, so that's a knock. But I'll take Eli over the majority of starters in the NFL.

I'm a NYG die hard, I'd take Rivers over Eli in a heartbeat.
Don't love Eli, or hate him, thing is one week he plays like Joe Montana, one week he plays like (fill in your all time shitty QB here)

[SportsPedagogy]

What exactly has Phillip rivers accomplished that Romo hasn't ?

[Jag8917]

Eli Manning did not cost them that game. See: defense.

[Ballinrees]

Eli didnt play how he should have and their defense was horrible...they arent Sb contenders or even close to it.

[FishFace5]

What exactly has Phillip rivers accomplished that Romo hasn't ?

Rivers is head and shoulders above Romo.
I would take Eli over Romo as well.