One year from now, will Cam Newton be a top 5 NFL QB?

[Albert Pujols]

Some say yes.

[rsnnh12]

If Peyton comes back, no.
Brady
Rodgers
Peyton
Brees
Rivers

I don't see him beating out any of those

[Bcatswin]

I think he is def going to be better than all of us ever thought.

[Tree Rollins]

No way. I'm not sure he'll be a top 10 QB....Qb's usually play better in their 1st year then 2nd. I don't know if it's b/c defenses figure them out or what. Look at Sam Bradford...Happened to Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco to i think

Will he be better then Aaron Rodgers, Philip Rivers, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Matthew Stafford, Matt ryan, Tony Romo, Joe Flacco, Ben Roethlisberger, Matt Schaub?.....There are a lot of good QB's

[8ArIvd5]

some like the smell of farts

[AlwaysDrawing]

Who knows. Could be the next Vick. Certainly no one could have claimed to expect his performance so far this season.

[zsr]

Who knows. Could be the next Vick. Certainly no one could have claimed to expect his performance so far this season.

He's already as good as vick, vicks nowhere near top 5. Reminds me of big ben only faster.

[Glitch]

if he stays with steve smith, he can do a lot of things. ive known and said cam was a good passer for a long time.

[doublej95]

It's an insult to compare him to Vick.

[Ice House]

He's a top 5 QB right now. Next year Panthers will have Justin Blackmon

[upscope]

[sneakerhead]

No, not top 5 at least

[face]

i like cam but he's 1-3, could not beat jay cutler, what has he done that makes you think he will be top five?

[EmpireMaker]

yes I think he will

[jsmithj88]

let the dude play a couple years before we put him in any lists
lots of people have a great 1 year career
look at matt cassell, matt moore, derek anderson

[dozer]

if only 5 teams are allowed to have qb's then yes.....................he won't be top 10 ever.............tooooooo da da da da da DUMB.

[dozer]

Give the defense a year to adjust to the ole ratard and then we'll see.

[Speedy88]

Top 10, not sure about top 5. There are a lot of really good QB's in the league. You see all these new good QB's, and it makes you think what the Jets see in Mark Sanchez. All these 2nd and 3rd year QB's show how great they can be in just 2 or 3 years, yet the Jets keep saying Sanchez is developing. The guy will never be a good QB. Go draft a new QB.

[Albert Pujols]

i like cam but he's 1-3, could not beat jay cutler, what has he done that makes you think he will be top five?

I didn't say he will, but I've heard it from people I have respect for.

He torched the Bears.

[KKoz9]

Give the defense a year to adjust to the ole ratard and then we'll see.

this ^^

[gryfyn1]

he might be a top 5 QB in the NFC south.....