Who will have the best career?

[MadCapper]

Between these 3 players....

2 Reds, 1 former Red.

Votto
Bruce
Hamilton

Well we need to know the players?

[MadCapper]

Well we need to know the players?

in the poll.

[mofome]

Between these 3 players....

2 Reds, 1 former Red.

Votto
Bruce
Hamilton

Thats a tough one. the os could have had votto and hamilton for bedard...

[MadCapper]

Thats a tough one. the os could have had votto and hamilton for bedard...

No f-ing way!?!?!

not even close... Hamilton by far

No f-ing way!?!?!

yeah but the O's are one of the worst teams at making trades. They dont know how to judge talent over there

[mofome]

No f-ing way!?!?!

votto, hamiton, and cueto i believe. We wanted bruce and went in another direction when they declined to make that deal.

[MadCapper]

cmon....

O's turned down Votto, Hamilton, AND Cueto?

How does their GM still have a job!

[MadCapper]

Votto (includng first AB tonight):

.286, 10 HR, 29 RBI, 26 R, 3 SB

[mofome]

cmon....

O's turned down Votto, Hamilton, AND Cueto?

How does their GM still have a job!

They wanted Bruce + for bedard...
Then they wanted kemp/Kershaw but would have settled for a package around those 2...
The deal they ended up with is one we won, but its still hard to believe we passed on that cinci deal.

Chris Tillman is the youngest pitcher in AA, i believe, and he has the best BAA...or close to it. Jones should turn out to be a good CF and the other players we got have some potential. Hopefully sherrill turns into a deadline deal guy and we get another prospect.

[ThreadKiller]

odds are on jay bruce.



-------------
Josh

[jjgold]

Hamilton

[Uncle Joe]

Votto

[MadCapper]

look at the results.

pretty cool so far.

[The HG]

Whoever doesn't get traded for the longest amount of time.

[zootiehead]

Hamilton is 27 and Bruce is 21.

[baconbrook]

Jay Bruce is a stud.

[Blister]

Blister says Jay Bruce and Blister is all ways right. Blister is out.

Hard to say. Josh Hamilton might be the best baseball talent to ever play the game. Will that translate into success? It sure is now. If he stays healthy there is no reason why he shouldn't be a first ballot HOF.

Sky's the limit for Bruce, though. Kid is 21 and is already one of the top 5 outfielders in the game.

[MadCapper]

Bruce,

Already a top 5 OF in the game?

After 2 starts?

Impressive!