depends on if he dies because he gains so much weight he explodes
Comment
McBa1n
SBR MVP
01-02-06
2642
#3
He's a tough call for me. I think he's been dogging it for more than a few years now - and compared to others in this era, I don't think he's ever been 'elite' for very long, outside of maybe 1 or 2 seasons. Borderline, for sure.
I think the 'really long/consistent' career stat players are kind of meh to me... The 'elite' players of every era really are the ones that deserve to be in the hall... Like a Jim Rice or a Dale Murphy.
Comment
madmaxx
SBR MVP
03-14-07
3289
#4
no chance in hell
Comment
mofome
SBR Posting Legend
12-19-07
13003
#5
yep.
Comment
AgainstAllOdds
SBR Hall of Famer
02-24-08
6053
#6
Originally posted by SBR_John
AAO = good dude. Buying you a drink in Vegas buddy.
Comment
TexansFan
SBR MVP
09-06-06
3367
#7
Not even close. Nowhere even close to close.
Comment
element1286
Restricted User
02-25-08
3370
#8
Nope.
Comment
Doc JS
SBR Hall of Famer
09-15-06
6885
#9
.261 lifetime batting avg. only hit .300 once in his career
never won an mvp
best defensive centerfielder since the Say Hey Kid
But Andruw is not an HOF'er...
Comment
2Pac
SBR MVP
12-12-07
1474
#10
No - he's an obvious cheater. OBVIOUS.
Comment
ChuteBoxe
SBR Hall of Famer
11-21-07
6885
#11
I vote no.
Comment
MadCapper
SBR MVP
01-27-08
4179
#12
How can some people say that a 10 gold glove CF with 500 homeruns has NO CHANCE at the hall!?
(assuming he hits 135 homeruns over the next 8 seasons)