Romo best qb in NFL

[element1286]

I think the argument for Big Ben can also be made. Remember though, just because a player is padded in the stat category doesn't mean that he's necessarily a great QB (look at Trent Green with the Chiefs). As of right now I could also see the argument that Eli isn't top 3 but I think by this time next year he will definitely be #3.

Eli needs to be consistent. It will be shown that Ben is the third best quarterback of his generation. And the greatest in Steeler's history.

[MJFtheGenius]

Eli lost for how many years???

That was romo's first full season

[Quebb Diesel]

the most polished passers in my opinion would be

1. manning
2. brady
3. palmer
4/5. a toss up between hasselbeck, mcnabb, brees, AND yes romo...and id almost take any of them over romo though b/c they have proven themselves year in and year out and also have won playoff games...romo can be arguably a top 5 qb today but i could easily fill him in with other qbs as well

[MJFtheGenius]

LOL!!!!

Hassleback and Mcnabb!!!!

Queb whatever respect i had for you as a knowledgable sports fan I have lost all.
Have you watched any football in the past 5 years, you are living in the past. Mcnabb can't play anymore and Hassleback is average

[element1286]

the most polished passers in my opinion would be

1. manning
2. brady
3. palmer
4/5. a toss up between hasselbeck, mcnabb, brees, AND yes romo...and id almost take any of them over romo though b/c they have proven themselves year in and year out and also have won playoff games...romo can be arguably a top 5 qb today but i could easily fill him in with other qbs as well

No Roethlisberger? I do like Mcnabb, it would be nice if he could stay healthy.

[MJFtheGenius]

and how you put Peyton over brady is a joke too

[Quebb Diesel]

those stats are misleading

Only that way becuase they had so many blowouts they were running the ball alot in the 4th quarter

But if you look at every close game or big game they had Romo threw the ball like 35 times plus

but look at the teams he threw 35+ attempts against...outside of vikings and the giants he shouldnt have thrown 35 passes anyway...he threw 11 of his 19 picks in those 35+ pass attempt games...against not so good pass defensive teams...im not saying romo is garbage...but he has definitely not proven to the league that he is hands down the best qb out there but def has potential of being a top 5 if he minimizes his arrant passes and quits locking in on TO every other pass...

[Quebb Diesel]

LOL!!!!

Hassleback and Mcnabb!!!!

Queb whatever respect i had for you as a knowledgable sports fan I have lost all.
Have you watched any football in the past 5 years, you are living in the past. Mcnabb can't play anymore and Hassleback is average

you are going to dog two former super bowl qb's?! i dont get it?

[MJFtheGenius]

you are going to dog two former super bowl qb's?! i dont get it?

Hassleback seems to be losing arm strengh.
Mcnabb simply can't play anymore anyone here in Philly will tell you that.

[Quebb Diesel]

and how you put Peyton over brady is a joke too

simply as a qb...i dont see why you wouldnt? of course anybody could put manning and brady as 1a and 1b, but when i compare the two i see peyton as a better overall qb...brady is amazing yes, but if you gave peyton new england's d in their super bowl runs could you not say peyton wouldve won just as many super bowls? and im not even a colts fan...i actually hate them...

[MJFtheGenius]

Well Romo was top 5 in MVP voting last year

take that for what you want

[MJFtheGenius]

Peyton is another numbers guy

chokecity

[Quebb Diesel]

Peyton is another numbers guy

chokecity

well until romo wins a playoff game/super bowl hell be chokecity too...

[element1286]

Peyton is another numbers guy

chokecity

Then what the hell is Romo? Peyton has a Superbowl, Romo doesn't even have a playoff victory.

[Quebb Diesel]

Well Romo was top 5 in MVP voting last year

take that for what you want

as far as i can remember brady received 49 votes and favre received the last 50th vote...so i dont see how theres a top five in mvp voting last year?

[MJFtheGenius]

He was on the ballot

[MJFtheGenius]

Then what the hell is Romo? Peyton has a Superbowl, Romo doesn't even have a playoff victory.

like I said before that was romo's first full season as a starter. if they do not go deep in the playoffs this year I will retract all this and agree he is a numbers guy and is a chokeartist.