Stats, WS Rings, Leadership, etc....
-
-
No, not even closeComment -
Im gonna say yes because he plays catcher, if he played any other position though he would just be an average ballplayer.Comment -
Comment -
I chose no, he is a good player, but hasent really done anything spectaclar...he might end up one, but right now, noOriginally posted by SBR_JohnComment -
-
True, but at this point, he's a "no". I'll never look back and say "Man, that Jorge Posada was one hell of a ballplayer." He won some rings and played on a historically potent offense which enabled him to boost his numbers a tad, but in my opinion he's not there yet. But yes, his numbers are going to be close when it's over.Comment -
If he played for the Reds, then no. But because hes a Yankee, and has rings, and plays catcher, then Yes. YES.Comment -
Posada has a career WARP around 80. Ted Simmons was in the high 90s and Joe Torre a bit above 100 and they weren't elected, although Posada did play on a bunch of championship teams. If he doesn't decline too badly and has a few more solid years like his past few, he should get in.Comment -
Won't get 2000 hits. Not that great of an average, decent amount of hr's. Probably won't get much more than 1000 rbi's.Comment -
hell no... lolComment -
No way JorgeComment -
Even as a Yanks fan I say no to this one. I don't even put Posada close to Munson and even he's borderline in my book. In order to be a hall of fame catcher you have to make your pitching staff better and I don't think Posada has done that.Comment -
No....It won't be even remotely close.....Comment -
He should be one of those guys that almost gets in but doesnt.
But he might get in cause he's a YankeeComment -
No.
Is Varitek?Comment -
Bunk, bunk, bunk, and more bunk. Jorge does not pass the "eye" test for the HOF.Originally posted by MadCapperComment
