Who would you rather have at QB in a big game.. Big Ben or Rodgers?

[thebertshow]

I would take Rodgers over Ben

[mike1814]

Rogers.

Big Ben gets too much credit for his defense winning games. He had two INT's and no TD's in the AFC championship game and some analysts are saying to look beyond the stats he had a great game. He did make some good plays I'll say. No doubt he's a good, tough QB but come on..

People here aren't truly answering the question. All things (and teams) being equal Rogers is the pick. Put Rogers on the Steelers and that would be freightening.

Trent Dilfer could win a Super Bowl with an awesome defense and good run game.

[zoso11871]

Ben!

[Landscaper]

Rodger's

[obamaismyuncle]

stupid question, this is Big Ben's 3rd super bowl and Rodgers didn't win his first playoff game till 2 weeks ago. I think Pitt will destroy GB by 10+.

[LChruscial85]

Rodgers is a great QB...but if you gotta choose...just base it on experience...Big Ben...and the majority of players on the Steelers have that much more over the Pack!

[LChruscial85]

Rogers. Big Ben gets too much credit for his defense winning games. He had two INT's and no TD's in the AFC championship game and some analysts are saying to look beyond the stats he had a great game. He did make some good plays I'll say. No doubt he's a good, tough QB but come on.. People here aren't truly answering the question. All things (and teams) being equal Rogers is the pick. Put Rogers on the Steelers and that would be freightening. Trent Dilfer could win a Super Bowl with an awesome defense and good run game.

If your gonna base something like that on Big Bens performance...Rodgers had a bad game against the Bears...and the Packers have an amazing Defense too... That interception he threw in the 2nd half right to Urlacher was a very bad throw. The only good thing about that is Rodgers made a TD saving tackle...Big Ben has proven time and time again to make big throws when he has to....don't say we aren't truly answering the question if we are saying Big Ben is a better big game QB and your aren't

[darren125]

Rodgers

[Raleigh77]

I'd take Aaron Rodgers

[RonPaul2008]

I'd rather have Steve Young in his prime.

[arnoldrothstein]

Is this a serious f\*\*\*ing question? Big ben in a land slide Rodgers is overrated as f\*\*k

[Stevedore]

stupid question, this is Big Ben's 3rd super bowl and Rodgers didn't win his first playoff game till 2 weeks ago. I think Pitt will destroy GB by 10+.

Destroy GB by 10+? Who's done that all year? NOBODY genius, GB hasn't been behind by more than 7 points in a game all year and you think they'll get blown? Put the bong away dude, you've had enough.

[Stevedore]

Is this a serious f\*\*\*ing question? Big ben in a land slide Rodgers is overrated as f\*\*k

If you like Ben fine, but Rodgers is overrated? 3 year starter, number #1 rated qb in the NFC and 3rd overall. Please explain genius?

[Lockitup1x]

Rather have Big Ben.

[illfuuptn]

Yeah ummmm Rodgers and it's not even close. Look at Ben's stats from last game. They were atrocious.

[HoldEmHook!!]

Ben is a big game player and untill Rogers proves he can lead a team in crunch time then Ben wins hands down......Green Bays Defense saved the day against Chicago with a pick-6.

[walshy83]

I would have to go with Big Ben here. Helluva qb in the playoffs, proven winner.

[GoCougs!]

I can't stand Ben. Total donkey.
I would pick him over most QB's just for the fact that he gets the job done.

[Jive]

Donovan McNabb isn't an option? I say Rodgers, although you have to give Ben credit for making plays at the big moments.

[delve_deeper]

Depends on the other team's defense.

[ebbearsfb1]

I guess illfuptn didn't watch... stats aren't everything... then again in the day of fantasy sports everyone is only worried about stats.... id say id take ben first then rodgers... both b4 peyton or brady

[k13]

Has Rodgers even won a big game yet?

[Brick]

go with rodgers the way hes been playing lately...nothing phases him