Should referees "let players play" in championship games?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SBR Lou
    BARRELED IN @ SBR!
    • 08-02-07
    • 37863

    #1
    Should referees "let players play" in championship games?
    I am always one that gets on officials about silly calls, excessive calls all year long, however, in a championship game I don't think you can let players clearly commit infractions without throwing a flag. I think you cut out the wishy washy crap, but flag the rest.

    Here's a collection of photos from a play in the FINAL DRIVE of SB XLII, which, if a flag is thrown, the game probably has an alternate ending... You tell me if there's HOLDING going on here....





















  • 2Pac
    SBR MVP
    • 12-12-07
    • 1474

    #2
    Dumb argument from crybaby Patriots fans with too much time on their hands. If they wanted to have some credibility, they would have to analyze pictures from every drive throughout the game.

    Holding can be called on every play in the NFL.
    Comment
    • 5 star bomb
      SBR Hall of Famer
      • 10-12-07
      • 5370

      #3
      Stupidest shit I have ever seen... obviously whoever the hell is crying about that has never played 1 snap of football in their life. Holding happens literally 95% of the plays.
      Comment
      • ipickwinners
        SBR MVP
        • 01-06-08
        • 3136

        #4
        lol 95% of the time? i dont think so.... 100% of the time a holding penalty can be called.
        Comment
        • SBR Lou
          BARRELED IN @ SBR!
          • 08-02-07
          • 37863

          #5
          I used the photos as an illustration of what I'm referencing. We can all agree clear holding took place, beyond that, we can also agree that the head official was in direct view of the infraction. His flag stayed in his backpocket.

          This isn't entirely about that play, it's more of an overall question, should officials "stay out" of championship games to the point where clearly blatant, game changing type infractions are ignored in the name of "letting the players play"?
          Comment
          • ShamsWoof10
            SBR MVP
            • 11-15-06
            • 4827

            #6
            Originally posted by 2Pac
            Dumb argument from crybaby Patriots fans with too much time on their hands. If they wanted to have some credibility, they would have to analyze pictures from every drive throughout the game.

            Holding can be called on every play in the NFL.
            Originally posted by 5 star bomb
            Stupidest shit I have ever seen... obviously whoever the hell is crying about that has never played 1 snap of football in their life. Holding happens literally 95% of the plays.
            Originally posted by ipickwinners
            lol 95% of the time? i dont think so.... 100% of the time a holding penalty can be called.
            Oh my god is that all you people do is repeat what you hear ??? Yeah you CAAAAN call holding on every play but NO there is not holding on every play... This is from people that watch too much sportscenter...

            Is that legit holding..? Yes of course it is... You'd have to think "BONES" has "D's" to not think it's holding...

            Comment
            • ipickwinners
              SBR MVP
              • 01-06-08
              • 3136

              #7
              u really are stupid, there truely is holding on every single play in the NFL
              Comment
              • SBR Lou
                BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                • 08-02-07
                • 37863

                #8
                Originally posted by ipickwinners
                u really are stupid, there truely is holding on every single play in the NFL
                Let me guess, you're an armchair QB too?
                Comment
                • ShamsWoof10
                  SBR MVP
                  • 11-15-06
                  • 4827

                  #9
                  Originally posted by ipickwinners
                  u really are stupid, there truely is holding on every single play in the NFL
                  No it's you who's stupid... Where did you three get that from..? What are the odds you three all at ANY POINT watch film on an offensive/defensive line at any level....? I would like SEER's opinion here not yours...

                  You guys don't know the differance between a screen pass and a screen porch... << I love that line...

                  Comment
                  • Thor4140
                    SBR Posting Legend
                    • 02-09-08
                    • 22296

                    #10
                    Originally posted by ShamsWoof10
                    . This is from people that watch too much sportscenter...

                    Been saying this for years bud. Why most guys lose handicapping. They take what sportcenter has to say as gospel as well as sportstalk radio.
                    Comment
                    • SBR Lou
                      BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                      • 08-02-07
                      • 37863

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Thor4140
                      Been saying this for years bud. Why most guys lose handicapping. They take what sportcenter has to say as gospel as well as sportstalk radio.
                      I agree with this, but sportstalk radio can be addictive at times. I do most of my searching for news related crap or injury stuff on the web at different news outlets, so the "spin" really doesn't seep in as much.
                      Comment
                      • jackpot269
                        SBR Posting Legend
                        • 09-24-07
                        • 12842

                        #12
                        No matter how they call them OK with me as long as its consistent. Big game or not both sides of the ball if its consistent its fair !! jmo!!!
                        Comment
                        • jackpot269
                          SBR Posting Legend
                          • 09-24-07
                          • 12842

                          #13
                          Originally posted by 2Pac
                          Dumb argument from crybaby Patriots fans with too much time on their hands. If they wanted to have some credibility, they would have to analyze pictures from every drive throughout the game.

                          Holding can be called on every play in the NFL.
                          I dont think crazyl is a Pats fan just saying!!!
                          Comment
                          • purecarnagge
                            SBR MVP
                            • 10-05-07
                            • 4843

                            #14
                            I'd say the patriots linemen did there fair share of holding they just sucked at it more as they gave up more sacks
                            Comment
                            • Willie Bee
                              SBR Posting Legend
                              • 02-14-06
                              • 15726

                              #15
                              Referees and umpires have the unenviable task of being expected to arrive at work on the first day and be perfect, then improve upon that from then on. Can't recall the MLB umpire who said that, but it's true. They should call a Super Bowl or World Series or Final Four or Stanley Cup the same way they call the opening game of the season, and in that manner is the only way they can really please everybody.
                              Comment
                              • Deuce
                                BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                • 01-12-08
                                • 29843

                                #16
                                Most championship games I like to see refs bury the whistles unless shit is blatant.
                                Comment
                                • SBR Lou
                                  BARRELED IN @ SBR!
                                  • 08-02-07
                                  • 37863

                                  #17
                                  Originally posted by Willie Bee
                                  They should call a Super Bowl or World Series or Final Four or Stanley Cup the same way they call the opening game of the season, and in that manner is the only way they can really please everybody.
                                  Bingo.
                                  Comment
                                  Search
                                  Collapse
                                  SBR Contests
                                  Collapse
                                  Top-Rated US Sportsbooks
                                  Collapse
                                  Working...