Both of these guys are legit insiders and know their shit, their good at what the do and have a lot of inside information. Its clear to everyone that these two guys are competitive and like to be right 100% of the time, but who exactly is better? They never seem to be on the same page and always have differing opinions. Mel Kiper is like the Wiley-old-veteran and Tod Mcshay is an up and coming analyst. I think that Mel Kiper is more knowledgeable and has better insight but i'm curious to see what the general consensus is. Most likely people have chose to pick one of the two guys to follow. Who is better at what they do and knows more shit?
-
-
After the article written by the sports agent in SI and the implications he puts on Kiper...Id go with McShay.Comment -
They both suck.
Exactly what experience does McShay have that makes him an "expert"? Oh yeah, ESPN created him.
If you want a real football guy who breaks down the draft-----the NFL Network's Mayock.
Mayock knows 1000x more football than either McShay or Kiper.Comment -
Both are complete dumbasses.Comment -
Mcshay for sure..Comment -
mel kiper is a fuken ass hole
...good dayComment -
Spend 5 minutes listening to Mayock and then compare it to Kiper/McShay.
You will never listen to Kiper and McShay again.Comment -
I'd love to see these two assclowns in the octagon... it would be the best slap fight ever!Comment -
I hate Kiper...Like Mcshay, but neither are super knowledgeable.Comment -
kiper knows his stuff.Comment -
kiper thought andre ware, akili smith and jamarcus russell would be hall of famers.
hes the brandon lang of draft picks.Comment
