More impressive: Halladay's perfect game or no-hitter?

[Illusion]

Have to go with the no hitter since it came in the post season. What do you guys think?

[Mikail]

Most impressive the fact it happened within months of the other.

[stealthyburrito]

no-hit.

postseason games will always hold ten fold the weight of any mlb regular season game.

[azn624]

definitely the no hitter in his first playoff start.

[Austin103]

First playoff start, playoff atmosphere, no hitter.

[hothandsmgee]

Considering he is only one of two to throw a no hitter in the playoffs, the no hitter.

[Roy Halladay]

Definitely the no-no. One walk away from a perfect game. Stakes were raised today gentelmen. And I delivered.

[Sunde91]

Definitely the no-no. One walk away from a perfect game. Stakes were raised today gentelmen. And I delivered.

Congratulations, Mr. Halladay.

[phLLyphan11]

No hitter simply from the fact that it's only been done twice. And the stakes are sooo much higher in the playoffs....And the Reds are actually good while the Marlins suck....and it was his first start in the postseason.....and the Marlins suck. God, the guy is just so good.

[Mikail]

Definitely the no-no. One walk away from a perfect game. Stakes were raised today gentelmen. And I delivered.

Nice first postseason appearance Gem Mr. Halladay.

[Kevy]

The No-Hitter

[FrozenMAN]

clearly shows why the reds BLOW and are overrated and will be swept outta the first round and do jack shit after having a solid season which is pretty commong for all dusty baker led teams.....LET'S GO GIANTS AND RANGERS!!!!

[jcubs55]

No hitter

[cobalt king]

hands down the no hitter, your first playoff game you do something for only the second time in history, unreal!

[thirtytwo]

i think Oswalt no-hits cincinnati too... dusty baker and his kindergarden will be an embarassment of 2010 playoffs...

[Marauders]

I agree with most here that the no hitter is more impressive.

[onlooker]

The no hitter today. Only 2nd player to do so in the playoffs and it was his first start. Wow!

[BigMattM]

Halladay is the greatest!

[Jonah]

I don't know about impressive, but maybe the perfect game was harder... Seems like a lot of guys can't hit worth crap in the post season, especially post season newbies.

[PlatinumBerg]

Beast!!!

[RollPlayer]

I guess i'm alone in thinking that a perfect game is better. A no no in the playoffs is definitely hard, but being perfect in a baseball game is almost impossible

[Tk Fo Sho]

Congrats Halladay

[kings12]

I would have to say the no-hitter strictly because it was done in the playoffs and due to all of the pressure expected of you to pitch well in that kind of atmosphere.

[zephyr]

No hitter in his first postseason start, and the team's first of these playoffs. Damn. That's icewater in the veins. Historic.

[krazey47409]

hallladay untouchable

[Bob Loblaw]

No hitter without a doubt. The only difference in the stat book was 1 measly walk that came on a 2 strike count. I need to watch it again but I thought there was a pitch in that at bat that could of easily been a strike or even a strike 3 called that wasn't called. I may be thinking of another at bat though. Either way, factor in the circumstances of a playoff game and his first playoff game after dominating the league for a decade and never getting a chance to show it in the postseason and this answer is easy. Hands down the best pitcher in baseball.

[Salamander]

Guy deserves to move up a couple of notches amongst the all time greats after this one.

[ytulavida]

.


Excellent game.

to Halladay.


.

[refrain87]

Halladay's a beast, glad he performed amazing tonight .

[rdo37]

He almost had the perfecto without the one walk...no hitter in your very first postseason game? Clutch. That's how you prove you're the best pitcher in baseball.

[pico]

no hitter

[thunderingherd23]

nothing was really hit hard......his first career postseason start....wow

[jjgold]

Playoff no hitter

[gafl]

No hitter. Opening game of the postseason.

[oiler]

Have to go with the no hitter since it came in the post season. What do you guys think?

besides him proving hes the best pitcher in baseball.no doubt the no hitter cause it happened when it really counts