Vick Just Might Be A Top 5 QB

[venice2222]

I'm sure the Eagles sign him to a big extension before season is over.

[slacker00]

He has respect also because he has been in slammer and blacks love that shit as it is part of their culture

Easy there, big fella. LMAO

[sportsfun]

today he was, tomorrow . . .

[slacker00]

1. McNabb
2. Vince Young
3. Josh Freeman
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Vick

[MoneyM1ke]

He's playing out of this world but not a top 5 Qb

[Fleeben]

1. McNabb
2. Vince Young
3. Josh Freeman
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Vick

what do you know, racist and stupid!

oh wait 'racist' covers both already

[Mac4Lyfe]

Vick is playing as good, if not better than any other QB in the league. He's making the right decisions, the right throws and leading his team to wins. Brady didn't do that last week. Neither did Favre, nor Manning in week 1. Don't forget that Vick took an Atlanta team with mediocre WR's to the NFC championship.

I think he's playing the best football in the league right now. He's hot as hell and making throws in tight spots. He has a cannon for an arm and is now mentally focused. He's a defenses worst nightmare.

[ttwarrior1]

lmao he played a terrible jacksonville, every qb has looked good against jacksonville and detroit. Just look at how much better favre was today.

Kolb would have as many td as vick and now he is being wasted away on the bench and wasting money as well.
If you really believe that the eagles would lose to detroit or jacksonville you would be an idiot . Almost every qb in the league would beat jacksonville and detroit.

[Naz18]

lmao he played a terrible jacksonville, every qb has looked good against jacksonville and detroit. Just look at how much better favre was today. Kolb would have as many td as vick and now he is being wasted away on the bench and wasting money as well. If you really believe that the eagles would lose to detroit or jacksonville you would be an idiot . Almost every qb in the league would beat jacksonville and detroit.

Every team in the league can beat detroit and jacksonville. Big deal, I even started vick in my Fantasy league. Had nothing to do with vick, it had to do, that they were playing jacksonville.

Favre threw 1 TD and 2 INT had a passer rating of 68.4

[ttwarrior1]

yeh but they won ,

[Extra Innings]

Here's always been good

[pico]

he is a great qb

[soli]

Vick looks real good and the difference is he has some good wide receivers

[GunShard]

I wanted Vick to be an Eagles starter last season.

[jjgold]

His arm strength is much better than I thought as his his foot speed.

It is some story, I hope them smash Wash this week

[sweethook]

i say hes just a halfback takin the snap hes no true gb - nuff said..

[will2survive]

he might get his money back by his great play.He's probably broke and playing for a good contract

[alka07]

right now vick are playing his best games

[will2survive]

6 tds ,0 int's 170 yards rushing-----he's going to amass 800-900 yards rushing------great comeback

[$Burm$]

no way vick is a top 5 qb in this league, I don't even think he would crack top 10. Brees, Rodgers, Manning, Rivers, Schuab.. I would even take Cutler over Vick, IMO..Cutler is having a great year, why isn't their love being shown for his bounceback season so far

[teecee]

has the ability of michael vick ever been questioned? character flaws aside, the man has always displayed immense talent and physical ability. very exciting to watch play football.

[ngates815]

has the ability of michael vick ever been questioned? character flaws aside, the man has always displayed immense talent and physical ability. very exciting to watch play football.

Eagles are my top team to watch with Colts as a very close 2nd.


If Kolb was in there, I wouldn't even bother turning on an Eagles game. I can't wait til Philly plays Chicago, so I can finally watch a whole game.

[SBR_John]

Not top 5 but maybe somewhere in the 9th to 12th slot. He is not a top 10 passer. He throws the short stuff good but on 3rd and 10 with the game on the line he is nearly the last NFL QB you want hitting a seam in a cover 2.

[donkdown]

yeh but they won ,

U get dumber by the word in this thread monkey.. Kolb is done!!! STFU about it. If u cant tell who the better qb is maybe u should quit gambling. Idiot!!! durr Vick played Det and Jax durrr!! U fck Eagles have a young team and a win on the road is a win on the road in this league. Stop hating before I come fck your girlfriend after I whoop your taco eating ass!!!

[ngates815]

Not top 5 but maybe somewhere in the 9th to 12th slot. He is not a top 10 passer. He throws the short stuff good but on 3rd and 10 with the game on the line he is nearly the last NFL QB you want hitting a seam in a cover 2.

But on 3rd and 3-6 he may be one of the top qb's you want in there.


I just watched the highlights from his game yesterday, and he was throwing the deep ball pretty good. And he THROWS the damn ball. Seems like every pass is a laser.

[EaglesPhan36]

Watching commments from week-to-week is hilarious. Can't wait for the first week Vick fails to live up to the hype everyone puts on him so that some jerkoff can start a "Vick is Over Rated Thread." The buildup for the Skins game is going to just be downright retarded, GUARANTEED. Vick has had the luxury of playing two very poor teams the last two weeks. I would say Washington will be his first test, but seeing them against the Rams - that is debatable. We really won't know how good Vick is until mid-October when the Iggles play Atlanta at home and Tennessee on the road followed by a bye week and then Indy at home. Those three games will tell you what you need to know.

Happy right now that my team is winning, but the hype is just stupid media-driven BS.

[biggie12]

Lets go Eagles!!!! can't wait for the skins game

[jjgold]

Vick will be the number 1 Jersey seller in no time, I will be watching game Sunday and I hope he smashes Wash

[brooks85]

this reminds me of his days in atlanta. People are blinded by his style of play. The big games he has seem to out way his consistent failures as a passer. Passing for 40 yard tds off your back foot is a good idea in Madden but not in the NFL. As soon as vick faces a legit team that forces him to stay in the pocket he is done for. Watch his preseason game against the bengals.

His numbers from sunday 17/31 against a porous D , ya that is top 5 QB alright. He is a good QB and fun to watch because of his threat to run but he will not carry any team through the playoffs.

[donkdown]

Vick will be the number 1 Jersey seller in no time, I will be watching game Sunday and I hope he smashes Wash

cmon Gold I wrote this yesterday!!!

[KKoz9]

If you need a qb with a 75 rating who'll lead the league in fumbles and getting sacked, you have you man.

enjoy couple good games a year.

BINGO!!!


All time passer ratings below up to and including week 1 this year. Of course this doesn't include his whole TWO games for the Eagles.





Rank Quarterback Passer Rating
1 Steve Young 96.8
2 Philip Rivers 96.2
3 Peyton Manning 95.5
4 Tony Romo 95.0
5 Kurt Warner 93.7
6 Tom Brady 93.4
7 Joe Montana 92.3
8 Drew Brees 92.1
9 Matt Schaub 91.9
10 Ben Roethlisberger 91.7
11 Chad Pennington 90.1
12 Daunte Culpepper 87.8
13 Carson Palmer 87.7
14 Jeff Garcia 87.5
15 Donovan McNabb 86.6
16 Brett Favre 86.4
17 Dan Marino 86.4
18 Trent Green 86.0
19 Jay Cutler 85.1
20 David Garrard 84.9
21 Rich Gannon 84.7
22 Marc Bulger 84.4
23 Jim Kelly 84.4
24 Mark Brunell 83.9
25 Roger Staubach 83.4
26 Matt Hasselbeck 83.1
27 Steve McNair 82.8
28 Brian Griese 82.7
29 Neil Lomax 82.7
30 Sonny Jurgensen 82.6
31 Len Dawson 82.6
32 Brad Johnson 82.5
33 Ken Anderson 81.9
34 Jake Delhomme 81.8
35 Bernie Kosar 81.8
36 Neil O'Donnell 81.8
37 Danny White 81.7
38 Jason Campbell 81.6
39 Troy Aikman 81.6
40 Dave Krieg 81.5
41 Randall Cunningham 81.5
42 Boomer Esiason 81.1
43 Warren Moon 80.9
44 Jeff Hostetler 80.5
45 Bart Starr 80.5
46 Ken O'Brien 80.4
47 Jeff George 80.4
48 Fran Tarkenton 80.4
49 Steve Beuerlein 80.3
50 Dan Fouts 80.2
51 John Elway 79.9
52 Tony Eason 79.7
53 Byron Leftwich 79.6
54 Elvis Grbac 79.6
55 Eli Manning 79.3
56 Chris Chandler 79.1
57 Mark Rypien 78.9
58 Jim Everett 78.6
59 Aaron Brooks 78.5
60 Phil Simms 78.5
61 Bert Jones 78.2
62 Johnny Unitas 78.2
63 Jim McMahon 78.2
64 Otto Graham 78.2
65 Kyle Orton 78.1
66 Jeff Blake 78.0
67 Bobby Hebert 78.0
68 Frank Ryan 77.6
69 Jim Harbaugh 77.6
70 Joe Theismann 77.4
71 Bob Griese 77.1
72 Jay Fiedler 77.1
73 Drew Bledsoe 77.1
74 Bill Kenney 77.0
75 Michael Vick 76.8
76 Erik Kramer 76.6
77 Jon Kitna 76.6
78 Gary Danielson 76.6
79 Doug Flutie 76.3
80 Stan Humphries 75.8
81 Wade Wilson 75.6
82 Steve Bartkowski 75.4
83 Ken Stabler 75.3
84 Scott Mitchell 75.3
85 Steve Bono 75.3
86 David Carr 75.2
87 Tim Couch 75.1
88 Norm Van Brocklin 75.1
89 Sid Luckman 75.0
90 Vinny Testaverde 75.0
91 Chris Miller 74.9
92 Don Meredith 74.8
93 Brian Sipe 74.8
94 Jake Plummer 74.6
95 Roman Gabriel 74.3
96 Gus Frerotte 74.2
97 Steve Deberg 74.2
98 Earl Morrall 74.1
99 Y.A. Tittle 73.6
100 Kerry Collins 73.5

[KKoz9]

1. McNabb
2. Vince Young
3. Josh Freeman
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Vick

What is this supposed to represent?

[ttwarrior1]

uh vick has played detroit and jacksonville folks and loaded with wr talent, even more talent then the colts and patriots wr's.

[D3 Mighty Ducks]

Guy was an average quarterback in Atlanta. The league will catch up to him.

Just average? The guy was a fuking beast one of the best scrambler Qbs ever to play the game. Name someone who was better at scrambling?

[KKoz9]

Just average? The guy was a fuking beast one of the best scrambler Qbs ever to play the game. Name someone who was better at scrambling?

Uh, running backs run better than him, that's who is supposed to run the ball.

See passer ratings several posts up. He was (is?) an average QB at best in Atlanta.