Seems like a lot of people think Mcnabb's best days are behind him. I still believe he can lead a team to the super bowl. I may be a little bias because he is my favorite NFL player but if you saw him the past couple weeks he is showing his speed and his knee doesnt seem to be bothering him as much. I think next year he is going to have a monster year. If Philly would just bring in a stud WR for Mcnabb watch out for Philly. I hope they decide to let him go I would love to see the Bears get him. I doubt that happens though..... What do you guys think of Mcnabb at this stage of his career?
-
-
i know mcnabb would be appreciated by the staff and fans in minn.Comment -
chicago is going to land him and they can be done with the grossman disasterComment -
McChoke STINKS!Originally posted by 5 star bomb
The man is STUPID, I remember when the reporter asked him if Owens makes him a better QB, his answer was NO!
McNabb is overrated and has choked in all the big games in his career except vs Atlanta in the NFC championship game and another overrated QB named Vick!
McChoke 1-3 in the NFC championship game
0-1 in the SB
What is his QB rating in those games?
Thats your answer!Comment -
Originally posted by Scorpion
did he choke on 4th and 21 vs gb?Comment -
Why point out two black quarterbacks?
You racist?
How bout Rex Grossman,Tony Romo, or Phillip RiversComment -
Originally posted by Scorpion
Besides Owens for 1 season please name me 1 legit #1 WR that the Eagles have had.... End of story. Mcnabb is not overratedComment -
Originally posted by 5 star bomb
what about fred-ex?
Comment -
Originally posted by 5 star bomb
How many legit WRs NE had when Brady won 3 super bowls?Comment -
WOW, is that highlight of his fukking career?Originally posted by mofome
If yes, then what more can I say?Comment -
Originally posted by Scorpion
Better overall team, much better defense and I would take Deion Branch over any of the Eagle Wr's in a secondComment -
Originally posted by mofomewhat about fred-ex?
Comment -
Originally posted by Scorpion
just an example vs your point. seemed like a pretty clutch play which is the opposite of 'choking'. i didnt make you say hes choked every big game but one.
Comment -
Originally posted by 5 star bomb
i rest my case.Comment -
Originally posted by mofome
That was Mike Sherman's choke. He did manage to survive a couple more seasons by letting his DC take the hit and get fired. Sherman was more to blame for GBs decline than any single person in the organization. Funny how Favre was taking all of the heat when it was Sherman's fault the whole time.
As for McNabb, his durability and heart has always been in question. His increasing in years won't help this issue. McNabb is certainly a top shelf NFL QB when healthy. He certainly deserves a job until he snaps his ACL and some young gun gets into the lineup keeps the job.Comment -
Mcnabb is playing in Philly next yearComment -
As a philly fan mcnabb is a joke. I hope he's gone next season. He was never accuracy man. This year he was no legs either. So what was he? Absolutely nothing,Comment -
Originally posted by slacker00
no doubt the packers have to stop that play, but mcnabb made a great pass. mcnabb has had a rough last couple seasons, but hes still a good player. hes a good friend of my uncles, so im a bit partial to him i guess. id like to see him in a more balanced offense....philly throws so often that i think it really limits hes chances of being as efficient as he could be. also, as has been noted, his wideouts have almsot always been awful.
i agree with just about everything you said. its nice to see someone disagree with something and not act like they're god trying to explain the ways of the world to a friendly ferret.
Comment -
Originally posted by Cee
Cee I like you man and usually respect your opinion but not in this case. Mcnabb gets treated like shit in Philly he needs to get the hell out of there and come to the Chi or somewhere else where he will be appreciated. He can still play manComment -
Sometimes two hearts don't dance to the same beat 5 starOriginally posted by 5 star bomb
I'd be happy to deal mcnabb. Philly fans get sick of seeing balls thrown into the ground or over peoples heads. He doesn't hit the WRs in stride so they get YAC. Just gets olds seeing the same thing all season. I'm not gonna say AJ feeley is better, but when he was in philly almost beat pats. And scored on offense.Comment -
Originally posted by CeeSometimes two hearts don't dance to the same beat 5 star
I'd be happy to deal mcnabb. Philly fans get sick of seeing balls thrown into the ground or over peoples heads. He doesn't hit the WRs in stride so they get YAC. Just gets olds seeing the same thing all season. I'm not gonna say AJ feeley is better, but when he was in philly almost beat pats. And scored on offense.
We will find out Cee.... I would love Mcnabb on the Bears!
Comment -
Originally posted by 5 star bomb
WINNER!!!
Name a legit #2 or #3 he's had, also...
His TE's are 'ok' and he makes them into pro bowlers. He's definitly the most under-appreciated and under-rated QB of this era.
Also, playing in Philly - the most unfairly treated.
I don't like him for 2 reasons - 1, he's consistently killed my packers and 2, 4th and 26 grr (GG Barnett and Sharper for blowing the coverage).Comment -
Originally posted by McBa1n
Not to pour salt into the wound but I thought it was 4th and 21? hahaha, i agree though man Mcnabb has been so under appreciated his whole careerComment -
Donovan was banged up this year but still a very good QB and better than most, he will turn any decent team into a winner.
Put him on Minny or Bears and they are big winners .Comment
